The Treasury should stop withholding hundreds of millions of pounds in apprenticeship levy funding, employers should pay more to train older apprentices and a new pre-apprenticeship programme should be created, Alan Milburn has recommended. The former Cabinet minister’s review of youth unemployment also called for the requirement for young apprentices to pass level 2 English and maths exams to complete their apprenticeship to be scrapped, alongside increased financial incentives for employers and training providers. Milburn outlined the proposals in his final report, ‘From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation’, which sets out a 10-year deal between young people and the state. His review, commissioned by the government last year, covers education, skills, welfare and health, and aims to reduce the UK’s not in education, employment or training (NEET) rate from 13 per cent to 5 per cent by 2036. You can read our full round up of the recommendations affecting the wider further education and college sector here. Here are the review’s proposals relating specifically to apprenticeships. It is not yet clear whether the government will accept and implement all the recommendations. Return apprenticeships to their core purpose Apprenticeship starts among 16 to 24-year-olds have fallen by around 40 per cent over the past decade, while the number of young people starting level 2 apprenticeships has collapsed by 73 per cent. Milburn concluded that apprenticeships should be the “largest education and skills priority” arising from his review. He said demand for apprenticeships “massively” outweighs supply and called for them to be returned to their “core purpose” as a “route for young people into skilled work”. The report argued that employers have made rational decisions to use apprenticeship levy funding, now called the growth and skills levy, to retrain existing and older workers rather than recruit younger staff. This has left England with low youth participation compared with other countries. It proposed increasing annual apprenticeship starts among under-25s from 172,000 in 2024-25 to 270,000 by 2036-37, with the aim of doubling the number of young people achieving an apprenticeship over the next decade. By then, around 35 per cent of each cohort should have started an apprenticeship by the age of 25, the report said. Milburn also wants the apprenticeship achievement rate to rise from around 65 per cent to 80 per cent, resulting in approximately 215,000 young people completing an apprenticeship each year. Abolish the Treasury topslice To help fund this expansion, Milburn called for all funding receipts raised by the apprenticeship levy to be released for apprenticeship training. He said the government must be “honest” with employers that the apprenticeship levy is a payroll tax, rather than a hypothecated tax ringfenced for apprenticeships. As FE Week readers will be aware, the government sets an apprenticeship budget that is generally lower than the receipts it receives from levy payments by employers. The Treasury retains the difference. Unofficial estimates suggest this gap will be around £800 million in 2026-27, but Milburn put the figure closer to £460 million. He said the government should set the annual English apprenticeship budget at the full value of English levy receipts and allow it to grow alongside those receipts. “In other words, the existing Treasury topslice of apprenticeship funding should be removed and those resources should be ploughed into apprenticeship expansion,” the report said. Milburn recognised this would be a “significant fiscal choice” but argued that a government “serious about rebuilding apprenticeships as a route for young people has to fund the ambition it sets”. “This has been a key ask of business and one I support,” he added. The report also proposed replacing notional employer levy balances and levy transfers over time with a “direct funding model aligned to employer demand and government priorities”. Make employers pay more for older apprentices Milburn said releasing the Treasury topslice should allow apprenticeships to be reorientated towards young people by providing 100 per cent funding from levy proceeds for under-25s, while reducing government contributions towards training older apprentices. His report confirmed a proposal that FE Week reported was under consideration last month, that employers should be required to pay 25 per cent of training costs for apprentices aged over 25, with the government covering the remaining 75 per cent. The savings would then be used to “increase funding for young people”. Milburn added that, depending on progress towards expanding youth apprenticeships and the availability of additional public funding, the government should be prepared to reduce its contribution to 50 per cent by 2031-32 to ensure the ambition for young people is met. Create a ‘clear’ pre-apprenticeship programme The report also urged the government to introduce a “clear” pre-apprenticeship programme “at scale” that leads into an apprenticeship, skilled work or further technical study. Milburn said this was a key feature missing from England’s system compared with countries with strong technical education routes. The programme should be based on level 1 provision and the government’s new level 2 occupational certificates, creating a “single, clear occupational route” for study between the ages of 16 and 19. “They should normally combine English and maths where required, sector-relevant technical learning, work-readiness support and substantial employer experience, with placements proportionate to the length and purpose of the programme,” the report said. Milburn said colleges should be the “principal providers” for 16 to 18-year-olds, with access continuing for older young adults who “require the same bridge”. He proposed an initial 25,000 places. The government introduced foundation apprenticeships last year as a route for young people not yet ready for a full apprenticeship. But the programme attracted just 160 starts in its first eight months, raising questions about how a new, much larger pre-apprenticeship offer would attract learners and employers. Axe the English and maths exit rule Another proposed change would remove the requirement for 16 to 18-year-old apprentices to pass level 2 English and maths exams to complete their apprenticeship. The rule was scrapped for apprentices aged 19 and over in February 2025. Milburn said apprentices would still be expected to study the subjects alongside their training, but argued that making exam passes a completion requirement can trap learners in “repeated failure, block progression and make employers less willing to offer opportunities”. He recognised that achieving level 2 English and maths is not a requirement for completing other 16 to 19 study programmes. “Government should remove this disparity for apprenticeships,” the report said. Give cash incentives to providers Milburn also proposed a “significant scaling up” of financial support for employers recruiting young apprentices and training providers that prioritise generating opportunities for young people. The current hiring payment available to eligible non-levy paying employers when they recruit new apprentices aged 16 to 24, introduced last month, should increase from £2,000 to £2,500, he said. The incentive should also be extended to levy-paying employers. Alongside this, the report proposed a new £2,000 payment for the training provider. There is little detail on how the provider incentive would operate, including what organisations would need to do to qualify. “The employer payment recognises the wage, supervision and first-job costs involved in taking on a young person. The provider payment rewards the organisations that generate opportunities, engage employers, recruit young labour-market entrants and support them to completion,” the report said. Give 10% of the apprenticeship budget to local leaders Milburn said the apprenticeship funding model should remain national across England to avoid major businesses that employ large numbers of apprentices having to deal with different approaches across the country. However, he proposed allocating an initial 10 per cent of the apprenticeship budget each year to mayoral and other strategic authorities. The money would be used to “strengthen employer engagement, generate opportunities, fund training costs, respond to local skills shortages and connect young people to sectors with growing demand”. This would provide a longer-term funding source for local apprenticeship brokerage services announced by the chancellor recently. Strengthen Find an Apprenticeship service Lastly, Milburn said the route into apprenticeships needs to become “dramatically simpler”. He described the current system, in which apprenticeships are advertised by different employers and providers at different times of the year, as a “maze”. The government should strengthen its Find an Apprenticeship website as the “national vacancy backbone”, while every strategic authority should establish a “simple, UCAS-style local access point” through which young people can see the education, training and apprenticeship opportunities available in their area.