Skip to content
17 November 2026

Milburn: Judge colleges on students’ work readiness

Review also says 16-19 budget should rise automatically with learner numbers, and in-year growth funded for good

Billy Camden

More from this author
10 min read
|

Colleges should be judged on whether learners are ready for work, with funding linked to progression into jobs or further study, Alan Milburn’s landmark review has recommended.

The former Cabinet minister wants new work-readiness and destination measures published and used by Ofsted, the Department for Education (DfE) and mayoral strategic authorities to hold further education providers to account.

The proposals form part of his final Young People and Work report, which also calls for automatic increases to the 16 to 19 education budget in line with student numbers and a new funding premium for providers supporting young people at risk of becoming NEET.

Milburn said colleges should become England’s “principal technical and transition institution”, with more than 150,000 additional 18- to 24-year-olds participating in FE annually by 2036, across colleges and other training providers.

The report calls for apprenticeships and FE provision to be the “first priority” for education and skills investment, arguing this would have the biggest impact on reducing the number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET).

You can read our full round up of the recommendations affecting apprenticeships here.

Commissioned by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) in November 2025, the review covers education, skills, welfare and health. It aims to reduce the UK’s NEET rate from around 13 per cent to 5 per cent by 2036, although its modelling projects a rate of 6.8 per cent from the proposed reforms.

Milburn proposed an initial £500 million investment in 2027-28, funded by reprioritising existing spending, to support additional employment and mental health services and more work placements, college and apprenticeship places.

Potential sources of savings identified by the review include changes to student finance for franchised higher education and foundation-year students.

It is not yet clear which recommendations ministers will accept and implement.

New work-readiness measures

The proposed FE accountability measures would mirror a ready-for-work standard Milburn wants introduced for schools in 2028.

One measure would assess work readiness at individual learner level, with results aggregated to provider level for accountability.

A second would assess whether providers successfully support young people into their next destination and future employment.

Results would be adjusted for different learner starting points, including disadvantage, care experience and special educational needs and disabilities (SEND).

“All educational institutions should increasingly be judged not simply by who enters and what qualifications they award, but by the destinations and sustained outcomes they help their students achieve,” the report said.

Milburn argued that work readiness should include communication, collaboration and creativity, alongside practical skills such as problem-solving, timekeeping, understanding basic workplace rights and knowing how to ask for help.

Pay colleges for outcomes, not just headcounts

Milburn’s interim report, published in May, suggested colleges should be funded according to whether learners progress into jobs or further training rather than simply how many enrol.

His final report confirmed this should be the direction of travel, but stopped short of setting out how such a funding system would operate.

It called for FE college funding to move from a “simple activity-based model”, where institutions are funded according to student numbers, towards one that “also recognises and rewards outcomes and destinations”.

The change would encourage providers to focus on courses delivering the strongest labour-market results for their learners, the report said.

David Hughes, chief executive of the Association of Colleges (AoC), warned in May that using employment outcomes as a funding metric was “fraught with difficulties” because labour markets vary significantly across the country.

Responding to the final report, Hughes said: “As the report makes clear, in every country with a better system for supporting young people and with lower NEET numbers, colleges have a bigger role from 14 years of age.

“In this country, colleges are ready to step up and inspire more 14 and 15-year-olds, enrol more 16 to 19-year-olds and provide the training and skills that young people need to find good work.”

Guarantee funding keeps pace with learner numbers

Milburn said colleges should become the institutions the participation system turns to when a young person “needs a route onwards”.

They “need” additional investment, he said, but the extra money should “purchase a clearer mission”, including “actively” re-engaging 16 and 17-year-olds whose first education or training route breaks down.

The report cited evidence from AoC that colleges had to enrol 32,000 extra young people in the current academic year without additional funding.

Funding for 16 to 19 education is tied to participation forecasts made at the spending review. When learner numbers exceed those forecasts, the budget must be spread more thinly across a larger number of students, Milburn said.

He argued that colleges and other providers should be able to “bring young people back into education with confidence that their place will be adequately funded”, with greater certainty over future budgets.

Milburn urged the government to guarantee that the 16 to 19 education budget increases automatically in line with participation.

The government should also fund growth where demographic pressures, high NEET rates and local labour-market demand justify it, and support capital and workforce investment where technical provision is constrained.

Over time, FE funding should increasingly support pre-apprenticeships, apprenticeships, technical routes and level 4 and 5 higher technical education, “with a smaller share of provision focused on GCSEs and A Levels”, the report added.

Make in-year growth funding permanent

The review also called for a permanent solution to the longstanding problem of colleges absorbing the costs of recruiting additional learners during the academic year.

DfE funds colleges largely on a lagged basis, meaning providers must initially meet the costs of additional students.

In previous years, exceptional in-year growth payments were not guaranteed, with funding decisions sometimes arriving partway through the academic year. Colleges have warned that this has led some to turn prospective students away.

