Skip to content
19 November 2026

Getting young people into jobs is only half the battle

More apprenticeships won't be enough unless young recruits receive the support they need to succeed
Petra Wilton Guest Contributor

Director of Policy and External Affairs, Chartered Management Institute

5 min read
|

The government’s response to the NEETs (not in education, employment or training) crisis is now beginning to take shape, with more apprenticeships, stronger local routes into work and renewed efforts to help those currently NEET take their first steps into the labour market.

That is welcome. But there is another question we should be asking: what happens once someone gets through the door?

The new local apprenticeship service is designed to create thousands more apprenticeship opportunities, with local teams matching potential recruits with employers and encouraging smaller firms that have never taken on a trainee to do so. It is an important response to the challenge that Alan Milburn identified in his interim report.

But getting someone into a first job is only half the challenge. The job also needs to be “sticky”: a place where a new starter receives the support, management and opportunity they need to stay, learn, earn and progress.

That matters because the barriers to employment do not disappear when someone receives a job offer. Milburn’s interim report highlights the growing prevalence of health conditions among those who are NEET, with anxiety, depression and neuro-developmental conditions among the defining features of the problem. It also found that employers are increasingly concerned about the pastoral support some recruits require, particularly smaller businesses that may not have the resources to provide it.

For employers, this can create a difficult balancing act. A recruit may have the potential and qualifications to do a job, but can need time to build confidence, understand workplace expectations or manage a health condition alongside work. That means that successful workplace integration may require more support than it once did.

Our ‘Bridging the Gap’ research suggests managers see significant gaps in some of the workplace skills new recruits need to develop, including resilience, professionalism, communication and the ability to receive and act on feedback. Almost half of managers have encountered recruits who lack an understanding of workplace-appropriate behaviour, while four in ten have seen a mismatch between academic knowledge and the practical requirements of the job.

These are all skills that can be developed through experience, coaching, feedback and opportunities to practise. The question is therefore not simply whether someone is “work ready”, but whether the workplace is ready to help them become work ready.

For someone entering employment for the first time, the workplace can be full of questions they have never had to ask before. How do I speak up in a meeting? How do I respond when someone tells me I have got something wrong? When is it appropriate to ask for help?

A good manager can turn those moments into opportunities to learn. In a hybrid workplace, where many of those lessons no longer happen naturally through sitting alongside experienced colleagues, that role matters even more.

And the quality of that first management experience can have consequences. Our research found that almost one in three people have left a job because of a negative relationship with their manager, while workers with ineffective managers are more than twice as likely to say they plan to leave their organisation within 12 months.

For those who may already face barriers to employment, a poor early workplace experience can make staying in work harder still. If we want to move people from inactivity into sustainable employment, the first few months demand forethought and investment, not an afterthought.

Managers need time and training to onboard inexperienced recruits, provide regular feedback, create opportunities to learn from colleagues and help new starters navigate the workplace. Our research found that 66 percent of managers see regular check-ins and feedback as one of the most effective ways to integrate new starters, while 89 per cent of managers who have received formal leadership training say it has improved their ability to develop younger employees.

There is a wider economic argument too. When organisations fail to retain and develop early-career employees, they lose the investment made in recruitment and onboarding, while weakening their future talent pipeline. Good management is not a soft add-on to employment policy; it is part of the infrastructure that makes employment sustainable.

The answer is not to tell those who are NEET that they are not “work ready”. Nor is it to assume that a health condition or lack of experience means someone cannot contribute. It is to recognise that readiness for work is developed, and that successful participation depends on the conditions around the individual as well as their own skills and ambition.

Those ambitions are clear. Sixty-four per cent of young people told CMI they want to become leaders at work. We should be asking how we help them realise that potential, rather than allowing a lack of experience to become a permanent barrier. We need to prepare people for work, but we also need to prepare workplaces for them. Management is the bridge between the two.

 

Share

Explore more on these topics

No Comments

Featured jobs from FE Week jobs / Schools Week jobs

Browse more news