Parents win payout after council SEND transport failure

Derby City Council agrees to pay over £4,000 to families for ‘impractical’ offer

Derby City Council agrees to pay over £4,000 to families for ‘impractical’ offer

A local council has been ordered to pay thousands to three families for failing to help SEND learners get to college.

Derby City Council has agreed to pay £4,240 after the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman investigated three complaints that the council’s transport offer for vulnerable students was “impractical and unaffordable”.

The investigation, published yesterday, found that the council had applied its post-16 SEND transport policy “too rigidly” and one mum had “no alternative” but to give up work to drive her child to school.

Derby City Council said it does not comment on individual cases but has taken “swift action” to implement all the Ombudsman recommendations.

Cash-strapped councils have increasingly introduced annual charges to families to contribute to post-16 SEND transport in a bid to fill their financial black holes, a previous FE Week investigation found.

Councils also alternatively offer personal travel budgets, which provides fixed regular payments to families to arrange suitable transport for their children with specialist needs. 

But a number of specialist colleges have previously raised serious safeguarding concerns of the safety of the actual transport provided, with safety breaches such as blind students abandoned by taxis reported.

The complaints

The investigation report outlined each of the three complaints to the council over its offer of personal travel budgets (PTB).

The first was from a parent named Ms X, who criticised that Derby council’s personal travel budget of £1,600 per year was an “unaffordable” contribution towards the cost of her child’s transport. Ms X said the only viable transport option was a taxi, which was £80 per day. 

As a result, she told the ombudsman that she had “no alternative” but to give up work and to take her child to school, causing her to rack up debt and lose her support network at work.

The second parent, Ms Y, also complained the PTB was “too low” for her fourth child to take a taxi to college so they were dropped off late and collected early, causing anxiety and the learner missing out on special education.  

Ms Y also complained to the education secretary who found the council applied the policy “too rigidly” and asked it to reconsider how it applies exceptional circumstances. 

The council eventually organised a taxi after the start of the 2024/25 academic year and offered to reimburse Ms Y’s mileage and retain the PTB as a financial remedy. She told the Ombudsman it does not reflect the “level of injustice” caused over a whole school year.

Meanwhile, Ms Z’s complaint said the council wrongly applied a policy that did not cover the age group of her child, who was an adult learner. 

She also complained that the annual PTB of £4,240 offered did not cover shared transport, which cost £144 per day – a shortfall of over £11,800 per year. The council full reimbursed her costs and offered to pay for a taxi.

The investigation

The Ombudsman found in all three complaints that the council had decided it was necessary for it to provide support, but did not then check whether the solution offered “did the job” of actually getting students to school or college.

The council failed to consider whether the PTBs were affordable for each family, it ruled.

It recommended the council apologise and offer compensation to all three families. 

It ordered Derby City Council to pay Ms X £1,000 for the distress it caused. It advised Ms Y to be paid £250 for the distress, £1,240 for the extra time spent taking her child to college, and £1,600 for the learners’ missed attendance.

The council was also made to pay £150 to Ms Z for the distress.

Amerdeep Somal, the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman said: “Councils must demonstrate they have considered the options offered to individual families, who are entitled to transport support, that actually provide a practical, safe and affordable solution to allow them to attend. They should not be given a simple ‘one size fits all’ blanket offer.

“Derby City Council has now accepted my recommendations to improve its service, including revising its policy. I hope this will mean it properly considers families’ applications in future.”

Councillor Paul Hezelgrave, Derby City Council cabinet member for children, young people and skills, said: “While the council is unable to comment on individual cases, we accept the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman’s findings in these three cases and have taken swift action to implement all recommendations set out in the report.

“The council offers high-quality home-to-school travel assistance to more than 1,000 children and young people every day. Through ongoing service and delivery improvements, we’re committed to making sure all eligible children, young people, and their families consistently receive excellent support.”

Latest education roles from

Principal & Chief Executive – Bath College

Principal & Chief Executive – Bath College

Dodd Partners

IT Technician

IT Technician

Harris Academy Morden

Teacher of Geography

Teacher of Geography

Harris Academy Orpington

Lecturer/Assessor in Electrical

Lecturer/Assessor in Electrical

South Gloucestershire and Stroud College

Director of Management Information Systems (MIS)

Director of Management Information Systems (MIS)

South Gloucestershire and Stroud College

Exams Assistant

Exams Assistant

Richmond and Hillcroft Adult & Community College

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

Reshaping the New Green Skills Landscape

The UK government is embarking on a transformative journey to reshape its skills landscape, placing a significant emphasis on...

Advertorial
Sponsored post

Safe to speak, ready to act: SaferSpace targets harassment and misconduct in education 

In an era where safeguarding and compliance are firmly in the spotlight, education providers face a growing responsibility: to...

Advertorial
Sponsored post

Screening for the cognitive needs of apprentices is essential – does it matter if the process is engaging?

Engagement should be the first priority in cognitive assessment. An engaging assessment is an inclusive assessment — when cognitive...

Advertorial
Sponsored post

Skills Bootcamps Are Changing – What FE Colleges Must Know 

Skills Bootcamps are evolving as funding moves to local control and digital skills trends shift. Code Institute, an Ofsted...

Code Institute

More from this theme

Ofsted, SEND

‘Wholly unsuitable’ EHCPs, long waits for help: SEND inspection failures revealed

Ofsted proposes ‘pool of inspectors’ and report cards to improve SEND inspections as shortcomings revealed

Jack Dyson
SEND

SEND job scheme extended after recruitment success

Flagship SEND programme rewarded with extra cash after target to double enrolments ‘reached’

Anviksha Patel
SEND

‘Worry’ over as doomed SEND college is saved by Big Issue

The 'outstanding' college feared closure after an eviction notice from Hounslow Council

Josh Mellor
SEND

Colleges directed to enrol SEND students despite inability to meet needs

AoC report finds scale of local authorities overruling college objections in particular cases

Anviksha Patel

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *