Skills Show ‘light goes on’

The third national Skills Show kicked off in Birmingham on Thursday (November 13) with have-a-gos, careers advice, skills competitions and the finals of the National Apprenticeship Awards.

At a dinner welcoming exhibitors, visitors and VIPs to the show on Wednesday, Skills Show patron Theo Paphitis said he was delighted to be returning for the third year in a row.

“The first time I came to the Skills Show, it was like a light coming on,” he said.

Highbury College, Portsmouth on the Hairdressing Showcase stage
Highbury College, Portsmouth on the Hairdressing Showcase stage

“Even as someone in business, I find as a parent I don’t always know how to advise my children on what they’re going to do with the rest of their lives, so having something like this is terrific.

“We should have been doing this years ago.”

As if making up for lost time, the first day of the show had more than 50 exhibitors and have-a-gos ensuring there was plenty to inspire the first batch of the Skills Show’s predicted 75,000 visitors, many from Midland primary schools.

Among the visitors was Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg and FE Week caught up with him during his tour of the show.

“It’s been absolutely brilliant,” he said. “I was here for a day last year and I just really wanted to come back again this year.

Singer Alex Moir on the main BBC stage
Singer Alex Moir on the main BBC stage

“Yes, it’s a skills showcase but it’s also actually a celebration of a way of learning which I think we should do more of in this country — learning by doing.

“It’s about metaphorically and literally getting your hands dirty, learning things from the people who are mentoring you and learning some practical skills not just conceptual ones.

“We should be valuing both vocational and academic qualifications equally and I think that’s what’s on ample display at the Skills Show.”

Head of the National Apprenticeship Service (NAS) Sue Husband was also among the first day’s visitors.

“It’s just been so invigorating — that’s the word I’d use,” she said.

Theo-police-box
Skills Show patron Theo Paphitis tours the show floor

“It just hasn’t stopped and it’s been brilliant seeing the young people’s faces — some of them were just getting so excited.

When Ms Husband spoke to FE Week, it was too early to tell how many visitors had passed through the NEC during the first day, but she said early indications suggested it had been “better than expected”.

“In terms of the timings, people are getting here earlier now,” she said.

“Usually there’s an hour or so at the beginning where it’s really quiet but it picked up straight away this morning and we’re pleased with that.

“And some of the stands that were probably not expecting that much interaction today because there’s been mainly primary schools were actually surprised by how many came and interacted on the stands.”

She added: “I know it sounds a bit trite, but meeting apprentices has been my favourite bit of today — although I did secretly enjoy meeting the Strictly Come Dancing stars.”

WorldSkills champ Terron wins again

Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg opened the National Apprenticeship Awards ceremony before WorldSkills 2013 gold medal-winning bricklayer Ashley Terron (pictured) claimed the apprentice champion of the year prize.

“The National Apprenticeship Awards really is one of my favourite events of the whole year,” Mr Clegg told the assembled employers, apprentices and sector figures.

“This night is always a celebration showcasing the talent, hard work and commitment shown by Britain’s top apprentices.”

“I was honoured and I wasn’t expecting to win,” said Mr Terron.

Mr Terron, whose father is also a bricklayer, said he was driven to achieve in his apprenticeship and to promote it to others by his headteacher, who questioned why someone as bright as him might do a bricklaying apprenticeship.

Ahley-measure

“I took a bit of offence, that he was questioning my family trade and me — even though I had my path set out,” said Mr Terron.

“And I’ve always had that in my mind. That spurred me on to try to strive and achieve the next best thing and that’s kept me going.

“I’ve since got back in touch with the school and oddly he’s taken a U-turn on his stance on apprenticeships.”

He added: “I was lucky that I worked with my dad so I had a chance to try bricklaying, but a lot of people don’t have that and more needs to be done to help people see what kind of opportunities are out there.”

Intermediate apprentice of the year went to Co-operative business admin apprentice Lois McClure, aged 20, who did her apprenticeship through Learndirect.

“I took an apprenticeship I didn’t really know what it was about they didn’t talk about it at school or college,” she said.

“I think I’ve won because I’ve just taken every opportunity I can. It’s amazing to win.”

Higher apprentice of the year was won by Hayley James, a Highbury College apprentice with IBM UK, while advanced apprentice of the year went to Anna Schlautmann, 21, a logistics apprentice with Alliance Learning, employed by MBDA Missile Systems.

Small employer of the year went to design company Blue Moon Creative, the medium employer award went to hovercraft designers Griffin Hoverwork, large employer of the year went to MBDA UK and the macro employer award went to housing developer Barratt Development.

 

Skills gap ‘between school and degree’

The Skills Show’s opening day also saw the publication of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development OECD Skills Beyond School report at the National Vocational Education and Training (VET) Conference.

The conference took place alongside the Skills Show at the Birmingham NEC.

The report called for the UK to put workplace learning at the centre of vocational education, warning that there would otherwise be a widening gap between qualifications and the skills employers need.

Simon Field, OECD lead vocational education researcher said the report contained two key messages for the UK.

Performers from Birmingham Metropolitan College
Performers from Birmingham Metropolitan College

“One is the need to do more to provide intermediate technical and professional skills, beyond school but less than a bachelor’s degree,” he said.

“The second is to integrate work-based learning systematically into programmes.”

The UK Commission for Employment and Skills (UKCES) welcomed the report.

Michael Davis, UKCES chief executive, said: “We support the view that higher level vocational training must have a clear line of sight to a job. Employers must be as close as possible to training to ensure the skills people develop are the ones businesses need.”

Association of Colleges chief executive Martin Doel said: “As OECD’s report says, ensuring workers have basic skills is important, but what is even more important is that education does not stop when someone enters the workplace.”

He added colleges in England worked` with an average of 600 businesses and were “always ready and willing to do more.”

 

A Street dance troupe on the main BBC stage
A Street dance troupe on the main BBC stage

All pics : ©2014 Professional Images

Unified CIF ‘not money-saving exercise’

Ofsted’s eight-week consultation on bringing an end to its independent FE and skills inspection regime comes to a close next month.

All education inspections would be “harmonised” under the proposed common inspection framework (CIF) for nurseries, schools and colleges from September next year, as revealed exclusively by FE Week at the start of August.

It is also proposing to halve the time between inspections of good FE and skills providers. Currently, good FE and skills providers face reinspection up to every six years if there are no concerns to trigger an earlier revisit — but Ofsted is looking at changing that to a “short inspection” up to every three years, unless concerns trigger one sooner.

The consultation further sets out proposals for four categories for judgements — leadership and management; teaching, learning and assessment; personal development, behaviour and welfare; and outcomes for children and learners.

With the consultation — available on www.ofsted.gov.uk — closing on December 5, Ofsted director of FE and skills Lorna Fitzjohn (pictured) spoke exclusively to FE Week to address concerns the proposals have raised within the sector.

What would the proposals mean for FE?

The proposals we have set out will be some of the most far-reaching reforms for education inspection in the last 25 years. At the heart of these changes are measures to help maintain and accelerate education standards in England.

We plan to introduce more frequent, but shorter inspections for good schools and FE and skills providers, with a clear focus on making sure that standards are staying high.

We are also planning to introduce a common inspection framework across all of our remits. The guidance in the handbook and the report structure will be adapted to suit FE providers. This will make it easier for employers and learners to compare providers and make informed choices.

What do you think is wrong with the way Ofsted inspects FE institutions at the moment? Is there any update on the negotiations about direct inspection of sub-contractors?

Ofsted has always played a vital role in promoting high standards so that the quality of provision improves for all learners. It is worth noting that more than nine out of ten providers said they were satisfied with how their recent inspection was carried out.

However, there is now a strong case for a more proportionate system where we move away from full inspections for good providers. Instead, we want a system based on professional dialogues between the inspectors and leaders, with a clear focus on whether the good standards are being maintained.

We understand that for some FE providers the use of sub-contractors counts for a substantial part of their provision. This is being looked at as part of the consultation and we are working to ensure that the quality of sub-contracted provision is included in any judgement we make about the provider.

Will there be a period of stability after these proposed changes are enacted?

Ofsted’s duty is to make sure that all learners receive the level of education and training that they deserve. For this reason, we are always reviewing the effectiveness of the way in which we inspect providers.

We understand that some teachers and trainers can feel uncertainty about what Ofsted looks for during inspection and this is something we want to avoid.

We will therefore be shortly publishing a ‘mythbusters’ document specifically aimed at those working in the FE and skills sector. This will dispel some of the rumours and hearsay about the inspection process and help sector workers to focus on what really matters — making sure they are giving learners the best education and training possible.

With the proposed move towards a single CIF, is there a danger that school specialists will inspect FE colleges, and vice-versa?

The move to a single inspection framework will in no way impact Ofsted’s ability to inspect providers. Those with experience in FE and skills will continue to inspect FE and skills providers.

A single framework will make it easier for providers, including University Technical Colleges, 16 to 19 academies and schools with sixth forms, to know what they are being judged against. We feel this will benefit the post-16 sector as a whole.

One proposal is to make clearer our judgements on the different types of provision. For example, someone reading an inspection report for a specific college would be able to clearly identify the quality of any apprenticeships, 16 to 19-year-old provision or adult courses which it offers.

Once the new framework is in place we will issue, as is normal practice, a handbook for FE inspectors on how to interpret the framework for the inspection of FE and skills so that it clearly relates to the sector and the different types of provision offered.

Will the proposals result in any job losses at Ofsted as departments inevitably move closer together?

The changes we are proposing are about maintaining and improving the quality of education and training in England. This is not a money-saving exercise.

We have carefully costed the new model in relation to inspection resource and are confident we can deliver within our existing budget.

 

Ofqual boss issues stability plea on Functional Skills

Ofqual boss Glenys Stacey has said qualifications should remain “as stable as possible” as Skills Minister Nick Boles looks at a Functional Skills rebrand.

Ms Stacey replied to a letter sent early last month by Mr Boles, in which he said Functional Skills would “continue to be one of the types of qualification that learners have available”.

In her letter, Ms Stacey welcomed the minister’s “clear statement about the importance you attach to Functional Skills qualifications”.

But, she added: “The brand of a qualification is important. It takes some years for qualification titles to become understood and trusted, particularly by employers and others who are not close to the education system.

“In general, our view is that we should keep the qualifications system as stable as possible, to allow qualifications time to prove themselves.

“We did a small survey of employers and others recently and found that employers in the survey had a broadly positive view of Functional Skills qualifications, as do colleges and other providers.”

See page 22 for an expert piece by OCR’s Charlotte Bosworth and visit feweek.co.uk for more, including a link to the letter in full.

 

Reports of more FE cuts prompt AoC defence

Further education has already taken its “fair share” of cuts, the Association of Colleges (AoC) has warned amid claims another £48bn could be slashed from government budgets.

The organisation has called for a review of education spending after warnings in national media that cuts could spiral way above the £25bn suggested by Prime Minister David Cameron, and a former civil servant warned the situation could be tough for FE for another decade.

A spokesperson for the AoC told FE Week: “Fair funding for colleges is always something that is high on our agenda and forms part of our discussions with the three main political parties.

“So far the FE sector has taken more than its fair share of funding cuts and we’re calling on the government to carry out a once-in-a-generation review of education spending to ensure that all age groups get an adequate budget. More stable funding would allow colleges to plan in the longer term.”

Education and Training Foundation chief executive David Russell said: “We have known for some time the fiscal climate for public services will remain very challenging for another five to 10 years.

“This presents a huge challenge to those delivering public value with public funding. It is the reason why excellent leadership, management and governance are vital to success of the FE and training system.”

The Treasury declined to comment. See feweek.co.uk for more sector reaction.

 

AoC backs Ofqual plans to scrap QCF regulations

The Association of Colleges (AoC) has backed Ofqual plans to ditch current regulatory arrangements for the Qualifications and Credit Framework (QCF).

A consultation launched in July on the QCF, which was itself launched in 2008, proposed that qualifications should be regulated by Ofqual’s general conditions of recognition.

A number of submissions from FE organisations, including representative bodies and awarding organisations, have now been seen by FE Week (see table).

AoC senior skills policy manager Teresa Frith (pictured), who submitted the response on behalf of the representative body, supported “efforts to reduce the amount of regulation”.

She said: “All qualifications should be valid regardless of their structure but [we] recognise that, in some instances, the QCF regulatory arrangements have not supported this intent.”

Ofqual stated in the consultation that it would not “impose design requirements about how QCF-type qualifications are structured [following the withdrawal of QCF regulatory arrangements]”.

Teresa-Frithnocutout

Ms Frith said: “This proposal should provide a welcome degree of flexibility in qualification and unit design.”

But she raised concern that “the removal of regulation might be seen as the removal of QCF, rather than allowing for a greater degree of flexibility to ensure ‘validity’.”

She warned scrapping the QCF regulatory arrangements “could be perceived as removing the ability to create credit bearing, unitised qualifications.

“A renaming of the remaining qualifications framework might be considered to ensure the sector remains clear that such an approach is not being prevented by the proposed changes to regulation,” she added.

Ms Frith said the AoC would like “clear reassurance” that the regulatory reforms would not lead to the complete “withdrawal of QCF from the system”.

Jeremy Benson, Ofqual’s director of policy, said: “This isn’t the end for qualifications based upon the QCF. We expect those QCF qualifications which are good quality and valuable to remain. But where they are found to fall short of our requirements, we would expect them to be either developed or withdrawn.”

Ofqual also asked for comments, through the consultation, on its plans for “QCF-type qualifications” to be “governed simply through our general conditions of recognition”.

Ms Frith said: “This appears to be a sensible way forward which should simplify regulation without removing the possibilities for easy accreditation of prior learning arrangements, unit assessment and the currency of credit. Any funding ramifications would need to be considered however.”

An Ofqual spokesperson said it was still considering responses to the consultation that closed last month.

 

Tablepage16

 

 

 

College issued warning over ‘hand-to-mouth’ finances

A Midland college has been warned about its “hand-to-mouth” financial situation by FE Commissioner Dr David Collins.

Dr Collins visited Birmingham’s 12,000-learner Bournville College (pictured), which has a current Skills Funding Agency (SFA) allocation of £8,495,746, in August after it was issued with a financial notice of concern by the in April.

In his report, published last week by the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills, Dr Collins praised the leadership and governance of the college and the quality of the provision offered to learners, which was rated good by Ofsted after a visit in May, but said it needed to do more to balance the books.

He said: “The college has successfully improved its quality and diversified its income streams over the last few years. It has grown by more than 5 per cent per year and predicts that it will be able to continue on this growth path into the foreseeable future. However, while this is an ambitious and commendable approach it is not without its risks.

“Not all projects have delivered the returns forecasted and a failure by the college to address inefficiencies in parts of the college’s operations has led to high levels of borrowing and serious cash flow issues.

“The present “hand to mouth” situation cannot be allowed to continue and there are opportunities to improve the position significantly if the college is prepared to bring its expenditure into line with sector norms. Fears that this will lead to a diminution of quality are not borne out by the evidence elsewhere.”

He said new projects or ventures into new markets needed “to be considered with a far greater degree of scrutiny by the governing body” and added that the college’s income base had “not been matched by an appropriate control of costs”.

College marketing director Alma Aganovic said: “We welcome the feedback from the FE Commissioner and are already in the process of implementing the recommendations from the report. The college would like to point out that last year we achieved a substantial improvement in our financial position which is commendable in the current climate. We were also recently inspected by Ofsted and achieved outstanding for leadership and management.”

 

Art space in £50m DfE refurb

A £50m tender to refurb the new Department for Education (DfE) HQ in London includes a gym and the creation of space for the government art collection, according to FE Week sister newspaper Academies Week.

The DfE announced in March that it was to leave the rented Sanctuary Buildings, in Victoria, and move its 1,600 staff to the Grade II-listed Old Admiralty Building (OAB), in Whitehall, by summer 2017. It claims the move will save £19m a year.

A tender for the refurbishment was put out last month offering the contract at a price tag of up to £50m, excluding VAT. It expects work, which will enable more staff to work in the building, to start next November.

Bidders are asked to provide details of their suitability to carry out work such as “full refurbishment of the gym” and “creation of space for the government art collection”.

The DfE said “no final decision” had been made on whether there would be a gym in the building and it was still in discussions about the artwork.

It also said refurbishment costs would be mainly met by the Cabinet Office through the sale of other government property. The size of the DfE contribution remains unclear.

Visit academiesweek.co.uk for more.

 

Making sure learners are set on the employability path

Employability is the added value that colleges can give learners — but just how well are they fulfilling this task? The Mindset Group of colleges is hoping it has developed a tool — free for UK-based colleges to use — that can assess how well colleges are performing on this, explains Lawrence Vincent.

As the Office for National Statistics figures released recently show another fall in the unemployment rate in the UK, you could be forgiven for thinking that the issues around youth unemployment were abating. Unfortunately, this is not the case.

In its August 2014 report Remember the Young Ones, the Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR) puts the figure of unemployed young people at 868,000 with the startling figure that those under 25 were three-and-a-half times more likely to be out of work.

The think tank has acknowledged that the Coalition has attempted to tackle the issues around youth unemployment, but that it had “failed to grasp the extent of the problem, or had not had the imagination to come up with better solutions”.

Youth unemployment is not just a UK phenomenon, but European countries with strong work-based vocational education and training see a smoother transition from education into work and consequently lower rates of youth unemployment.

The IPPR also cautioned that even a full economic recovery was unlikely to see the problems of youth unemployment disappear recommending that employers and educational institutions needed to improve their relationships.

European countries with strong work-based vocational education and training see a smoother transition from education into work and consequently lower rates of youth unemployment

That’s not to say some organisations are not doing so already. Facing an often poor perception, FE colleges are conscious of the need to do more to improve the employability of their students, whether it is improving external links or their more general internal provision. In order to make these improvements, individual gaps in provision and areas of weakness need to be identified.

In order to address this need, The MindSet Group — a non-trading group of FE colleges — was set up to address both the perception and the reality of the FE sector and ultimately to help tackle the UK’s issues surrounding youth unemployment.

Currently made up of 12 FE colleges and employability and recruitment organisation REED NCFE, The MindSet Group aims to develop the sector’s employability competence through innovative solutions by the sector, for the sector. The members are Barnet Southgate College, Blackpool and The Fylde College, Bournemouth & Poole College, Derby College, Harlow College, Portsmouth’s Highbury College, Milton Keynes College, North East Surry College of Technology, South Essex College, Stockport College, Sunderland College and Telford College.

The first of these solutions is the Student Employability Toolkit (Set) — a tool that can be used free, for a whole-college employability review which has been developed by four members of The MindSet Group; Bournemouth & Poole College, Derby College, Highbury College and Milton Keynes College.

It has been created to assist in developing the reputation and positioning of the FE sector in relation to its role with employers in the future of the UK economy, through both self-assessment and knowledge sharing.

Members of The MindSet Group believe UK FE colleges need to grasp the employability initiative, bringing solutions, guiding policy and informing debate by working together to improve the employability of the UK’s students and this begins with sharing knowledge and identifying gaps in provision.

Only by working together will we help our young people achieve their full potential.

MindSet launched its employability toolkit — the Set — last month with two regional events in Derby and Bournemouth and then three events this month in London, Sunderland and Stockport.

Go to www.themindset.org.uk for more details, or come and see us at our stand at the Association of Colleges conference.

 

Fetl launches £100k collective grants

Further education organisations can apply for new £100k research grants from the Further Education Trust for Leadership (Fetl).

It announced on Thursday (November 13) that it was accepting applications for collective research grants.

Jill Westerman CBE, Fetl chair, said: “We would welcome applications from organisations with innovative and visionary ideas, particularly around leading learning and leadership for the future in our sector.”

Former Learning and Skills Improvement Service (LSIS) chair Dame Ruth Silver launched Fetl over the summer with a budget of up to £5.5m of leftover LSIS funding.

Fetl invited applications for individual FE leaders to apply for fellowship grants in September and has now agreed on four candidates set to receive between £10,000 and £30,000 each. The four individuals are expected to start their research in the new year. Mark Ravenhall, Fetl chief executive, declined to comment on the identity of the chosen individuals nor their research topics.

However, he said: “We received 21 applications which were whittled down to a shortlist of six, before four were chosen.”

Groups interested in FETL collective research grants should visit www.fetl.org.uk to apply by noon on December 12.