Skip to content
19 November 2026

Latest news from FE Week

Milburn sets out apprenticeship shake-up to favour young people

The Treasury should stop withholding hundreds of millions of pounds in apprenticeship levy funding, employers should pay more to train older apprentices and a new pre-apprenticeship programme should be created, Alan Milburn has recommended.

The former Cabinet minister’s review of youth unemployment also called for the requirement for young apprentices to pass level 2 English and maths exams to complete their apprenticeship to be scrapped, alongside increased financial incentives for employers and training providers.

Milburn outlined the proposals in his final report, ‘From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation’, which sets out a 10-year deal between young people and the state.

His review, commissioned by the government last year, covers education, skills, welfare and health, and aims to reduce the UK’s not in education, employment or training (NEET) rate from 13 per cent to 5 per cent by 2036.

You can read our full round up of the recommendations affecting the wider further education and college sector here.

Here are the review’s proposals relating specifically to apprenticeships.

It is not yet clear whether the government will accept and implement all the recommendations.

Return apprenticeships to their core purpose

Apprenticeship starts among 16 to 24-year-olds have fallen by around 40 per cent over the past decade, while the number of young people starting level 2 apprenticeships has collapsed by 73 per cent.

Milburn concluded that apprenticeships should be the “largest education and skills priority” arising from his review.

He said demand for apprenticeships “massively” outweighs supply and called for them to be returned to their “core purpose” as a “route for young people into skilled work”.

The report argued that employers have made rational decisions to use apprenticeship levy funding, now called the growth and skills levy, to retrain existing and older workers rather than recruit younger staff. This has left England with low youth participation compared with other countries.

It proposed increasing annual apprenticeship starts among under-25s from 172,000 in 2024-25 to 270,000 by 2036-37, with the aim of doubling the number of young people achieving an apprenticeship over the next decade.

By then, around 35 per cent of each cohort should have started an apprenticeship by the age of 25, the report said.

Milburn also wants the apprenticeship achievement rate to rise from around 65 per cent to 80 per cent, resulting in approximately 215,000 young people completing an apprenticeship each year.

Abolish the Treasury topslice

To help fund this expansion, Milburn called for all funding receipts raised by the apprenticeship levy to be released for apprenticeship training.

He said the government must be “honest” with employers that the apprenticeship levy is a payroll tax, rather than a hypothecated tax ringfenced for apprenticeships.

As FE Week readers will be aware, the government sets an apprenticeship budget that is generally lower than the receipts it receives from levy payments by employers.

The Treasury retains the difference. Unofficial estimates suggest this gap will be around £800 million in 2026-27, but Milburn put the figure closer to £460 million.

He said the government should set the annual English apprenticeship budget at the full value of English levy receipts and allow it to grow alongside those receipts.

“In other words, the existing Treasury topslice of apprenticeship funding should be removed and those resources should be ploughed into apprenticeship expansion,” the report said.

Milburn recognised this would be a “significant fiscal choice” but argued that a government “serious about rebuilding apprenticeships as a route for young people has to fund the ambition it sets”.

“This has been a key ask of business and one I support,” he added.

The report also proposed replacing notional employer levy balances and levy transfers over time with a “direct funding model aligned to employer demand and government priorities”.

Make employers pay more for older apprentices

Milburn said releasing the Treasury topslice should allow apprenticeships to be reorientated towards young people by providing 100 per cent funding from levy proceeds for under-25s, while reducing government contributions towards training older apprentices.

His report confirmed a proposal that FE Week reported was under consideration last month, that employers should be required to pay 25 per cent of training costs for apprentices aged over 25, with the government covering the remaining 75 per cent.

The savings would then be used to “increase funding for young people”.

Milburn added that, depending on progress towards expanding youth apprenticeships and the availability of additional public funding, the government should be prepared to reduce its contribution to 50 per cent by 2031-32 to ensure the ambition for young people is met.

Create a ‘clear’ pre-apprenticeship programme

The report also urged the government to introduce a “clear” pre-apprenticeship programme “at scale” that leads into an apprenticeship, skilled work or further technical study.

Milburn said this was a key feature missing from England’s system compared with countries with strong technical education routes.

The programme should be based on level 1 provision and the government’s new level 2 occupational certificates, creating a “single, clear occupational route” for study between the ages of 16 and 19.

“They should normally combine English and maths where required, sector-relevant technical learning, work-readiness support and substantial employer experience, with placements proportionate to the length and purpose of the programme,” the report said.

Milburn said colleges should be the “principal providers” for 16 to 18-year-olds, with access continuing for older young adults who “require the same bridge”.

He proposed an initial 25,000 places.

The government introduced foundation apprenticeships last year as a route for young people not yet ready for a full apprenticeship. But the programme attracted just 160 starts in its first eight months, raising questions about how a new, much larger pre-apprenticeship offer would attract learners and employers.

Axe the English and maths exit rule

Another proposed change would remove the requirement for 16 to 18-year-old apprentices to pass level 2 English and maths exams to complete their apprenticeship.

The rule was scrapped for apprentices aged 19 and over in February 2025.

Milburn said apprentices would still be expected to study the subjects alongside their training, but argued that making exam passes a completion requirement can trap learners in “repeated failure, block progression and make employers less willing to offer opportunities”.

