Failing colleges that merge ‘can expect’ Ofsted monitoring visit

Grade three or four colleges that merge can expect to receive a monitoring visit before their first full inspection, Ofsted has confirmed today.

The clarification, which applies to mergers from January 2018 onwards, follows criticism that poor-performing colleges had been able to get away without any Ofsted scrutiny following a merger.

According to the FE and skills inspection handbook, updated today, a “newly merged college will normally receive a monitoring visit before the first full inspection if the overall effectiveness grade of one or more of the predecessor colleges was requires improvement or inadequate”.

The exceptions to this are where “the merged college has already received a support and challenge visit” or the merger “took place before January 2018”.

The move follows criticism from education select committee chair Robert Halfon, who accused Ofsted in August of allowing mergers to be an excuse for turning a blind eye to failure.

He demanded the inspectorate “monitor all failing providers” regardless of their merger status, after an FE Week investigation uncovered an example of an institution formed through the merger of a double grade four and a grade three college that had yet to receive a monitoring visit a year post-merger.

Following the area reviews of post-16 education and training, which ended in March last year, newly-merged colleges are now given up to three years before they receive a full inspection.

A monitoring visit could be carried out at “any reasonable time” to a college post-merger, according to the handbook – but in practice this hasn’t happened.

FE Week’s investigation found that just two colleges had received a monitoring visit following a merger. One of these involved two colleges previously rated ‘requires improvement’, which the other involved a grade four and a grade two college.

Colleges that could expect to receive a monitoring visit under the new policy include Trafford College, which merged with Stockport College in April – just a month after Stockport was rated ‘inadequate’ for the third time in five years.

Likewise, New City College, which merged with grade three Epping Forest College in August, will fall under the scope of the new policy, as will Stockton Riverside College, which joined forces with grade four Redcar and Cleveland College in the same month.

In an expert piece for FE Week in July, the education watchdog’s deputy director for FE, Paul Joyce, insisted that “merging with another college is certainly not a route to avoiding inspection” and that “we are monitoring colleges that merge very closely”.

All new apprenticeship standards to be introduced by August 2020

The government has committed to introducing all new apprenticeship standards in time for August 2020, rather than “by 2020” as previously stated.

Plans to stop funding old apprenticeship frameworks and ensure providers were only delivering new Trailblazer standards were first announced in October 2013, with the frameworks initially planned to end in 2017/18.

However, the government’s ‘2020 vision’ apprenticeship document, released in December 2015, pushed this deadline back and planned instead for “a migration from apprenticeship frameworks to standards over the course of the parliament, with as much of this to take place by 2017/18 as possible.”

Three waves of frameworks have so far been switched off, but earlier this year the Education and Skills Funding Agency announced it would not be closing any further frameworks until 2020.

“By 2020, we expect that employers and providers will have completed the transition, and that all starts will be on standards, so all frameworks will be withdrawn to new starts at that point,” the guidance said.

However, “by 2020” has now morphed into August 2020 at the earliest, after the Treasury released a press release today on changes to apprenticeships.

This included £5 million for the Institute for Apprenticeships to introduce new standards and update existing ones.

“The government will discontinue the old frameworks so that all new apprenticeships will be on the same higher-quality standards by the start of the 2020/21 academic year,” it said.

According to the most recent apprenticeship framework delivery list, published on September 12, 86 frameworks have been withdrawn so far. Two more have withdrawal dates listed – level four public relations (January 1, 2019) and level five care leadership and management (December 31, 2018).

To date, 124 frameworks remain without a withdrawal date.

EuroSkills 2018: Russia tops medal table

The Russian Federation reigned supreme at EuroSkills 2018 after their team claimed nine golds, eight silvers, two bronzes and 10 medallions of excellence in Budapest.

Following up in second place was Austria while France finished third (full table below).

Russia, which is hosting next year’s WorldSkills competition in Kazan, took 37 young people to compete in Hungary – the largest team out of any competing nation.

They won top podium spots in mobile robotics, welding, mechanical engineering design CAD, graphic design, visual merchandising, web development, ICT specialists and hotel receptioning.

Austria took 32 competitors and won four golds, 12 silvers, two bronzes and nine medallions of excellence. Their gold medals were achieved in automobile technology, plumbing and heating, painting and decorating, and concrete construction.

France’s 25 competitors won three golds, three silvers, six bronzes and 10 medallions of excellence. They were announced Europe’s best skilled nation in wall and floor tiling, heavy truck maintenance and hairdressing.

