Skip to content
18 November 2026

Don’t sacrifice older apprentices to create opportunities for young people

More young people need apprenticeships, but restricting opportunities for over-25s could backfire
Ben Rowland Guest Contributor

Chief executive of AELP

4 min read
|

I was really pleased to represent all AELP’s members at the launch of Alan Milburn’s report, From a Welfare State to a Working State.

Its recommendations aim to rebuild routes into skilled employment via a breathtakingly wide range of measures, and AELP supports much of its direction. But there is a simple test for every proposal: will it lead to more real opportunities for young people to take up?

Many of the proposals are things AELP has campaigned for over many years. We have consistently called for the Treasury top-slice to be returned to the apprenticeship budget; for apprenticeships for under-25s to be fully funded from Levy receipts; and for stronger incentives for employers and providers that create opportunities for young apprentices. We have also argued that young apprentices should not face a Level 2 English and maths exit requirement. These are practical recommendations that could change hundreds of thousands of lives.

The skills system is already helping young adults prepare for work and progress into it, with independent training providers delivering 60 per cent of youth apprenticeships alongside colleges delivering around 30 per cent. Both provider groups have a strong record of working with employers and supporting learners with different needs and starting points.

Independent providers also have a strong track record when it comes to delivering study programmes, SEND provision, supported internships, employability support and employer-led training. That’s why we must see the much-needed pre-apprenticeship programme open to any provider on the apprenticeship provider and assessment register.

The same principle applies to the report’s ambition to guarantee participation in further education for 16-19-year-olds. The goal is right. Delivering it will depend on drawing on the full range of providers and the strengths they bring, rather than assuming one type of institution can meet every learner’s needs.

Skills are only half of the equation. A young person can be prepared, motivated and ready to learn, but they still need an employer to offer the job or apprenticeship. If employers are holding back from recruitment, increasing college places alone will not solve the problem.

The review’s proposed £2,500 hiring payment, extended to levy-paying employers, and a £2,000 incentive for providers will create opportunities for young apprentices, and are welcome recognition of the role that both employers and providers play. Employers need to see a clear case for taking on someone at the start of their career and they also need to know that someone is by their side all the way through – that is the crucial role that providers play.

These measures are a welcome start, but the government will need to go further if it wants to stimulate enough employer demand.

It should look at the full cost and perceived risk of hiring, including employer national insurance contributions, and make sure businesses have the confidence and support to recruit and develop young adults.

We do have one area of real concern. Restricting apprenticeship funding for people aged 25 could backfire badly. First, it risks being the final straw for many employers who will turn away from the scheme, some permanently, just as government needs them to double down on it.

Second, by preventing progression just because someone has passed an arbitrary birthday, the lower rungs of the career ladder will be clogged up just as government needs them to be cleared.

Third, without clear routes for progression, the system risks losing the pipeline of talent and role models it needs. The government might succeed in reducing funding for over 25 apprenticeships only to find there is no increase in under 25 apprenticeship opportunities: the money will be free but have nowhere to go, a case of hitting the target but missing the point.

As government figures out its response, we will be pressing the case for a gradual transition that means they bring employers and providers with them and give themselves a chance of succeeding in reducing NEET numbers, a goal I know we all share.

 

 

Share

Explore more on these topics

No Comments

Featured jobs from FE Week jobs / Schools Week jobs

Browse more news