He recognised that achieving level 2 English and maths is not a requirement for completing other 16 to 19 study programmes. “Government should remove this disparity for apprenticeships,” the report said.

Give cash incentives to providers

Milburn also proposed a “significant scaling up” of financial support for employers recruiting young apprentices and training providers that prioritise generating opportunities for young people.

The current hiring payment available to eligible non-levy paying employers when they recruit new apprentices aged 16 to 24, introduced last month, should increase from £2,000 to £2,500, he said.

The incentive should also be extended to levy-paying employers.

Alongside this, the report proposed a new £2,000 payment for the training provider.

There is little detail on how the provider incentive would operate, including what organisations would need to do to qualify.

“The employer payment recognises the wage, supervision and first-job costs involved in taking on a young person. The provider payment rewards the organisations that generate opportunities, engage employers, recruit young labour-market entrants and support them to completion,” the report said.

Give 10% of the apprenticeship budget to local leaders

Milburn said the apprenticeship funding model should remain national across England to avoid major businesses that employ large numbers of apprentices having to deal with different approaches across the country.

However, he proposed allocating an initial 10 per cent of the apprenticeship budget each year to mayoral and other strategic authorities.

The money would be used to “strengthen employer engagement, generate opportunities, fund training costs, respond to local skills shortages and connect young people to sectors with growing demand”.

This would provide a longer-term funding source for local apprenticeship brokerage services announced by the chancellor recently.

Strengthen Find an Apprenticeship service

Lastly, Milburn said the route into apprenticeships needs to become “dramatically simpler”.

He described the current system, in which apprenticeships are advertised by different employers and providers at different times of the year, as a “maze”.

The government should strengthen its Find an Apprenticeship website as the “national vacancy backbone”, while every strategic authority should establish a “simple, UCAS-style local access point” through which young people can see the education, training and apprenticeship opportunities available in their area.

Milburn targets NEET rate of 5% with new national youth service

A new national youth service and legal “guarantees” of work, training or support would slash the UK’s NEET rate from 13 to 5 per cent within a decade, Alan Milburn is expected to argue tomorrow.

The Milburn review will recommend that the government sets a ten-year ambition to end long-term unemployment through a new ‘youth opportunity service’ and two “guarantees” enshrined in law.

A new youth opportunity service (YOS) should be the “engine room” of the government’s efforts to cut the number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET), the review is set to recommend.

Underpinned as legal rights, a permanent “opportunity guarantee” would give young people a route into education, training or work and while the YOS would offer a “support guarantee” of health, employment and practical help.

The review will set out a wide range of reforms designed to cut the UK’s youth NEET rate from Europe’s second highest, at 13 per cent, to be closer in line with the continent’s “best performers” such as the Netherlands, at about 5 per cent.

This would mean cutting national NEET numbers from about one million to 400,000 by 2036.

The service would bring together employment, careers, health and practical support, with young people offered a personalised “participation plan” and a named adviser.

A ‘complete reset’

Former health secretary Milburn said his report, ‘From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation’, will call for a “complete reset” to Britain’s approach to its youth NEET problem.

He added: “Britain has had a youth NEET problem for 25 years and never a plan to end it. We are at a fork in the road and half measures will not do. A complete system reset is needed.

“A lost generation is not inevitable. A work generation is possible. This is not simply a cause for young people.

“It is a cause for the country. We have to make the next generation a national priority. Youth participation has to run through public policy like a stick of rock.”

The report will propose reforms across government and public services including: colleges and apprenticeships, early years and schools, health, welfare, employers, and the “whole system”.

A new “additional cost allowance” should replace PIP (personal independence payments) while a health and disability fund would quickly meet immediate or changing costs, he is expected to recommend.

Milburn will argue that crude benefit cuts will not work without upfront investment in employment and education support, with savings building over the next decade. He wants to rebalance spending from £25 on youth benefits for every £1 spent helping young people into work or education, to £2 on benefits for every £1 spent on support.

On Tuesday, Milburn is expected to say: “A lost generation is not a fact of life. It is a choice. And I believe it is the wrong one.

“Not just because it is a fiscal crisis or an economic crisis. But because it is a moral one. We are failing as a nation to gift the next generation the opportunities they need to succeed.

“It is time for a new settlement that makes work not welfare the future for the next generation.

“Demographic change makes getting young people into work a necessity. Britain’s future relies on us backing young people.”

Media trailing

Much of Milburn’s recommendations were trailed in a series of news reports and interviews this weekend, including tens of thousands more technical and vocational training places for 16 to 18 year olds and 150,000 more place for adults ahed 19 to 24.

Milburn is expected to tell the government to fund every student colleges recruit and reform accountability mechanisms to reward progression into employment or further learning.

The Treasury will be urged to end the controversial apprenticeship levy top slice and an aim will be set for starts for young people to double helped partly by increasing employer contribution rates for hires aged 25 and over, rising gradually from 25 to 50 per cent by 2031-32.

As already reported, a new YOS would come alongside potential benefit sanctions for young people who do not accept help, and a reformed welfare offer for under 25-year-olds known, as a “youth allowance”, which would be at the current Universal Credit rate.

Deadlines for support

The YOS would offer young people support within a maximum time frame, including meeting a named advisor within 14 days, agreeing a participation plan within four weeks, and starting “substantive” activity such as work or training within four months.

Employers who hire a young person who is NEET for more than six months would be eligible for a £3,000 payment, while those who are still NEET after twelve months will be guaranteed a paid six-month job through the existing Jobs Guarantee.

This weekend, the government announced it was reducing the qualifying period of unemployment for the Jobs Guarantee from 18 to 12 months.

FE colleges struggle to meet demand as 10,500 extra students enrol

FE colleges expect to teach 10,500 more 16 to 18-year-olds than originally allocated this year and are struggling to meet demand with mounting waitlists for courses across the government’s priority industries.

The Association of Colleges’ annual enrolment survey, published today, found more than four in five colleges are over their learner allocation in 2026-27, with one provider surpassing by as many as 598 students.

The 90 FE colleges surveyed collectively expected 10,482 more learners for the 2026-27 academic year – 3 per cent over – who will only be partially funded.

The figure is down from 11,042 – or 5 per cent – last year.

In August, colleges were given a “guarantee” that the government would meet the cost of in-year growth in 16 to 19 student numbers only for this year, following two years in which the DfE only funded three-quarters of over-recruitment.

But the guarantee does not mean colleges will be fully funded for every additional student they enrol, as the Department for Education’s in-year growth formula only partially funds the extra costs.

David Hughes, chief executive of AoC, said colleges were being forced to turn students away because they “cannot set up the space and staffing with at best short term and partial funding”.

“Young people and adults recognise that there are jobs out there and they want the skills training to be able to access them but colleges are hampered in being able to meet that demand,” he added.

It comes on the eve of Alan Milburn’s landmark report which is expected to recommend extra funding for colleges to create tens of thousands more technical and vocational training places for 16 and 17 year olds alongside 150,000 more places for adults aged 18 to 24 .

Education secretary Lucy Powell said at the AoC conference last week: “Frankly, I think it’s unforgivable that there are almost 150,000 16-18-year-olds who right now are NEET. Instead of sitting at home, we need to get them into college or doing an apprenticeship. I want us to reach them with an exciting, new and engaging offer.

“But you’ve told me the barriers you face to do this. A big one is the way you’re funded, the lack of a guarantee on funding for every student who enrols during the year and how late you find out the funding rate for the following year. I know that makes it harder for you to plan with confidence and to engage this important cohort of young people.”

Construction bottleneck

Colleges also reported increased demand and waiting lists across all eight industrial strategy priority sectors, particularly in the construction and health and social care sectors.

Almost six in ten (59 per cent) colleges have set up waiting lists for construction courses, up from 56 per cent last year.

Close to nine in ten (86 per cent) cited construction as the sector most commonly associated with enrolment growth, followed by health and social care (55 per cent).

The figures continue a trend from last year when ministers injected £600 million towards training for 60,000 more “engineers, brickies, sparkies and chippies”.

Comparatively more than a quarter of colleges (27 per cent) have waiting lists for health and social care courses, a fall from 33 per cent in 2025.

Providers blamed the increased pressures to shortages in specialist staff, workshop space, facilities and equipment.

The report said: “Demand is particularly strong in construction, health and social care, advanced manufacturing and digital provision, while waiting lists in many priority sectors indicate that colleges could support greater economic growth if capacity and funding constraints were addressed, it is worth noting that not all colleges will keep waiting lists, so this does not reflect definitive demand.”

The AoC recommended the government ensure 16 to 18 funding allocations “reflect continuing growth” so colleges can meet demand without “compromising quality or financial sustainability”.

Apprenticeship slump

The proportion of colleges reporting a drop in apprenticeship enrolments more than doubled in the 2026 survey, from 14 per cent last year to 30 per cent.

Colleges cited the drop to employers delaying starts until October so they could qualify for the government’s new hiring grant, which launched last month.

The grant pays non-levy employers £2,000 for taking on apprentices aged under 25, as part of a £1 billion earmarked package to encourage businesses to hire young people.

GCSE resits rise

More students are arriving to college without a grade 4 in GCSE English and maths, pushing up resit enrolments, the survey found.

Four fifths (79 per cent) of colleges reported increases in GCSE maths resits, compared to 61 per cent last year. In English resits, 77 per cent noted more enrolments, up from 65 per cent in 2025.

The findings come after education secretary Lucy Powell pledged to remove “barriers” caused by funding and the resit policy preventing colleges working with young people classed as NEET.

Unmet adult demand

The survey also found nearly two in five (38 per cent) of colleges are running waitlists for ESOL courses. Almost a quarter of those have over 200 adults waiting to be placed.

FE colleges added that devolution was making adult recruitment harder from “postcode-based funding restrictions” that limit access across boundaries and, in some cases, a cap on enrolments.

Hughes said the reported cap on adult funding is a “major barrier” for colleges.

“They need more certainty over the years ahead and they desperately need more adult funding,” he said.

Education questions – November live blog


Milburn NEET report: what FE can expect on Tuesday

Colleges could be funded to enrol over 150,000 more students aged under 25 while employers would have to pay even more towards apprenticeship training costs for older apprentices under recommendations expected from Alan Milburn on Tuesday.

The proposals were trailed across multiple national newspaper and broadcast interviews this weekend ahead of the former Labour minister’s landmark final report on reducing youth unemployment, commissioned by work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden.

It follows Milburn’s interim report in May, which analysed the causes behind the large numbers of 16 to 25 year olds not in education, employment or training. Tuesday’s report is expected to recommend a raft of policy changes across education, employment and welfare to reduce the near one million NEETs.

