£16k legal bill blow as apprentice assessor’s £50k fine upheld

EPAO refutes Ofqual allegations that the company deliberately breached rules for financial gain

EPAO refutes Ofqual allegations that the company deliberately breached rules for financial gain

Ofqual has stood by its decision to fine an apprenticeship assessment organisation that challenged a £50,000 penalty – and lumped additional legal costs of almost £16,000 on top.

Qualifications for Industry (QFI) owner Richard McClelland had vowed not to pay the charge and shut down the firm after claiming the regulator forced him out of the apprenticeships market.

He disputed the fine when it was issued in October but Ofqual’s internal enforcement panel upheld the decision this week.

QFI, a specialist construction end-point assessment organisation, became dormant in March after surrendering Ofqual recognition following a six-month probe into its capacity and delivery.

Ofqual claimed QFI breached a special condition imposed in 2021 which ruled no more than 200 learners could be registered to take its qualifications at any one time, and a maximum of 200 learners could take assessments in any 12-month period.

QFI did not dispute volumes were breached but alleged the regulator misled staff into believing the special condition had been lifted. 

The company also argued the 200 cap only applied to the qualifications and apprenticeships it first gained recognition for, not the many other courses it was recognised for following later expansion requests.

Ofqual reviewed further representations in December but ruled QFI’s “non-compliance” was “deliberate” – the company allegedly chose not to cap the number of registered learners “due to the impact compliance would have on its profitability”.

The enforcement panel said there was “no proper basis for QFI to presume a decision to approve the expansion request meant the special condition had been lifted or varied, in the absence of any notification from Ofqual”.

It added the panel “remains of the view that QFI either wilfully and knowingly breached the special condition, or was grossly negligent if it in fact assumed at any stage the special condition no longer applied”.

McClelland had accused Ofqual of using QFI as a “sacrificial lamb” after the notice to fine revealed the enforcement panel had considered reducing the £50,000 fine in light of QFI’s decision to surrender recognition. But the regulator decided this was not “appropriate” as its “fining power” would be “less of a deterrent if awarding organisations believed they could operate in a non-compliant manner and surrender recognition to avoid a monetary penalty”.

This week’s judgment revealed Ofqual has also charged QFI legal costs of £15,846, taking its total bill to £65,846.

McClelland told FE Week: “For reasons unknown to me, Ofqual forced QFI out of business, then after the fact attempted to justify doing so. QFI has refuted all allegations made by Ofqual. 

“Now after Ofqual has concluded its internal process we will take advice on the independent legal options available to us.”

Latest education roles from

Executive Director of Finance – Moulton College

Executive Director of Finance – Moulton College

FEA

Director of Governance – HRUC

Director of Governance – HRUC

FEA

Principal and CEO

Principal and CEO

Hills Road Sixth Form College

Senior Quality Officer

Senior Quality Officer

University of Lancashire

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

Funding Is Flowing, Demand Is Rising — It’s Time for FE to Deliver on Green Skills

As the UK races toward net zero, the government says it wants to back 2 million green jobs by...

Advertorial
Sponsored post

Helping every learner use AI responsibly

AI didn’t wait to be invited into the classroom. It burst in mid-lesson. Across UK colleges, learners are already...

Advertorial
Sponsored post

Supporting the UK’s Transport Decarbonisation Plan Through Skills

The UK Government’s Decarbonising Transport: A Better, Greener Britain strategy sets a legally binding path towards a net-zero transport...

Advertorial
Sponsored post

Project power: ASDAN expands its qualifications portfolio

From 2026, ASDAN’s planned Foundation and Higher Project Qualifications will sit alongside its Extended Project Qualification[CM1] , creating a complete...

Advertorial

More from this theme

Ofqual

New ‘honesty’ rules for awarding organisations kick in from December

Awarding organisations required to act with honesty and integrity or face fines

Anviksha Patel
Ofqual

Awarding body fined £15k for ‘serious’ conflict of interest failures

The company shared an office and staff with one of its test centres

Josh Mellor
Ofqual

Ofqual probe finds exam extra time figures wrong for years

'We are correcting the record as soon as possible', regulator says

Lydia Chantler-Hicks
Ofqual

Ofqual raps apprenticeship assessor over rogue pass results 

The awarding body breached the regulator's rules, but won't face sanctions

Josh Mellor

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *