Devolving 16 to 19 education funding is a âknife-edge policyâ that risks creating a postcode lottery unless colleges help shape how it is implemented, the new president of the Association of Colleges has warned.
Gerry McDonald, CEO of New City College, said the reforms have the potential to deliver a long-needed structural shake-up of further education, bringing curriculum and local economic needs closer together and ending âunhealthy duplication and competitionâ.
But he warned that poorly designed devolution could instead create âhard bordersâ between neighbouring areas and different rules and entitlements across the country.
Delivering his first speech at the AoCâs annual conference since becoming the organisationâs president last month, McDonald said: âThe opportunities ahead of us are considerable, but so too is the peril.
âIf it isn’t top of our agenda already, then devolution of funding for young people certainly will be very soon. In my view, it’s a knife-edge policy.
âDevolution could be the structural change we have long needed, strengthening the connection between curriculum and local economy, ending unhealthy duplication and competition, integrating 16 to 18 and adult budgets, creating a new era of local prosperity, with colleges right at the centre, or not.
âIt could all too easily go the other way. Hard borders on the central line between London and Essex, different rules and entitlements across Yorkshire’s four strategic authorities. The postcode lottery clichĂ© becomes the description of the system we create.â
Embrace the uncertainty
His warning comes a week after education secretary Lucy Powell told MPs that the transfer of 16 to 19 funding powers to mayoral strategic authorities â a plan announced by prime minister Andy Burnham over the summer â would be gradual rather than a âbig bangâ across the country.
Powell acknowledged concerns that devolution could create a postcode lottery, saying ministers were working out how to establish clear lines of accountability across a âvery patchwork and fragmentedâ system of local government.
She said the government wanted to link local delivery more closely with employers and labour markets, while maintaining national expectations, outcomes, qualifications and pathways.
Further details on exactly how mayors will be handed control of 16-to-19 funding is expected to be included in the âRewiring the Stateâ delivery plan, due to be published before the end of the year.
McDonald called on colleges to work collectively with civil servants to design an âadaptive and forward-lookingâ blueprint for devolution.
âWe need to have white papers with green edges,â he said.
âWe need to be bold in saying this might work in Havering, but good luck in Kirklees. In other words, we need to embrace the uncertainty that comes with new design. We must have the courage to say we donât know.â
He said the sector needed to âbuild slowlyâ, adding that there “can be beauty in a jigsaw designed by all of us”.
AoC chief executive David Hughes also acknowledged during his conference speech that the prospect of devolving significant powers to local politicians was causing anxiety among college leaders.
He said concerns included the capabilities of mayoral strategic authorities, the risk of parochial decision-making and the possibility of a postcode lottery.
But Hughes urged colleges to view the reforms as an opportunity to secure a stronger strategic role in their local economies.
âThere’s such an opportunity for us to secure a much better position for colleges, with better accountability, with much more appropriate oversight than we’ve got at the moment,â he said.
â[We need] to be able to become the very best partner to mayors, a strategic partner, not just a delivery organisation, and give colleges the agency to be able to design and deliver and to get on and lead.â
He added: âWe’ve got to see devolution as that opportunity. So when the Milburn report comes out, let’s step in. When the mayors come asking what you can do, let’s step up.â
âWe have ignored adult education to our shameâ
McDonald also used his presidential address to call for a renewed focus on adult education, arguing that the country had neglected its national responsibility to adult learners.
He highlighted the role adult learning had played in his own family, revealing that his mother returned to education in her mid-30s after leaving school at 15, studying for O levels in English and maths before going on to complete an Open University degree and master’s.
She then enjoyed a long career as a social worker, he said.
âThis is the power of adult education, and we have ignored it to our shame,â McDonald said.
He made a special mention of institutes of adult learning, describing them as âthe jewels in the FE systemâ which should be âcherishedâ as they are in the âeye of the adult funding stormâ.
He called for colleges and providers to work together to design a system built on the sector’s âhistory of innovation and adaptationâ, not âwritten complete and sufficient by any one of usâ, but is ârather a glorious patchwork of ideas from all of usâ.