Extra FE places and a ‘NEET premium’

The Financial Times reported on Saturday that Milburn will recommend tens of thousands more technical and vocational training places for 16 to 18 year olds alongside 150,000 more places for adults under 25.

It also reported a proposed “NEET premium” to give colleges extra funding for recruiting young people at risk of dropping out of education and employment.

Estimates suggest the expansion of places could need an additional £1 billion to £2 billion a year.

Ministers are also reportedly considering announcing a commitment to fund every student colleges recruit in 2027-28. If implemented, this could remove the longstanding convention of giving colleges an annual allocation and deciding mid-year how many, if any, students above that allocation could be funded.

Milburn has previously suggested reforming college funding and accountability mechanisms to reward progression into employment and further learning, rather than just enrolments.

Opportunity guaranteed

Milburn confirmed in a BBC interview broadcast on Sunday that his report will propose a statutory “opportunity guarantee” for young people.

The proposed entitlement would cover apprenticeships, “pre-apprenticeships”, college places and jobs, alongside mental health support and job coaching.

Unlike previous temporary job schemes, like Kickstart, Milburn wants a permanent duty on government to provide opportunities.

In return, young people would be expected to accept places in education, training or work, or face benefit sanctions.

He told the BBC: “We are going to have a duty on government to provide opportunities. We’re calling it the opportunity guarantee. So there should be a guarantee for a young person, because at the moment the only guarantee they’ve got is to a very simple thing, to get a benefit. What sort of right life is that?

“So we’ve got to make sure the whole of the state and the whole of government is changing its approach to this.”

Higher apprenticeship costs and end of the top-slice

Mulburn’s report is also set to recommend doubling the number of apprenticeships for young people over the next decade.

The Sun on Sunday reported that Tuesday’s report will recommend increasing youth apprenticeship starts from 100,000 to 215,000.

It’s not clear how he came up with those figures. Just under 75,000 under 19 year olds started an apprenticeship in 2024-25, according to the latest government data, and a further 97,000 were aged 19 to 24.

Meanwhile, The Times reported on Saturday that Milburn will recommend the government increases apprenticeship training costs for employers for apprentices aged 25 and over, suggesting a 25 per cent contribution rate.

This idea, reported to be on the cards by FE Week last month, has been doing the rounds as ministers consider ways to pivot the apprenticeships system away from adults and towards young people.

Milburn is reportedly set to propose the government go even further by increasing the co-funding rate to 50 per cent by 2031-32 and ending the controversial Treasury top slice of levy funding.

The top-slice is the amount the Treasury keeps after collecting the funds paid by employers and dishing out budgets for apprenticeships to the DfE and devolved nations. As levy receipts from employers have grown faster than the apprenticeships budget, the top-slice now represents around £700 million.

According to The Guardian last month, Milburn is also expected to propose a new pre-apprenticeship programme, delivered mainly by colleges.

Welfare and employment reforms

The most politically contentious proposals will be on cuts to benefits for young people.

Milburn’s interim report said the government currently spends £25 on benefits for young people for every £1 it spends helping them into employment. He told the BBC on Sunday his recommendations would, over time, reduce that ratio to £2 for every £1.

McFadden, also appearing on the BBC’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg show, confirmed that some future claimants would receive less than under today’s system, while outlining Milburn’s proposed additional protections for people unable to work and those facing disability-related costs.

McFadden was not asked to directly comment on Milburn’s reported education or apprenticeships proposals.

The work and pensions secretary announced today another expansion of the government’s jobs guarantee scheme, which fully subsidises a six-month job for eligible unemployed 18 to 24 year olds. The qualifying unemployment will now change from 18 months to 12 months in April 2027.

What happens next

Milburn said this weekend his proposals will represent a ten-year period of “sustained investment and reform”.

McFadden confirmed on Sunday that ministers will respond to Milburn’s recommendations on Tuesday, with a more comprehensive response alongside legislation in the new year.

Newbury College and Activate Learning to consult on merger

One of England’s smallest colleges will merge with one of the country’s largest groups next year, following a period of financial turmoil.

Newbury College, which had an income of about £15 million in 2024-25, plans to merge with Activate Learning, which has an annual turnover of £113 million.

Activate, the seventh-largest college group in the country by turnover, currently has about 17,000 learners across eight FE campuses in Surrey, Berkshire and Oxfordshire, while Newbury College has about 3,900 learners at its west Berkshire campus.

A public consultation on the merger is likely to be held in the new year, FE Week understands.

It would mark the end of the small, standalone college which struggled with “fragile” finances and rising costs linked to its private finance initiative (PFI) contract for its building, which ends next July.

 

Shared ambitions

In a joint statement, the colleges said skills minister Jacqui Smith had now signed off the merger plans and the two organisations are working towards a potential merger date of 1 August 2027.

They added: “Building on Newbury College’s longstanding role in its community, significant improvements in its financial performance and the quality of outcomes, the proposed merger would bring together the strengths and expertise of both organisations.

“Our shared ambition is to widen learning and career opportunities for students, support staff development and strengthen partnerships with our employer partners and stakeholders, both within our local communities and the wider Berkshire.”

The merger plans were recommended following an FE commissioner-led structure and prospects appraisal last year.

Other partnerships explored by the college included with Basingstoke College of Technology, but then principal Anthony Bravo rejected the idea, telling his governors a union was “not financially viable”.

Newbury MP Lee Dillon said: “Newbury College plays a hugely important role in our community, and I am really positive about the opportunities this proposed partnership could bring.

“Bringing together Newbury College’s local strengths with the wider experience of Activate Learning has real potential to open up even more opportunities for students and staff, while building a strong future for further education here in Newbury and west Berkshire.

“I look forward to seeing the proposals develop and hearing the views of students, staff and the wider community as the consultation moves forward.”

Rare PFI deal ends

Newbury College was handed £1.5 million in 2024-25, via an “advance of funding” agreement with the Department for Education but was placed in intervention when it failed to repay at the agreed time due to a “cashflow gap”.

The department converted the debt into an emergency funding package in December 2025 after awaited proceeds from the sale of land “did not arrive as planned”.

Its accounts for 2024-25 showed a £1.6 million deficit following a £1.5 million shortfall the previous year.

Newbury College is due to reach the end of its 25-year PFI deal in July next year, after paying £40.5 million for a building which originally cost about £10 million.

Ongoing costs associated with the deal have also included interest on its debts, “lifecycle” payments for building upkeep, and maintenance, cleaning and security.

Since 2018 its annual charge to contract owner Equitix, part of global investment firm Tetragon Financial Group, has shot up from between £1.2 million and £1.5 million to £2.5 million.

College interim principal Lee Probert and Equitix have both previously told FE Week that the PFI deal funded facilities that were of an “exceptional standard”.

Automated apprenticeships: The money behind the machines

An AI company promises to slash the cost of producing apprenticeship teaching videos by 95 per cent. Another offers a virtual Ofsted inspector that can observe lessons and produce report cards. Others have developed systems to predict which learners might withdraw before completing their courses – or trigger funding clawbacks.

Welcome to the expanding market for artificial intelligence in apprenticeship training, where almost every aspect of delivering a qualification is becoming an opportunity for automation.

What apprentices may lose in the great AI efficiency race

For financially stretched training providers, the attraction is obvious. Technology can take over time-consuming administration, help staff to manage more learners and potentially transform the economics of delivery.

For the companies selling these products, it represents a lucrative new market.

Of the 15 largest privately owned training companies by apprenticeship levy funding in 2024-25, FE Week identified evidence that all but two were using AI in at least one aspect of teaching, assessment, marking, feedback or predicting learner performance.

But the benefits are not necessarily being shared equally.

While some providers say savings are being reinvested into more individual support for apprentices, automation is also enabling larger caseloads and higher profit margins. So, who ultimately benefits from the efficiency revolution?

Higher revenues

The commercial advantages of adopting AI to improve productivity can be particularly attractive for companies.

As AI platform Sainaptic says in its website’s sales pitch to training providers: “By relieving assessors of repetitive marking, you scale capacity without ballooning overheads, leading to higher revenues.”

There is little clear evidence yet of widespread redundancies among AI-adopting training providers caused by its implementation, although at several of them, turnover has increased considerably faster than employee numbers.

In 2025, Cambridge Spark, which developed its own AI feedback and assessment platform, increased turnover by nearly a third and operating profit by two-thirds, paying out £2.5 million in dividends, while expanding its workforce by just 15 per cent.

At Kaplan, average employee numbers fell by 3.4 per cent to 979 in 2025, despite turnover rising 4.4 per cent to £100.7 million. Operating profit also increased by 19.8 per cent.

Kaplan’s director of education Lisa Nelson describes its TutorBot as a “study partner that provides the support of a teaching assistant around the clock”.

She said coaching and tutor caseloads had remained static since 2023 and the company’s “priority remains delivering high-quality, human-first apprenticeship training”.

At Multiverse, overall headcount fell from 822 to 813 in the year to 2024-25, while revenue rose by more than a third to £80 million.

One prospective Multiverse coach told FE Week they had been informed they would be expected to support approximately 100 learners, compared with around 40 in a previous coaching role.

Kaplan’s Lisa Nelson

15 minutes of one-to-one coaching

Each apprentice would receive just 15 minutes of one-to-one coaching monthly, according to the prospective employee.

Multiverse said its coaches’ sentiment on workload and tooling had improved over the previous six months, and pointed out that as well as the monthly group coaching, learners get monthly workshop sessions and can request as many 1:1 sessions as they like.

The account illustrates the potential tension between improving productivity and preserving meaningful human contact, although it does not establish that AI was responsible for the caseload expectations described.

Nick Heard-Jones, who is undertaking doctoral research into private equity involvement in the training sector, believes the primary objective of providers should be to enhance the learner and employer experience.

“Shareholders need an appropriate return on their investment, but we also need to see a step up in quality,” he said.

He is particularly concerned about the implications for the relationship between apprentices and the people supporting them.

“One of the key features of an apprenticeship is an inexperienced apprentice training alongside a subject expert, receiving individual and personalised feedback within the occupational context.

“If coach/assessor caseloads increase as a consequence of AI utilisation, the risk is this will be lost and the apprentices’ experience will diminish.”

While the financial benefits of AI are relatively easy to quantify, changes in the quality of individual learner support are much harder to measure.

Ofsted judgments, Heard-Jones points out, do not reveal what proportion of apprenticeship funding is spent directly on teaching and supporting learners.