EuroSkills 2018 came to a close on Saturday night after three days of brutal competition.

Twenty eight European countries competed in 35 official skills. Over 100,000 spectators were said to have visited the competition, being held at the Hungexpo arena, over its duration.

Flying the flag for Team UK was 22 individuals. WorldSkills UK boss Dr Neil Bentley had given the team a target of a top 10 finish in the overall medal table.

And they achieved just that.

They finished joint ninth with Sweden. Beauty therapist Holly-Mae Cotterell claimed gold, while bronze medals went to mechatronics duo Danny Slater and Jack Dakin, mechanical engineering CAD competitor Ross Megahy, and hairdresser Gavin Jon Kyte.

Team UK also claimed seven medallions of excellence.

“This is a fantastic result for Team UK and the country as a whole,” said Dr Bentley.

“We were gunning for a top ten position and we got it.

“These brilliant young people – training and preparing them to be among the very best across Europe – are the UK’s new generation of high flyers.”

An FE Week souvenir supplement about EuroSkills Budapest will be published this week, in partnership with Pearson.

FE Week is proud media partner of WorldSkills UK and Team UK.

Chancellor set to announce apprenticeship levy changes

The Chancellor, Philip Hammond, is set to announce that the annual apprenticeship levy transfer facility will rise from 10 to 25 percent.

In a speech at the Conservative Party Conference later this morning, Mr Hammond will also say that he will consult with businesses about further changes to the levy from 2020, following the slow take up and employer criticisms.

As reported in FE Week, large employers used just 10 percent of their levy funds in its first year since launching in May 2017, and monthly starts figures continue to be well below pre-levy levels.

The Conservative Party Manifesto in 2017 committed to “allow large firms to pass levy funds to small firms in their supply chain”, a policy which was introduced in May 2018.

The online Apprenticeship System for levy paying employers when launched allowed for up to 10 percent of annual funds to be shared with up to one employer and has since been expanded to unlimited receiving employers.

FE Week understands that since the policy was introduced six months ago, the take-up has been very low, despite employer groups lobbying heavily for the flexibility.

A spokesperson for the Conservative Party said the increase from 10 to 25 percent available for levy transfer from April 2019 comes alongside a commitment to “expanding the apprenticeships available”, as well as “kick-off the first stage of the Government’s engagement process seeking views on the flexibility and development of the Apprenticeship Levy.”

Mr Hammond will say the changes form part of a “new” £125 million package to support learning and and fuel productivity.

Mr Hammond’s speech will take place during the 10:00 to 12:30 session at the Conference at Birmingham’s NEC. Follow @FEWeek for live updates of the speech.

Six ways technology can boost productivity in FE

The further education sector plays an important role in England’s education system. In 2017/18, the country’s 266 colleges provided education and training to 300,000 apprentices, 600,000 young people aged 16 to 18, and 1.4 million adults.

However, it has also received an average 30 per cent funding cut from 2009 to 2019 and staffing levels which have slumped by 20,000 since 2010. What’s more, across the UK, the FE estate structure is changing, with a shift towards regional colleges which have strong links with each other, independent providers and industry.

Simply put, colleges are under immense pressure to deliver high-quality education with dwindling resources – they suffer more than any other stage of education. So how can our FE establishments reshape to be more productive and financially stable, while also providing an excellent learning experience that produces a workforce with the skills required to help the UK economy thrive post-Brexit and beyond? The answer lies in digital transformation.

The tools are out there to not only reimagine productivity from automating processes but also by enabling educators to rethink the way they work. For example, by choosing an integrated learner Management Information System (MIS) such as Advanced’s ProSolution, FE providers can quickly and responsively manage applications and enquiries, learner enrolment, registers, timetables, examinations, reporting and oversee the production of Individualised Learner Records (ILRs). These tools can unleash a new era of collaboration – as well as competition – between FE providers, where the most successful organisations will be those that use technology to facilitate smooth and successful partnerships between themselves, students and employers.

Easing the burden of Ofsted  

While accurate and ongoing self-assessment is crucial for continued improvement in teaching and training delivery, Ofsted Inspection is one area that continues to cause FE establishments a big headache.

Ofsted’s latest Annual Report revealed that more than 80 per cent of teachers say inspections create ‘unacceptable burden’, with four fifths of teachers stating that Ofsted inspections create additional work. So how can productivity be improved in this area?

Alongside automating dozens of previously manual processes, feedback from colleges indicate that our ProSuite helps to support compliance, providing a very reliable audit trail. For example, this proved invaluable when, in September 2016, just five months after rolling out the software, Grimsby Institute of Further & Higher Education started preparing the data for its next Ofsted inspection.

The Institute uses ProAchieve to gain the vital information that all FE colleges and all types of private training providers need to improve learner and organisation performance, whilst at the same time ensuring they remain compliant and prepared for Ofsted with the ever-changing and demanding government and inspection standards.

Ricky Coxon, Executive Director of Information Services at Grimsby Institute, said: “We knew we were doing an outstanding job with regards to learner progress, attainment and attendance – and Advanced’s solution helped us showcase this. Teachers and support staff could focus on any areas of weakness and put in place improvement plans to instigate change for positive outcomes. When we pulled it all together, our data looked very strong. We found we were six per cent above the national average for 16-18 year olds, and above in almost all other areas, too.”

By combining technology solutions, staff were able to access higher quality student data and work more efficiently – all of which helped the college to gather important evidence required for the inspection. Impressively, Grimsby Institute won the highly coveted ‘outstanding’ rating from Ofsted – held by less than one per cent of the general FE colleges in England.

This shows first hand how data can help bring together hundreds of staff to deliver positive outcomes. Over 95 per cent of all further education colleges in England use Advanced ProSuite, with 25 per cent of customers reporting that they feel “well prepared” for Ofsted Inspections after implementing the software. Imagine the impact on British teaching and learning if all educational institutions embraced technology and put data at the heart of their insight.

Six key areas where technology could boost productivity in FE

Increasing efficiency when it comes to managing data for Ofsted inspections is just one area that technology can help increase productivity in FE. It can also reshape and personalise learning, boost productivity in the staff room, and improve strategic and operational decision making, particularly around teaching, learning support, and curriculum design. It can:

  1. Speed up administration and reporting, freeing up staff to focus on boosting student outcomes

Standard procedures such as student enrolment, completion, transfer or withdrawal can now be done in minutes. As a result, 70 per cent of institutions benefit from time-savings through acquiring the ProSuite, with 43 per cent of customers saving two or more hours per day after implementing one of Advanced’s solutions. Grimsby Institute saved time on approximately 240,000 enrolments, completions, transfers and withdrawals during 2016/2017 and became nearly 200 per cent more efficient on these tasks – the equivalent of freeing up 11 people – allowing staff to focus on improving student outcomes and boosting college operations.

  1. Boost learner outcomes

Integrated software like Advanced’s ProMonitor is key for teaching staff to track learners. It has modules designed for a range of users to access individual learner data, to write reports and to ease the administrative burden of marking. Holding a centralised collection of key learner details, the system makes it easier to raise, track and follow up on comments and understand your learners. The email integration can notify those who need to know, keeping everyone in the loop. Each learner can also have their induction and meetings recorded, building a detailed picture of them. This is especially useful in cases where learners need additional support, or become at risk, allowing teachers/FE institutions to create actions plans to reduce learners risk status. It can also be customised to design multiple individual learner plans.

  1. Improve transparency

Alongside the ability to automate dozens of previously manual processes, technology solutions can also support compliance, providing a reliable audit trail. If the data is questioned, the processes are so transparent that it’s easy for colleges to see exactly who entered the data, find the source of that data and quickly rectify it.

  1. Reveal trends and highlights areas of weakness

By integrating systems, such as finance and HR, student information can be kept up-to-date centrally, providing a single real-time view of student data across the college, and delivering increased confidence in the analysis and trends that are revealed. Tools such as ProObserve help staff streamline lesson observations so they can focus efforts where needed, resulting in greater learner progress across the board.

  1. Show real-time information in one place

Improving outcomes, measuring progression and retaining learners are the main goals for FE organisations. Having the right information available is key to keeping learners on track and ensuring they meet their potential. With most college data tied up in multiple systems, the process of pulling it all together is manual and laborious, using up time that could be better spent teaching. A dashboard solution, such as Advanced’s ProMetrix, can help provide valuable insight to guide a retention strategy, monitor students’ progress, assess course effectiveness, direct decisions and resource allocations. Some 83 per cent of customers believe the ProSuite allows them to effectively analyse the success of courses and departments for continuous improvement.

  1. Increase successful interactions with employers and prospective students

FE colleges and training providers face significant challenges in terms of maximising access to employers and stakeholders whilst contributing to the government’s target of achieving three million apprenticeships by 2020. ProEngage is a specialist CRM solution, designed for the FE market that can manage and help to increase successful interactions with employers and prospective students.

Apprenticeships: training providers need to get a handle on data

The Government recently announced that training providers will be asked to log apprentices’ off-the-job training hours to prove that the minimum funding requirement is being met. A new data field for Individual Learner Records (ILR) has been designed to help providers demonstrate compliance. Data must be recorded monthly and contribute to each learner’s full ILR.

Further guidance on the new field explains that it should record the “cumulative total of actual off-the-job training delivered to date, to the individual apprentice, in the academic year by the training provider”.

While having the right information available is key to keeping learners on track and ensuring they meet their potential, training providers argue that such processes are heavily labour intensive, taking up hours of admin. There is a smarter way. Advanced’s solution, ProAchieve, gives training providers easier access to the vital information they need around learner achievement.

By replicating a variety of ESFA and Ofsted reports, ProAchieve enables training providers to see clearly how well they are performing across year groups and whether they are on track. They can view learning aims and learner data from the ILR, as well as funding data from the Funding Information Suite (FIS) and Provider Financial Report (PFR) files. Using ProAchieve means they can also easily look up values such as demographics and learner details, plus use the extensive data filtering functionality to highlight key information to facilitate the drive to improve performance.

Implementing integrated systems from one supplier like this is a simple way to deliver the efficiencies that all training providers are seeking.

 

How technology made Aylesbury College more productive

Aylesbury College, part of Buckinghamshire College Group, needed to simplify its student administration, making it more efficient, so that staff could spend more time focusing on learners and their education.

The college was already using ProAchieve to analyse student retention and achievement, and ensure it was meeting targets. On the back of this success, it implemented Advanced’s MIS solution to make it easier to centralise, maintain and report on data. This would enable student enrolment, registration, timetables and examinations to be managed more productively.

Using the software suite meant all the college’s systems could work immediately as one cohesive whole. This meant teachers could take registration on different devices, including mobile, with the data immediately available online. With lesson attendance a key indicator of student success, the college could immediately take appropriate action for any students who are absent. It also afforded them the time to give greater care to their ‘looked after’ and ‘safeguarded’ students.

The system has also reshaped the college’s ability to take a holistic view of all the components in its study programme, linking the data and giving a single view of each student. For the first time, the college can tie attendance figures together with learning, student programmes and target grades, and has seen a marked improvement in student achievement as a direct result.

Fiona Morey, Deputy Principal of Buckinghamshire College Group, commented: “We wanted to integrate all our systems, and the solutions within the suite now communicate seamlessly with each other.”

Following Aylesbury’s merger with Amersham and Wycombe College, the amalgamated systems can maximise the benefits and efficiencies that the college was looking to achieve. With all information in one place, the college can easily analyse vital data so that it is making informed decisions to ensure its learners get the best possible outcomes. Staff across all sites have streamlined access to crucial data, with dashboards showing a real-time view of learner attendance and progress. As a result, the college is now agile enough to respond to student information with speed and accuracy. Implementing ProMonitor, to further help gauge student success, will be the last piece of the jigsaw.

“ProSolution is simple, powerful and has a huge impact on the efficiency of our organisation, helping us to monitor and analyse our students’ activity, retention and achievement so that we can continue to evolve and deliver an outstanding academic experience.”

Reimagine your goals from a new perspective, and gain the time to rethink, recharge and reshape your college. Find out more today

If you want to find out more about how we support 95% of FE colleges in England each year, click here.

 

 

EuroSkills 2018: ‘Awesome’ finish to competitions for Team UK

It’s been a tiring and testing week but Team UK are feeling “amazing” and “awesome” to have today finished competitions at EuroSkills 2018.

Hairdressing competitor Gavin Jon Kyte, who works and trains at Reds Hair Company in Herefordshire, had huge support from friends and family throughout his journey in Budapest.

“I didn’t even know my friends and family were stood there but to see them when I finished was awesome,” he told FE Week.

“I’m quite happy with what I’ve done but it is a waiting game now and see what happens tomorrow.

“I completed six tests – colouring, cutting, men’s and women’s hair, perming and bridal hair.

“I gave it all my hardest and the best I could and we’ll see where we can go from there. It was a fantastic experience.”

Holly-Mae Cottterell (pictured above), Team UK’s beauty therapist who’s also from Reds Hair Company, felt great when that final claxon went.

“I’m feeling amazing, pretty tired as well and these three days have been stressful but so worth it,” she said.

“I did the best I could and couldn’t ask any more from myself. That’s all I wanted, to give my maximum effort and that’s what I did.”

Collette Gorvett, who has gone from working in a burger bar in Swansea to The Ritz since taking part in the WorldSkills process, said:“Overall it has gone okay but we’ll see tomorrow night.

“My first day was in fine dining and then I moved on to the bar section and my final day was bistro for casual dining.”

Asked if she was phased by the thousands of spectators watching on, Collette replied:  “I didn’t notice anyone looking at me I was so concentrating on the task and making sure I was doing everything with a smile and confidence.”

She said she’s “up against a tough couple of competitors” and her “fingers are crossed for everybody”.

Thomas Lewis, who was chosen over his twin brother in the same skill during Squad UK to compete in Budapest, described to FE Week how he was feeling after the final day.

“I feel good and well happy that I finished the job, feeling knackered as well,” he said.

“I’m happy with what I done, a couple of things I would have changed but I tried my best and give it everything I could.”

Matthew Barton, who competed in plumbing and heating and is from Kendal College, told FE Week he was feeling “great but knackered” after completing his tasks.

“Nationals was pretty mad but this was at another level, it has been a good test,” he said.

“It’s made it a hell of a lot better with the team just having them around and the squad leaders they’ve been so much help, it’s been great.

“Tomorrow I want to relax and hopefully I can get some sort of medal.”

And Highbury College web designer Lewis Newton was ecstatic with his experience.

Tomorrow night will be the closing ceremony of EuroSkills 2018 where we’ll find out which of Team UK’s 22 competitors finished in the top three in their disciplines.

FE Week is proud media partner of WorldSkills UK and will be covering the event live.

You beauty! Team UK wins gold at EuroSkills 2018

Team UK is celebrating tonight after competitors bagged one gold and three bronze medals to retain its top-10 position at EuroSkills.

The team finished in ninth place overall when these successes were combined with its medallion of excellence haul of seven.

Picking up Team UK’s gold was Holly-Mae Cotterell (pictured), who was voted Europe’s best beauty therapist.

She also won Team UK’s Best of Nation award.

The 20-year-old, who works and trains at Reds Hair Company in Herefordshire,  told FE Week after completing the competition yesterday that she was feeling “amazing”.

And she felt just as amazing after claiming gold.

Holly celebrated gold at a sparkling closing ceremony in front of thousands of spectators tonight at the Papp László Budapest Sportaréna, which was streamed live for the world to watch.

Team UK’s bronze medallists included mechatronics duo from Toyota Danny Slater and Jack Dakin.

They were lost for words following their success.

Mechanical engineering CAD competitor Ross Megahy from New College Lanarkshire also picked up a bronze.

And hairdresser Gavin Jon Kyte, who is also from Reds Hair Company, was “buzzing” to also come third in his skill.

Medallions of excellence were awarded to: ICT specialists Cameron Barr and Shane Carpenter; cooking competitor Nicolle Finnie; florist Elizabeth Newcombe; welder Scott Kerr; plumbing and heating competitor Matthew Barton; restaurant services competitor Collette Gorvett; and joiner Christopher Caine.

Dr Neil Bentley, chief executive of WorldSkills UK, said: “This is a fantastic result for Team UK and the country as a whole. We were gunning for a top ten position and we got it.

“These brilliant young people – training and preparing them to be among the very best across Europe – are the UK’s new generation of high flyers.”

He added that Budapest was a “litmus test” to see how the UK might fare when it leaves the European Union next year.

“We had an amazing result and the team worked incredibly hard, but we can’t be complacent,” said Dr Bentley.

“Other countries across Europe are investing heavily in skills development, and we need to ensure we don’t fall behind.

“Governments, employers and the education sector must embrace this success and use the energy and momentum generated here to inspire to help propel economic growth and productivity.”

Having triumphed through regional heats, a national final, Team UK selection process and months of intensive training, the 22 young trades people spent three days in gruelling competition at the 10th  EuroSkills finals beginning Wednesday, September 26.

They were among more than 500 other competitors from 27 other nations, who are specialists in 35 different skills from hairdressing to heavy truck maintenance, and plumbing to mechatronics.

Keep an eye out for FE Week’s souvenir supplement covering TeamUK’s journey to EuroSkills Budapest 2018, published next week in partnership with Pearson.

EuroSkills 2018 Budapest: watch the closing ceremony LIVE

The 10th EuroSkills will draw to a close tonight after 28 countries completed three gruelling days of competition.

A closing and awards ceremony will be streamed live from Budapest from 6.30pm BST and finish at 8.30pm where we will find out how Team UK performed.

Representing the UK was 22 young trades people who competed against 500 other competitors from around Europe in skills ranging from mechanical engineering CAD to cooking.

Tonight’s ceremony will be held at the biggest sporting complex in Hungary, Papp László Budapest Sportaréna.

Up for grabs tonight are gold, silver and bronze medals for the top three competitors in each skills. Competitors will be given a medallion of excellence if they reach the international standard in their skill.

Watch the closing ceremony live here.

FE Week is proud to be the official media partners for Team UK and WorldSkills UK.

 

Revealed: DfE damning investigation into 3aaa

Crisis-hit Aspire Achieve Advance was given a £7 million apprenticeships contract increase two years ago despite an investigation that found dozens of funding and success rate “overclaims”, FE Week can reveal.

In recent weeks the apprenticeship giant has come under heavy scrutiny after its co-founders resigned and the Education and Skills Funding Agency suspended it from recruiting apprentices in the midst of a government investigation.

Now, FE Week has discovered that the training provider, better known as 3aaa, was subject to a separate investigation by the ESFA in 2016 – which is understood to have resulted in the company paying back a substantial six figure sum.

This raises further questions whether too much money is going to larger providers

Auditing firm KPMG was called in following claims by a whistleblower about non-compliance with funding rules.

‘Project vanilla’, as it was code named, was treated with “high confidentiality” and is only known by a select few people at 3aaa and the Department for Education.

The report has now been leaked to FE Week (read it in full here).

The whistleblower claims included: incorrect start dates resulting in failure to reach minimum duration; incorrect use of “break in learning” status which is inflating success rates; apprentices with long periods without learning activity.

The probe found dozens of “errors which support the allegations or which have an impact on funding of success rates”.

All monthly payments to 3aaa were stopped during the investigation, but resumed when it was concluded, at which point the provider was then rewarded with a £7 million increase to its in-year allocation.

MP Robert Halfon, a former skills minister and current chair of the education select committee, expressed concern after FE Week showed him the findings.

“Clearly 3aaa was allowed to expand their apprenticeship provision very quickly and the funding investigation in 2016 raises significant questions,” he said.

“Apparently a further £7 million was passed over to 3aaa after the investigation highlighted concerns.

“In light of the Learndirect ‘too big to fail’ debacle, this raises further questions whether too much money is going to larger providers.

“I will be calling for reassurances that the DfE/ESFA acts swiftly and in the interest of protecting public funds and particularly in safeguarding apprentices.”

KPMG “primarily” held discussions with 3aaa owners Peter Marples and Di McEvoy-Robinson as well as the provider’s resources director at the time, Lee Marples, during the investigation.

They sampled 663 apprentice records. The findings included apprentices not completing their minimum duration of 366 days; recorded as being on a “break in learning” when they should have been withdrawn; and where there was no evidence of learning for more than six months.

Instances were also found where “documents such as individual learning plans, enrolment/applications forms, and apprenticeship and learning agreements were incomplete”, including dates and signatures missing. Investigators also found some documents, “mainly the enrolment forms”, were missing from the learner files and for 87 apprentices their signature was dated an average of 108 days after the start date in the data.

The investigation report also detailed where the “provider confirmed that funding had been over-claimed”, such as for recording withdrawals in the wrong period and for functional skills qualifications that had been “deleted” from the data “as the provider was informed that the learner was no longer required to complete these learning aims”.

The report states that the ESFA should consider the “funding and success rate impact”.

The investigation report does not quantify the value of any over or under-claims, but FE Week understands 3aaa had a substantial six figure sum deducted from subsequent payments.

“We have not identified any evidence of deliberate circumvention of funding rules by the provider,” the investigators said.

A spokesperson for 3aaa said the provider could not comment on the report, due to confidentiality agreements.

The DfE said: “We do not comment on any investigations, ongoing or otherwise.”

The ESFA’s current investigation into 3aaa was sparked earlier this year when a whistleblower approached the agency with new claims about its business.

Owing to this, Ofsted declared its latest inspection of the provider, which was expected to result in another “outstanding” rating, as incomplete in June.

Mr Marples and Ms McEvoy-Robinson, who set up 3aaa in 2008, resigned from their roles as the company’s chief executive and main director respectively last week.

The provider was then suspended from recruiting apprentices, but FE Week later revealed that senior employees had been “instructed” to tell its staff to not date any paperwork for “planned enrolments”.

3aaa had the largest allocation for non-levy apprenticeships last year at nearly £22 million. Its overall ESFA allocations totalled more than £31 million.