University apprenticeships to be externally assessed


Degree apprenticeships will have to assessed with an industry expert who is independent of the university, under new proposals published today.

The Institute for Apprenticeships and Technical Education has launched a consultation on changes to how degree apprenticeships are created, run and examined.

One of their proposals is for the end-point assessments of all degree apprenticeships to include input from a “trained individuals with appropriate occupational and industry expertise,” independent of the higher education institution.

Gillian Keegan

That EPA will also have to be integrated with the degree assessment, following concerns from skills minister Gillian Keegan the two forms of examination were separated “by a long way”.

Plans to let employers mandate degrees in apprenticeships where graduating is necessary for the occupation, and safeguards to stop existing programmes being “rebadged” as apprenticeships are also covered by this consultation.

Keegan today said IfATE’s proposals “will help make sure degree apprenticeships continue to meet the skills needs of employers and create even more opportunity to earn while you learn for people across the country”.


Assessor changes will ‘address conflicts’ in apprenticeship assessment

The current rules on degree apprenticeship assessments do not insist assessors come from outside the higher education institution.

They do not even force universities to use someone from a different department to the apprentice.

IfATE hopes their proposed tightening of the rules around external assessors will “address the conflicts inherent in integrated degree apprenticeship assessment,” the consultation document reads.

Integrating degree examinations and EPA is intended to reduce the burden on apprentices while also providing a single check of their competence and whether they have met the requirements for the degree.

It is also meant to “achieve better alignment between the on- and off-the-job training”.

IfATE does not intend to prescribe how employers and providers integrate the two assessments, but will set a principle, provide examples of best practice and support trailblazer groups when they are developing a standard.

Yet the institute does insist it “not be possible to pass either the degree or the apprenticeship in isolation from one another”.

University Vocational Awards Council chief executive Adrian Anderson said his organisation had “long championed” the integrated model, including the use of individuals with appropriate occupational and industry expertise.

He says the model “is being used for some of the most significant apprenticeships,” including the level 6 police constable course.


Employers mandating degrees could flood apprenticeship market

The consultation also proposes employers be handed powers to “mandate degrees in apprenticeship standards” if graduate status is a labour market requirement for an occupation.

Under the current system, apprenticeships can only include degrees if specific bachelor’s or master’s qualifications are needed for the occupation.

It could lead to a further flooding of degree apprenticeships onto the apprenticeship market.

The report notes how degree apprenticeships have swelled since they launched in 2015, with over 30,000 starts on apprenticeships at levels 6 and 7, including over 20,000 starts on degree apprenticeships, in 2019/20.

In just the first six months of 2020/21, there were 5,853 starts on the level 7 senior leader degree course, 1,731 on the level 6 police constable degree programme, and 1,434 on the level 6 chartered manager course.

Level 6 and 7 courses which currently do not have a mandated degree may be able to become degree apprenticeships if their trailblazer group “considers it appropriate,” the impact assessment report states.

Over the past few years, Ofsted chief inspector Amanda Spielman has frequently expressed concerns about a trend she raised in her 2018 annual report of “existing graduate schemes being rebadged as apprenticeships”.


IfATE hopes to ‘rule out rebadging’

In the consultation, IfATE says it will publish guidance on how providers can ensure off-the-job training (the degree) complements their on-the-job work to combat this.

The quango will also make providers validate degrees which are specifically for an occupation against IfATE’s “employer-specified” knowledge, skills and behaviours for that occupation.

Jennifer Coupland

“The idea is to rule out degree apprenticeships that amount to no more than rebadging of existing full-time or part-time degree programmes,” the institute has said.

IfATE chief executive Jennifer Coupland has said since her organisation launched in 2017, “we’ve seen lots of examples of good practice, which we want to make the norm across the whole programme”.

The consultation is being run through IfATE’s website and closes at midnight on 16 September.

More from this theme

Apprenticeships, Cabinet reshuffle

Red tape forces small firms to turn their backs on apprenticeship cash incentives

The scheme this week received its second extension from the chancellor

Billy Camden
Apprenticeships, Conservative Party Conference, Kickstart

Sunak extends apprenticeship employer incentives and Kickstart scheme

Apprentice incentives will run until end of January while Kickstart will go until end of March

Billy Camden
Apprenticeships, Ofsted

Inclusivity and diversity apprentice panel helps provider gain top Ofsted marks

The provider's online community platform has impressed the watchdg and improved attainment

Fraser Whieldon

New campaign aims to raise apprentice pay

Organisers hope the initiative will help tackle the high dropout rate in apprenticeships that has troubled ministers

Billy Camden

DfE and provider locked in legal battle over terminated contracts

It is believed to be the first time a training provider has taken the DfE all the way to...

Billy Camden
Apprenticeships, Ofsted

Ofsted raps business school over management apprenticeships

A high-profile business school that made millions of pounds by quickly recruiting more than 800 management apprentices has been...

Billy Camden

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply to Mandy Crawford-Lee Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. Benjamin Feighery

    The answer here seems simple, do the same as Policing is doing and have the EPA be a module that must be passed for the awarding of the overall degree… that will also stop learner’s withdrawing from the apprenticeship or refusing to take part in the EPA once they have been awarded the degree element.

    As for the independent industry expert being involved, good luck finding volunteers for that, I guess this is yet another unexpected cost that providers will have to bear within the bounds of the funding bands.