Jamie Hibbert of Cambridge Spark

Where do the hours go?

For teaching staff, the benefits of using AI can be considerable. A Jisc pilot of TeacherMatic found FE teachers saved “just over two hours” each week.

One independent training provider representative said tutors who had previously been working 60-hour weeks were “happy” that AI had enabled them to cut their hours to the 40 they were supposed to be working in the first place.

Jamie Hibbert, a digital skills coach at Cambridge Spark, developed a Copilot agent that analyses transcripts of meetings with apprentices and their line managers, then drafts progress reviews against the relevant knowledge, skills and behaviours.

The time he spends writing up each review has fallen from as much as 45 minutes to 20, so he can now concentrate fully on the conversation instead of dividing his attention between coaching and note-taking.

“I don’t see it as doing my job for me. I see it as helping me get better at what actually matters: my ability to support and coach apprentices.”

At Hawk Training, operations director Vanessa Jones said in an Aptem case study that the company would be “significantly struggling in terms of capacity” without AI.

“The timesaving is where we can invest in human-to-human education,” she added.

But the question is whether time saved through automation consistently translates into better learner support and staff satisfaction.

At Multiverse, instructors told The Guardian that AI systems monitoring their teaching had caused them “horrendous stress”.

The technology assigns risk statuses and confidence scores, with staff complaining that legitimate teaching decisions could be flagged as undesirable digressions.

Multiverse said human managers retained responsibility for performance reviews and the technology helped to identify areas requiring support.

Multiverse founder Euan Blair
Multiverse founder Euan Blair

The money behind the machines

The Department for Education’s assessment of England’s edtech market identified assessment technology as its fastest-growing segment, generating £470 million in turnover.

The research, which focused primarily on schools, also identified weaknesses in the evidence for the effectiveness of edtech and how institutions evaluate it.

For apprenticeship technology companies, the financial results illustrate the commercial momentum.

Between 2024 and 2025, turnover rose from £4.7 million to £6.3 million at Bud Systems, £9.9 million to £10.8 million at OneFile (part of Canadian software group Harris Computer), and £7 million to £9.1 million at Aptem.

These businesses provide platforms that have become central to how many apprenticeship providers manage learners, assessment, progress and compliance, and have developed AI-enabled functions.

Once a provider’s learner records, assessment workflows and staff routines are embedded within a platform, changing supplier can become difficult and expensive.

The report warned about vendor lock-in, while one training provider source fears that AI tools are being offered cheaply to encourage adoption before “all of a sudden a significant cost will start to come in”.

The concern is that providers could exchange one substantial expense – human labour – for a growing dependence on technology companies whose long-term charges they cannot easily control.

The companies are also developing close relationships with organisations representing the sector.

Bud, OneFile and Aptem are all patrons of the Association of Employment and Learning Providers (AELP), with patronage costing £10,000 plus VAT annually.

The association represents training providers while maintaining commercial relationships with businesses selling them software and automation.

There is no evidence that those arrangements have improperly influenced its policies.

But they illustrate how closely connected the suppliers, customers and representative organisations have become as technology takes on a larger role in apprenticeship delivery.

AELP chief executive Ben Rowland said: “Many of our patrons are not suppliers but regular AELP members, who are going above and beyond with their contribution. We know all our patrons are proud to support AELP and the sector, and we are proud to have them all as patrons.”

A screenshot from Synthesia’s AI-generated video resembling me, based on a photograph I uploaded onto its platform

When teachers become avatars

In some cases, providers are using the latest technology to produce AI-generated lessons, replacing filmed human presenters with avatars.

Paragon Skills, part of Knovia, has been using AI video platform Synthesia to produce teaching materials for apprenticeship e-learning modules.

Instead of commissioning conventional video production, staff write scripts, select synthetic presenters and generate lessons or workplace scenarios featuring AI avatars.

The company’s programmes include adult care, early years and professional services.

Synthetic presenters allow courses to be updated quickly when legislation changes, and new scenarios can be created without the expense of filming additional material.

Oxbridge Pathways, operated by Liverpool Colleges Ltd, markets AI-generated lessons and a “talking tutor video with lip-sync” across 84 UK qualifications.

It advertises enrolment at £250, plus £20 per unit, excluding final assignment or assessment and awarding-body registration fees.

Oak’s ‘observer at the back of every online classroom’

The automated inspector

A newer market is emerging around quality assurance and inspection preparation.

Apprenticeship software company Oaks advertises an AI inspector called Alana, “who you can talk to”, which conducts spoken mock inspections, examines evidence and produces practice Ofsted report cards.

Another service is described as being an “observer at the back of every online lesson”.

Alana joins online lessons as a muted guest, identifies speakers and drafts teaching observations, which are “sent to the tutor to read and respond, never shown to learners”.

The company says the audio is “deleted once the notes are written”.

Its advertised forthcoming products include a “revenue rescue engine” to identify apprentices at risk of triggering funding clawbacks, and a “predictive flight risk” tool which estimates the likelihood of learners withdrawing and generates “micro-rescue plans”.

A further product, the “learner journey time machine”, promises to turn an apprentice’s progress into an “Ofsted-ready narrative”.

Such systems might enable earlier interventions and better management. But they also raise questions about whether technology is being used primarily to improve education or to optimise funding and inspection outcomes.