Ahead of the current academic year, ministers guaranteed funding for eligible exceptional growth in 2026-27.

Milburn welcomed that commitment but said it should become a permanent feature of the funding system.

He also proposed a mechanism to provide colleges with “timely, proportionate funding” for additional eligible learners enrolling after the November reference date.

“No young person should be told to wait until the following September because the funding system works to an academic-year timetable,” he said.

“Systems should adapt to the lives of young people, not require young people to adapt to the administrative convenience of systems.”

New NEET premium

Milburn also called for a “participation and work-readiness premium” for FE, initially targeted at 16 and 17-year-olds who were previously NEET or at serious risk of becoming NEET.

The funding would support outreach, mentoring, enhanced pastoral support, work preparation, employer brokerage and evidence-based re-engagement.

It should not become an unconditional uplift to college funding, the report warned.

Milburn proposed initially targeting the highest-risk learners and testing whether the premium “materially changes” participation and destinations before widening eligibility where the evidence supports doing so.

Industry-led technical colleges and UTC expansion

The review called for a mayor-led mechanism to establish new industry-led technical colleges, specialist campuses or equivalent centres.

Strategic authorities would identify gaps in local skills provision, bring together employers and education providers, and sponsor proposals for central government approval and funding where required.

The report cited Ada, the National College for Digital Skills, and the London Screen Academy as examples of specialist provision designed around particular sectors and connected to apprenticeships, further study and employment.

The proposals follow the mixed record of the previous national colleges programme, announced in 2014 for industries including high-speed rail, nuclear, onshore oil and gas, and creative industries.

Several institutions struggled with recruitment and financial pressures, while the National College for Onshore Oil and Gas was wound up without opening.

Milburn also recommended establishing a national digital “Open College” for skills, enabling learners to build up accredited modules from colleges, universities and approved providers.

It would operate across existing institutions rather than become a new provider, with funding contributions from employers and other private investors.

The review also called for expansion of University Technical Colleges (UTCs) and their newer “UTC sleeve” model, which embeds technical provision within existing secondary schools.

Milburn said UTC sleeves should become “over time a mainstream part of the school landscape”.

Outstanding FE colleges, UTC-type provision, specialist campuses and employer-backed institutions should also be enabled to expand where there is demand.

Work placements for V Levels

The report welcomed prime minister Andy Burnham’s recent announcement to expand access to substantial work placements for 16 to 18-year-olds.

Milburn said every young person undertaking a publicly funded technical or vocational study programme should have access to high-quality, structured workplace experience.

The duration should be proportionate to the length and purpose of the programme.

That would mean retaining the existing 45-day T Level industry placement requirement while introducing proportionate workplace experience for incoming V Levels, Occupational Certificates, Foundation Certificates and pre-apprenticeships.

Industry-to-FE route for teachers

A larger role for FE would require a stronger workforce, Milburn said.

He proposed a “high-status” route enabling experienced industry professionals to move into FE teaching or combine employment in their sector with part-time teaching.

Training should be funded, with incentives concentrated on occupations and areas facing the greatest shortages.

The approach could build on Taking Teaching Further, with additional incentives for prospective teachers and employers encouraged to release experienced staff to support teaching, assessment and curriculum development.

Support for care leavers

Milburn also proposed extending Pupil Premium Plus funding in full to care-experienced 17 and 18-year-olds to provide support through the end of compulsory education.

He recommended a Care Leaver Transition Allowance of £50 a week for six months, modelled on the former Education Maintenance Allowance (EMA).

It would support care leavers who are NEET or at serious risk, conditional on agreeing a participation plan covering education, employment, training or other progression activities.

Some young people could be ‘less well off at first’

The review’s wider welfare proposals include abolishing the health element of universal credit and replacing existing benefit arrangements for under-25s with a new youth allowance.

Milburn also proposed replacing personal independence payment (PIP) for under-25s with an additional cost allowance, providing non-means-tested financial support for people with significant, established and ongoing disability-related costs.

A separate local health and disability fund would cover more immediate or changing needs.

Milburn acknowledged that the reforms could make some young people “less well off at first”, although the report’s modelling projects that young people’s net incomes would rise by more than £2 billion overall once all the reforms are taken into account.

He said existing PIP recipients with established and ongoing additional costs who already combine the benefit with education or work should retain the financial support enabling their participation during the transition.

They should not have to interrupt their studies or demonstrate economic inactivity to secure the appropriate entitlement under the new system.

Milburn proposed that existing payments should continue while individuals move to the replacement arrangements, with benefit changes following investment in employment and education support.

The new system would be introduced subject to legislation, with phased implementation for new claimants and personalised transitions for existing recipients.

Ministers are expected to respond to Milburn’s recommendations later today.

Share

Explore more on these topics

No Comments

Featured jobs from FE Week jobs / Schools Week jobs

Browse more news