Skip to content
19 November 2026

V Levels must earn trust A Levels built over generations

Rushing V Levels risks undermining the very parity of esteem they are intended to achieve
Andrew Parkin Guest Contributor

Principal of St Dominic’s Sixth Form College and chair of ASCL’s sixth form advisory group

4 min read
|

The level 3 landscape is entering a period of significant change. Alongside A Levels, T Levels are becoming more established, while proposed new V Levels are intended to create clearer pathways for young people after 16.

The ambition behind these reforms is understandable. For decades, governments have sought to address the challenge of achieving genuine parity of esteem between academic and technical education. As ASCL has argued, the deeply ingrained perception that academic routes carry greater status than technical and vocational routes must shift if we are to achieve that goal. Without this change, efforts to build the skills base the country needs are undermined and the talents of many young people risk not being fully recognised or developed.

However, parity of esteem cannot simply be created through qualification reform. It must be earned over time through confidence, credibility and sustained support from employers, universities, schools, colleges, learners and families. If policymakers are serious about creating qualifications with lasting value, there is much they can learn from the enduring success of A Levels.

As principal of St Dominic’s Sixth Form College, a high-performing specialist A Level provider, I see first-hand the continuing demand for academic study. My commitment to A Levels is unwavering. They remain one of the most respected qualifications in the world and continue to be the gold standard of academic study before higher education.

A key reason for their enduring popularity is the flexibility they offer. A Levels allow young people to pursue subjects they find intellectually stimulating while delaying specialisation until they are more certain about their future direction.

It is a rare opportunity for a student to combine physics, classics and mathematics, or music, geography and sociology, simply because those subjects interest them. One of the great strengths of sixth form education is the ability to accommodate ambitious and sometimes unconventional subject combinations. In an education system increasingly focused on specialisation, that freedom retains enormous value.

A Levels are also respected because they are rigorous. The sustained application of knowledge and skills over two years develops intellectual depth, independent learning and critical thinking. Their reputation has been built over decades through consistent standards and a clear purpose. Any qualification seeking similar levels of public confidence will also need to establish a reputation for rigour, reliability and quality.

Perhaps most importantly, A Levels help young people develop attributes that will serve them throughout their lives. Success requires resilience, determination, self-discipline and commitment. These qualities matter enormously in a labour market being reshaped by technological change, artificial intelligence and economic uncertainty.

None of this diminishes the importance of technical and vocational education. High-quality technical pathways are essential if we are to meet future workforce needs and provide opportunities for young people with different talents, interests and ambitions.

However, there should be caution about the pace at which new qualifications are introduced. If V Levels are to succeed, they will need more than a place within funding systems, performance measures or UCAS tariff tables. They will need genuine brand recognition.

A Levels are recognised and understood by virtually every parent, employer and university. Young people know what they represent and the opportunities they can unlock. That recognition was not created overnight. It has been built over generations and is a major reason why the qualification continues to command such confidence and esteem.

The experience of T Levels illustrates how challenging this process can be. Although they offer considerable strengths, it has taken years to build awareness and understanding among learners, employers and the wider public. Establishing a trusted qualification brand takes time.

For that reason, there is a risk that the introduction of V Levels is being rushed. A longer lead-in period could have helped schools, colleges, employers and universities develop a clearer understanding of their purpose and value. If parity of esteem is the goal, policymakers must recognise that esteem is built gradually through consistency, quality and trust.

The future level 3 landscape should see A Levels, T Levels and high-quality vocational qualifications sitting alongside one another. But if V Levels are to enjoy the same confidence that A Levels command today, they must be given the time needed to establish their identity, earn trust and build a reputation that endures. That is perhaps the most important lesson that the success of A Levels can teach us.

 

Share

Explore more on these topics

No Comments

Featured jobs from FE Week jobs / Schools Week jobs

Browse more news