Aptem Enhance is ‘proven to help providers to cut admin and focus on learner outcomes’

How much do apprentices know?

Despite the rapid adoption of AI, there is considerable variation in how providers explain its use to learners.

Training providers are not subject to a universal requirement to notify learners when AI assists with marking or feedback.

However, UK data protection law requires providers to be fair and transparent about how they process personal data, and the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has warned that failing to explain AI-assisted decisions could breach these requirements.

Separately, Ofqual has highlighted a strong consensus among assessment experts that students should be informed when AI scoring systems are used – and that those systems should be explainable.

Of the 13 largest providers where FE Week identified evidence of AI use, Kaplan was the only one found to have a clear, publicly accessible statement explaining how it uses AI in relation to learners (although Multiverse told FE Week it informs apprentices when feedback is AI-generated, and says it has made it as easy as possible for apprentices to ask for a human to review.)

Kaplan promises that learners will be told when they receive AI-supported feedback, that consequential decisions will retain safeguards against over-reliance on AI, and that policies will help learners to avoid plagiarism.

And of the 15 biggest providers, FE Week identified publicly accessible, specifically AI-related policies or guidance on learners’ use of AI at just one –Train’d Up Railway Resourcing Limited.

It’s document defines AI misuse as using it to review, rewrite, summarise, paraphrase, improve or adjust the word count of assignments, or failing to follow guidance where AI use is permitted.

Other providers may give learners guidance through internal systems or course materials that are not publicly accessible.

But the disparity raises questions about how clearly apprentices are being told what they can and cannot do with AI – and how much they know about providers’ own use of the technology.

Edtech investor and expert Richard Taylor

Who is watching the machines?

The pace of commercial development is testing regulators’ capacity to keep up.

The Department for Education’s generative AI product safety standards, updated in January 2026, seek to establish safeguards for AI products used in education, but edtech specialist Richard Taylor described them as a “belated acknowledgement” of inadequate safeguards.

He estimated that 95 per cent of current UK edtech AI claims fell outside the standards.

A senior source involved in AI safety work with the DfE believes that more than half of the edtech products being used in FE fall short, and technology suppliers themselves complain that regulators are not providing sufficiently timely guidance.

The government is launching a new edtech certification scheme, but its remit is focused on schools and colleges and the Department for Work and Pensions says it is not currently framed as applying to apprenticeship providers.

The DfE says providers should be transparent about automated decision-making and ensure that learners understand how their personal data is processed.

But the ICO recently identified wider compliance weaknesses in audits of 28 education technology providers, including confusion over responsibilities for handling personal data.

The risks of connecting AI systems to sensitive learner and employer information are becoming more acute.

A recent government cybersecurity survey found that 82 per cent of FE colleges surveyed had adopted some AI tools, but only 66 per cent of those using or considering AI had specific cybersecurity processes to manage the associated risks.

Meanwhile, Google’s Threat Intelligence Group has warned that autonomous AI agents are being used in cyberattacks to access sensitive databases at speeds previously impossible for human attackers.

That raises questions about the security of interconnected learner and assessment records, particularly as AI products gain access to more institutional systems.

Some providers are also discovering that a useful AI product can be unacceptable to employers whose information it processes.

Decoded, a provider specialising in AI training, developed a chatbot to answer apprentices’ questions about end-point assessment.

Senior learner success coach David Parry said it successfully saved coaches time, but employers concerned about data protection objected to apprentices using an external AI system and asked the provider to switch it off.

For training providers, the financial attraction of AI is clear. Automation offers the possibility of increasing learner numbers, reducing administrative costs and improving productivity without a corresponding expansion in the workforce.

But the uncertainty over whether money saved through automation is being reinvested into teaching matters in a sector funded by public money.

Ultimately, the measure of success should not simply be how much money or staff time AI saves, but whether apprentices receive a better education as a result.

 

SEND reform plans must do better on post-16 provision, DfE admits

The Department for Education has admitted it approved council SEND reform plans despite gaps in post-16 provision, claiming they met the criteria set out in its own guidance.

Alasdaire Duerden, the DfE’s post-16 SEND lead, told delegates at the Association of Colleges annual conference this week that officials were now asking themselves whether the guidance used to judge the plans was “strong enough on post-16”.

He said the next version of the guidance, expected early next year, will put more emphasis on post-16 education.

Local area partnerships, led by councils alongside integrated care boards, had to submit three-year local SEND reform plans in June, setting out how they will deliver the government’s proposed reforms.

The plans, most of which have since been approved by the DfE, unlocked up to a 90 per cent write-off of councils’ high needs deficit.

An FE Week investigation recently found that many councils lacked firm proposals for expanding post-16 places for SEND school leavers, following an analysis of 40 published plans.

Speaking at a session exploring whether colleges will get “lost” in the SEND reforms, Duerden said he was not directly involved in approving council reform plans.

“I acknowledge the fact that some of the plans that we have seen have not been brilliant, but we have got some time to get that right,” he added.

The legislation behind the reforms is not expected to come into force until “probably 2030”, leaving time to strengthen local plans.

Duerden explained that approval came down to whether plans met the criteria in the DfE’s guidance.

Quality assessment framework

The DfE and NHS England assessed plans against a quality assessment framework shared with councils when the plans were commissioned, scoring them across eight areas on a four-point scale.

“We can see where there are some holes here, but actually we couldn’t not sign something off that met the criteria in the guidance,” he added.

“So, the question for us is, ‘was the criteria in the guidance strong enough for post-16?’”

A Local Government Association spokesperson said: “Councils worked hard to complete reform plans and carefully follow the process and guidance as set out by the Department for Education.

“We want to ensure that every child with SEND, including post-16, gets the support they need to receive the fulfilling education they deserve.

“It is vital government works closely with councils, not just to deliver the reforms but to tackle the present challenges in the system.”

Beefed up plans

The DfE views local SEND reform plans as live documents and expects councils to revise their plans annually as the reforms roll out and legislation is put in place.

Duerden said his team was already talking to civil servants responsible for local partnerships and experts at hand about updating its framework.

He said: “They are saying the next iteration of the guidance – because they are going to have to reproduce those plans this coming year – has to have far more in it to do with post-16 and has to really emphasise that in a much stronger way than it has done so far, so that we can actually get you into those conversations and get that seat at the table.

“Our challenge is to make sure the criteria are stronger.”

He also said the government intends to make a post-16 representative a mandatory member of new local SEND partnership boards.

Duerden urged colleges to work out how to coordinate as a sector so that one person could represent several local authority areas following any future devolution.

FE Week analysis shows that a fifth of the 40 plans from its investigation confirmed a dedicated board seat for a college representative.

Clare Howard, Natspec chief executive, said she hoped the DfE would ask local authorities to work with all FE providers delivering specialist provision for 16 to 25-year-olds.

“We were concerned that previously published plans did not recognise the essential role of specialist colleges in providing for young people with the most complex needs and providing specialist support to inclusive mainstream.”

She added: “We are pleased that the DfE has confirmed that the LA SEND reform plans are an iterative process.

“We look forward to working with the DfE on guidance to support local areas to do this effectively.”

College ordered to pay £81k to victimised security guard

A London college group has been ordered to pay more than £80,000 to a former security guard after a tribunal ruled that she was victimised and forced out of her job.

The employment tribunal found that Toyin Orisaremi was driven to quit in 2024 after the London South Bank Colleges’ handling of her reports of blackouts and dizziness experienced while working as a security guard.

The college said it acted over safety concerns, but the tribunal ruled that its handling of her suspension, pay and grievance amounted to victimisation.

South Bank Colleges, which runs Lambeth College and London South Bank Technical College, is rated ‘good’ by Ofsted and part of the London South Bank University (LSBU) Group. It said it regrets the “errors” it made and has apologised to Orisaremi.

According to a remedy judgment published this week, the college group must pay her £81,291.59.

An LSBU Group spokesperson said: “We accept the findings of the tribunal; the judgment has highlighted that this was a complex case in which errors were made in our management of the situation, which we regret. We have learned from these events and have taken steps to address this, including further training for our staff.

“We would like to apologise to Ms Orisaremi for the distress this experience has caused.”

Shown the door

Orisaremi resigned in May 2024. The original tribunal found that she left due to a “cumulative course of conduct” by the college, which “destroyed trust and confidence”.

This included failures regarding recommendations from occupational health, which helps employers to make reasonable adjustments for workers struggling with physical and mental health. They also covered its handling of her suspension, pay and a grievance she raised.

In a reconsideration judgment, the tribunal went further and ruled that Orisaremi’s forced resignation was itself an act of victimisation. It found that managers and HR staff knew about complaints she had made, and they had a “significant influence” on how they treated her, which drove her to quit.

During the proceedings, the college accepted that some of the matters amounted to victimisation.

She won her complaints of victimisation, constructive dismissal, unauthorised deduction from wages and claims for holiday and notice pay.

The tribunal also allowed Orisaremi to claim for psychiatric injury “caused or materially aggravated” by the victimisation, including her suspension and how her pay and grievance were handled. She was later awarded £3,500 for personal injury.

Disability claims fail

In the first judgment issued in August, the judge dismissed Orisaremi’s claims of direct disability discrimination, discrimination arising from disability, indirect disability discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments and harassment.

It initially ruled that Orisaremi was not disabled but later accepted that it had overlooked the college’s own admission that she was disabled by anxiety.

However, the judge said that the college could not reasonably have known her anxiety was a disability. Orisaremi had told occupational health her anxiety stemmed from ongoing symptoms and “perceived” work stress, and it expected her mood to settle “within weeks”.

It found the college’s treatment of her was driven by concerns about blackouts she had reported and her “safety-critical” duties as a security guard.

It upheld its earlier findings that her blackouts, dizziness and back pain were not classed as disabilities.

Financial security

The total compensation includes a basic award of £3,850 and £17,475 for past loss of earnings.

Orisaremi was awarded £30,000 for injury to feelings, one third of which was related to her unfair dismissal, and two thirds attributed to her pre-dismissal treatment.

The judge also awarded her £2,500 in aggravated damages. These are usually awarded where an employer has acted in a malicious or oppressive way, including how it defends a claim or complaints.

Employment Judge Harley added an uplift of nearly £5,900 after the college failed to follow the ACAS code of practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures.

The total also includes £2,937 in notice pay, £1,141 in holiday pay, £737 in unpaid sick pay, £500 for loss of statutory rights, almost £8,000 in interest, and a tax gross-up of £4,806.

Orisaremi was contacted for comment.