Ofsted reports discomfort at ‘blurred boundaries’ between UTC learners and staff

Inspectors drop 'outstanding' UTC Reading to 'inadequate' in new report

Inspectors drop 'outstanding' UTC Reading to 'inadequate' in new report

31 Mar 2023, 16:21

More from this author

Ofsted has reported instances of racist language from students and learners’ discomfort from “blurred” boundaries between staff and pupils at a university technical college in Reading.

UTC Reading, run by Activate Learning Education Trust, was rated ‘inadequate’ by inspectors in a report published today following a visit in February – its first visit in eight years because of the exemption from routine inspections as a result of its previous ‘outstanding’ rating.

The watchdog reported that “the boundaries between staff and pupils are blurred. Pupils describe staff as ‘more like friends than teachers’. Some pupils told inspectors that this makes them feel uncomfortable.”

It continued: “Several pupils made serious allegations about staff directly to inspectors during the inspection. Too many pupils told inspectors that they had not felt able to report them to school staff. Pupils told inspectors that, in one case when they did report serious concerns to staff, these were dismissed.”

Elsewhere, inspectors found that in class “many pupils talk over their teachers” which goes unchallenged, and said that not all students felt they could report serious safeguarding concerns because “they have little confidence staff will act”.

The education watchdog said that teaching was inconsistent which resulted in gaps in students’ learning.

Ofsted said that attendance for sixth form students was too low, explaining that while leaders have set out consequences for those not attending many students were not on board.

Inspectors reported use of racist language from some pupils, with staff not always taking effective action on inappropriate behaviour.

However, Ofsted said that trust leaders had a clear vision and were beginning to support the 14-19 UTC well having identified that standards were slipping, albeit acknowledging this was very recent.

It said that the chief executive and chair of trustees had made some immediate changes to tackle weaknesses but said that until the inspection leaders and governors had not realised the extent of those problems.

A spokesperson from the Activate Learning Education Trust – the schools arm of Activate Learning which runs the UTC – said the trust was disappointed with the result but accepted the report’s findings and “take full responsibility for the shortcomings identified”.

The trust apologised to students, parents and the wider school community and pledged regular updates on its improvement efforts.

The spokesperson added: “The safety and wellbeing of our students is our top priority, and we have taken swift and significant action, including appointing a new executive principal, to address the issues as a matter of urgency.

“We recognise this news may be concerning, however we want to reassure everyone that we are taking the feedback serious, and are absolutely committed to ensuring that UTC Reading is, once more, recognised as a good and high-performing school.”

Wayne Edwards, principal at the ‘good’ rated UTC Heathrow which the trust also runs, is UTC Reading’s new executive principal, and had served as the college’s vice principal for four years until July 2017.

The UTC, which opened in 2013, had 499 learners on the school’s roll, of which 298 were sixth form students at the time of the inspection. It has a capacity of 600 learners.

Simon Connell, chief executive of the Baker Dearing Educational Trust which supports UTCs said it was working with UTC Reading to address the “disappointing outcome”.

“We are reassured that swift and decisive action is being taken to address the concerns raised in the report. In particular, Wayne Edwards’ appointment as executive principal of UTC Reading, following his success at UTC Heathrow, gives us confidence that the safety of pupils is a top priority.”

He said that three quarters of UTCs had been rated at least ‘good’ since the pandemic, stressing that UTC Reading’s report is “very much an exception”.

More from this theme

Ofsted

Essex sixth form college celebrates Ofsted upgrade to ‘outstanding’

Principal describes the feat as a 'ringing endorsement' of 'high quality work'

Billy Camden
Ofsted

Ofsted snubs FE providers from sub-judgements website change

The move to add sub-judgements to school profiles on its website has been planned for at least two months...

Josh Mellor
Bootcamps, Ofsted

Ofsted slates US firm with £5m DfE bootcamps contract

Whistleblower flagged concerns last year but no action was taken

Billy Camden
Ofsted

Land-based college retains ‘outstanding’ Ofsted grade

Hartpury College celebrates another grade 1, six years after it last achieved the feat

Anviksha Patel
Colleges, Ofsted

Waltham Forest named London’s only ‘outstanding’ general FE college

Inspectors heaped praise on the college for helping students to "flourish"

Josh Mellor
Apprenticeships, Ofsted

Uni caught short after fast-tracking degree apprenticeship for NHS

Ofsted found some employers' operational needs for advanced clinical practitioners weren't being met

Josh Mellor

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

7 Comments

  1. J Hornsey

    Our son had to leave due to extreme anxiety, we were threatened with a £2000 for him not attending due to everything described above four years ago, we took him out of the school resulting in him having no exam results.

  2. Parent

    Its a shame there was an 8 year gap for an ofsted inspection. There were issues when my son was there 2018-2020. A lot of disruption in class and behaviour issues from students. Hope they got those sorted now.

    • Teacher

      Are we claiming that educational establishments up and down the country are much different to this? Especially colleges?
      As a teacher, I removed my son to be homeschooled for the messages of inequality, abuse and hierarchy that he was getting amongst other factors. As a teacher, I’ll be removing myself from the ‘system’ by the end of the academic year.

  3. Phil Hatton

    Rarely get comments from parents and staff like these and a shame that if internal complaints did not work that they didn’t raise them with Ofsted. What on earth were governors doing? There should be some form of learner forum involving governors while walking the campus and talking to learners occasionally would have uncovered so much.

    • I made Internal complaints when my daughter was at UTC and they were not dealt with, then raised with Ofsted as you suggest and Ofsted ignored me and told me to go back to the school. This school had no controls in place.

  4. Ex teacher

    Unfortunately for the pupils this Ofsted is spot on. Poor expectations of pupils, who wander in and out of classes, causing huge disruption to learning and some longer standing staff who lack appropriate professional boundaries. This undermines the cohort of pupils, many of which are lost in an environment where they have relative freedom to behave how they like unchallenged. staff have no support from a complacent senior team who believe their own hype from a previous outstanding grade and ignore and constructive comments from staff who raise concerns.