Apprenticeships, Awarding

Nostalgia is not a strategy to navigate assessment evolution

Mark Carney’s catchphrase applies as much to apprenticeships as Western powers in the Trump era – we must move forward and change, says Steve Smith

Mark Carney’s catchphrase applies as much to apprenticeships as Western powers in the Trump era – we must move forward and change, says Steve Smith

1 Mar 2026, 7:00

The further education and skills sector is facing one of the most significant shifts in its recent history. 

The move from end-point assessment towards a new, principles-driven apprenticeship assessment model is more than a technical tweak, it is a fundamental change to how we think about quality, assurance and trust.

In a recent speech at Davos, Mark Carney, Canada’s prime minister, reminded global leaders that “nostalgia is not a strategy”. 

That phrase has stayed with me because it resonates so strongly with where our sector now stands. 

It is understandable to look back at what felt familiar and certain, but the reality is the old model is not coming back.

The question is not whether change will happen, but how we will choose to respond to it.

This new assessment landscape brings big challenges. It asks training providers and awarding organisations to rethink delivery models, build new capability and have confidence in different approaches to assessment and marking.

And, at the heart of this reform sits a non-negotiable responsibility, protecting the integrity of occupational competence. 

In the STEM and digital sectors SIAS supports, the industry voice has been clear and consistent that reform cannot come at the expense of rigour.  

Employers rely on apprenticeship standards as a mark of readiness and they need confidence. Trust is hard won but easily lost. 

But acknowledging the challenges should not make us cautious about change. It should sharpen our focus on getting this right!  

Within that responsibility sit significant opportunities to design assessments that are better aligned to learning, more responsive to employers, and more embedded within programmes rather than bolted on at the end.

We need to shift from a defensive posture

To make this work, mindset matters. We need to shift from a defensive posture to a constructive one; from seeing change as something being done to us, to recognising it as something we can actively shape.

We must all lean into this moment, and I know the awarding sector is driven by a simple principle: putting providers, learners and employers at the heart of our approach.  

Greater provider involvement in assessment can strengthen relevance and responsiveness, and it can co-exist within a system that protects quality and standards.

Awarding organisations that design dual assessment strategies flexible enough to support greater provider ownership, while still offering awarding organisation-led delivery where needed, are enabling genuine choice.  

They recognise a simple reality: providers are starting from different places. Some are ready to take on more control, while others face structural, regulatory or capability constraints as they navigate transition. A one-size-fits-all approach will not work.

I believe our role as awarding organisations, therefore, is not to dictate the model but to create a framework that allows for collaboration, progression and confidence over time.

If we approach this transition with discipline as well as ambition, then we have the opportunity to build a model that combines flexibility with credibility, that supports innovation while safeguarding standards. An approach that earns the continued trust of employers, regulators and, most importantly, learners.

Leadership at this moment is about stepping forward with clarity, positivity and purpose. 

We need to let go of legacy positions. Nostalgia is not a strategy. What is required now is deliberate evolution, grounded in standards but responsive to the future.

Latest education roles from

Finance Director – South Devon College

Finance Director – South Devon College

FEA

Assistant Principal – Adult Skills – West London College

Assistant Principal – Adult Skills – West London College

FEA

Assistant Principal – West London College

Assistant Principal – West London College

FEA

Head of Finance

Head of Finance

Jewish Community Academy Trust

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

What you missed in the post-16 consultation response

With the publication of the government’s response to the post-16 skills pathway consultation, there’s been lots of media outlets...

Advertorial
Sponsored post

Apprenticeship reform: An opportunity to future‑proof skills and unlock career pathways

The apprenticeship landscape is undergoing one of its most significant transformations in decades, and that’s good news for learners,...

Advertorial
Sponsored post

Stronger learners start with supported educators

Further Education (FE) and skills professionals show up every day to change lives. They problem-solve, multi-task and can carry...

Advertorial
Sponsored post

Preparing learners for work, not just exams: the case for skills-led learning

As further education (FE) continues to adapt to shifting labour markets, digital transformation and widening participation agendas, providers are...

Advertorial

More from this theme

Apprenticeships

Civil servants raced to beat their own level 7 apprenticeship deadline

'Contradictory' government behaviour contributed to level 7 starts rush before funding ended in January

Anviksha Patel
Apprenticeships

Apprenticeship units funding model is ‘stacked against providers’ 

Officials warn training firms that funding could be withdrawn with just four weeks' notice

Billy Camden
Apprenticeships

Apprenticeship budget to rise to £3.3bn amid savings scramble

Allocation for 2026-27 will increase by 5.8% - but Treasury top-slice still hits £700m

Billy Camden
Apprenticeships

DWP caps new starts on defunded apprenticeships to stop recruitment rush

Funding axe will also kick in immediately for providers with no recorded starts on affected standards in 2024-25 and...

Billy Camden

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *