Ministers have refused to provide public funding for a new apprenticeship designed to tackle fraud, fuelling concerns that specialist occupational standards are being squeezed out under the government’s funding priorities. The fraud control specialist apprenticeship, which has been developed over more than two years led by the Cabinet Office, will be approved for delivery next month but carry a government funding band of £0. The decision was made despite Skills England recommending a funding band of up to £7,000 for the standard. Work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden rejected that recommendation, with the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) later confirming that employers would have to meet the full cost of training themselves. Employers involved in developing the standard told FE Week they were left in “sheer disbelief” and had failed to overturn the decision. The move has raised fresh questions about the future of specialist apprenticeships as ministers review the country’s 700-plus standards in an effort to streamline the system. It comes just weeks after the government reversed plans to scrap five maritime apprenticeships following pressure from employers, unions and MPs. Skills England had earmarked the standards for retirement because of low numbers of starts. But ministers agreed to retain all five after political and industry lobbying convinced them of their importance to specialist industries and regional skills pipelines. The government agency has made clear that it is exploring what apprenticeships in other industries could be surplus to requirements, including those with low starts and in areas where there is too much overlap and duplication between standards. But experts have urged officials to recognise that there are heritage skills and niche apprenticeships where small numbers are to be expected, and which they said must not be disproportionately affected. It is understood that Skills England is now considering, through its “skills for work programme”, whether the requirements of some specialist occupations could be met through broader apprenticeship standards that can then be tailored by training providers and employers to different industry contexts. There are concerns that DWP and Skills England plan to quietly retire specialist apprenticeships without sufficient consultation and transparency. Shock and disbelief The fraud control specialist apprenticeship was developed by a trailblazer group involving employers and the Public Sector Fraud Authority (PSFA), the government body responsible for leading work to tackle public sector fraud. An industry representative involved in its development told FE Week the group was shocked by the “incredible” decision considering the “clear need” for skills in fraud prevention and control. Fraud is estimated to cost the UK economy between £220 billion and £350 billion annually, according to the source, who said employers have repeatedly highlighted the need for greater expertise in preventing fraud rather than simply investigating it after it occurred. A note of a meeting with DWP officials, obtained by FE Week, states that the department’s new priorities for the growth and skills levy are increasing economic growth in key sectors and tackling the number of 16 to 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training. Officials told the trailblazer group that the fraud control apprenticeship did not fit those priorities. A source close to the apprenticeship’s development, who asked not to be named, said the justification was difficult to understand. “I don’t think you need to be a genius to be able to see the link between prevention and then economic growth,” they said. PSFA is understood to have been frustrated by delays in receiving clarification about the decision. On top of this, employer representatives were initially invited to a meeting with DWP officials to discuss the funding position, but the meeting was changed to an officials-only session. The apprenticeship has now been completed for delivery, and the trailblazer will see if there is privately funded demand for the programme. If there is no demand, the group hopes this insight will build the case to revisit the funding decision down the line. Starts can commence from 18 December. Skills England banner shows fraud control specialist apprenticeship will only be privately funded Another source close to the development of the standard said: “The reaction was one of sheer disbelief. Fraud control is a key focus from the government and we all believed this would have been a high-performing apprenticeship.” The DWP defended the decision. The department told FE Week that the government was reforming the apprenticeship system to support those at the start of their working life and meet the skills needs of key sectors, “so funding must be prioritised”. They added that the fraud control standard was already in the late development stages when this reprioritisation took place, and the funding decision “reflects this”. Asked whether other apprenticeship standards were being considered for similar funding restrictions, the DWP said further updates would be shared in due course. The department published fresh guidance on privately funded apprenticeships last month, which stated that while around 1 per cent of apprenticeships are currently privately funded, it is “expected that the volume of privately funded learners may increase, following the change to the funding of level 7 apprenticeship provision and other standards”. Sixteen popular mid-management apprenticeships were defunded this year.