The government has been pressed to launch an “urgent review” of traineeships over fears the programme could hit learner benefits, FE Week can reveal.

The Association of Employment and Learning Providers (AELP) has called for a new look at how the government’s flagship youth unemployment scheme will affect Job Seeker’s Allowance (JSA).

It is concerned that working around the Department for Work and Pensions’ (DWP) 16-hour rule — which limits the number of hours skills’ provision claimants can do in a week — will be more important than considerations surrounding the needs of learners when courses are designed.

“The rule has long been a source of contention for skills providers and in this instance means that skills elements, including maths and English provision within traineeships, will adversely impact on JSA payments if they exceed this amount per week,” said an AELP spokesperson.

“Work experience placements are treated slightly differently — placements of up to 30 hours a week are allowable within JSA regulations, but only up to a maximum of eight weeks, after which the 16-hour rule once again applies.

“The only exception to this is where an apprenticeship opportunity arises as a result of the work placement, where an extension to 12 weeks can be allowed.”

He added: “AELP believes that the cumulative effect of all this will mean that the short-term impact on a learner’s welfare benefits may in some cases be more important to the design of a traineeship than its potential effect on their future job prospects.

“Provision will therefore have to be configured around compliance with benefit rules as much as, if not in some cases more than, the needs of the learner (or even the potential employer) involved.

“We feel that this confluence of rules and regulations undermines the principle of delivering a flexible programme based on learner needs, and are pressing for an urgent review of the rules surrounding JSA and Traineeships in particular — for example by considering whether traineeships should qualify for a blanket exemption from the 16-hour rule.”

A spokesperson for the Department for Education told FE Week: “Traineeships have been designed to have the flexibility to fit with the benefits system.

“DWP policy is that JSA claimants can undertake up to 30 hours a-week work experience for a maximum of eight weeks.

“JSA claimants on traineeships will be able to spend up to 30 hours a-week on work experience, or work experience and training combined, provided that the training element is under 16 hours per week.

“Claimants will remain on JSA throughout their traineeship, unless agreement is reached between the provider and jobcentre locally to fund full-time participation via a JCP training allowance.”

A Department for Business, Innovation and Skills spokesperson told FE Week there was no exemption for traineeships, but added that the programme would be reviewed.

She did not indicate when the review would take place, but said: “Traineeships are in the first year of a staged national rollout and all aspects of delivery, including work experience, will undergo a formal evaluation.”

Traineeships were first proposed by Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg in June last year to help young people gain work-related skills and attitudes.

Pressure for the scheme mounted after it emerged that 979,000 16 to 24-year-olds were out of work in the three months from December to February.

The youth unemployment figures, released by the Office for National Statistics, showed a 20,000 increase on the three months from September to November.

The AELP wants to hear from providers — via — about their experiences of traineeships and JSA compliance.

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


    • Marc Ozholl

      They are certainly more flexible than English Traineeships. Recent review highlighted very little improvement in English and Maths though – can’t imagine messrs’ Gove and Hancock would be too happy about that! I think the starting Traineeship wage in Wales is £30 a week – if this was replicated in England would the ‘wage’ be offset against JSA (or JSA cut completely)? With no additional funding for Traineeships I dont see how it couldnt be, and that would still leave 19-24s in the same situation they are now. Hopefully the DfE, EFA, SFA and DWP can sit down and come to an agreement, otherwise Traineeships won’t reach a large percentage of people who would benefit the most.

  1. Julie Millott

    Looking at the rules n regulations, it appears that someone on jsa can work 30 hours per week for 12 weeks and then 16 hours after that? Could that not fit it perfectly with traineeships?
    Full time for 12 weeks gaining experience in the work placement and then have 16 hours a week for 4 weeks developing functional skills to increase their levels and then have the last month on a trial with a view for an Apprenticeship or full time position? Or am I missing something?