Exam papers to be marked in India

A leading FE awarding body’s decision to send exam papers to India to be marked could hit standards, Unison’s head of colleges has warned.

Christine Lewis questioned City & Guilds’ plans to scan and then electronically send thousands of functional skills papers abroad.

“It is sad if this initiative is about using cheap labour, at the risk of compromising standards,” she said.

She further questioned whether, at a time of high unemployment, there was “another solution” and if the problem stemmed from a lack of markers in the UK.

However, Chris Jones, chief executive of City & Guilds, defended the move, saying it wasn’t a “money-saving exercise”, but about meeting the “quick turnaround” that functional skills demanded.

“This is about reliability and integrity of the service,” he said, adding however that City & Guilds had invested a “substantial” amount in India and hoped for “cost-savings” it could “pass on to its customers”.

He said the firm currently charged around £13.50 per assessment, which covered commissioning test authors through to printing, loading, distributing and marking, quality assurance and integrity of results and certification.

It is understood to be the first time FE papers have been marked abroad and two other large awarding organisations told FE Week they had no plans to follow suit.

Exams watchdog Ofqual said the move hadn’t breached any rules, but said it was monitoring the situation.

“Our focus is on the quality of the marking, not the location where it takes place,” said a spokesperson.

She added: “But we will be keeping an eye on things to make sure.”

Meanwhile, a spokesperson for the Association of School and College Leaders said the move presented “yet more evidence” that the testing system was “overloaded”.

City & Guilds’ exam papers will be sent to MeriTrac, which claims to be the largest testing and assessment company in India.

The papers would only be for tests with a “low level of subjectivity and…a very clearly defined marking scheme,” Mr Jones told FE Week. They represented around 2.8 per cent of City & Guilds’ total number of exam papers, he added.

An 18-month pilot showed the company had “a far higher level of integrity in terms of marker pool, and the same levels of reliability in terms of marking and quality assurance, than we would naturally be able to achieve in the UK”, said Mr Jones.

Learners sat functional skills papers all-year round, he said, which resulted in high volumes of marking at times such as Easter when contracted markers in the UK — teachers and retired teachers — were often unavailable.

“The Ministry of Defence can’t send anyone to Afghanistan unless they have their functional skills; we have to be able to turn these results round in a couple of days,” said Mr Jones.

Around 220 Indian teachers now acted as markers, all of them trained by City & Guilds’ chief examiners over two weeks in the Asian sub-continent, he said.

Mr Jones added the company had retained 75 of its 167 contracted UK assessors for functional skills and was looking at other work opportunities for those who might lose out on contracted work.

[download#107]

Lord Lingfield heads chartered status panel

Further education bosses have welcomed the appointment of Lord Lingfield (pictured) as chair of the group that will give out chartered status, a new quality indicator for the sector.

Skills Minister Matthew Hancock asked the Tory peer to take on the role as he had the “right background and expertise”, the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) told FE Week.

Lord Lingfield will now put together a panel before the summer recess, in time for a formal launch in November.

Providers will put themselves forward for chartered status, which will be awarded for the first time in the early part of next year. If providers met certain criteria, such as showing strong leadership and management, and having excellent feedback from learners as well a programme of community activity endorsed by local enterprise partnerships, they could use the status in their titles.

A BIS spokesperson said: “Ministers want to put chartered status on a long term, independent footing as soon as possible and are appointing the chair and panel members directly.

“This is consistent with views expressed in response to a consultation on the matter.”

He added that the positions of chair and the rest of the panel would be unpaid.

Lord Lingfield sits on the EU sub committee for home affairs, health and education. He is also pro-chancellor of Brunel University, deputy lieutenant of Greater London and chairs a range of organisations, including the Centre for Education Management (now CEFM).

He previously served as director-general of St John Ambulance and chaired the Grant-Maintained Schools Centre throughout the 1990s.

Last year he wrote an independent review on professionalism in FE at the request of former Skills Minister John Hayes. His report explored how to “raise the status of further education professionals” and ultimately resulted in the creation of the FE Guild, currently being developed to set professional standards across the sector.

Lynne Sedgmore of the 157 Group, described the new chair as a “significant champion” of the “quality and excellence of colleges”.

She said: “We welcome the appointment. Lord Lingfield is someone who has spent time understanding and supporting the work of FE colleges and our sector.”

“He has already made a compelling case for greater professional autonomy for FE,” she added.

The Association of Colleges’ deputy chief executive, Gill Clipson, said the group “looked forward” to working with Lord Lingfield in developing chartered status for colleges.

“This work will build on his recommendations in last year’s report on professionalism within FE and, in this context, we will be interested to see how the charter will relate to his other recommendations concerning the establishment of a guild and the role of inspection within FE,” she said.

K College up for grabs after ‘failed merger’

Providers have been invited to open days to find out about taking on the business of a struggling college being broken up following a failed merger.

Two events will be held at K College, in Kent, for organisations looking to take over its provision.

The possible break-up of provision comes after the college, which was formed of a merger between West Kent College and South Kent College in 2010, ran into debts of £6m and was issued with a notice of concern by the Skills Funding Agency.

The college’s new principal, Phil Frier, later conceded the merger hadn’t worked and proposed splitting the college in two.

He suggested one half should incorporate the Dover and Folkstone campuses, while the other comprised Ashford, Tonbridge and Tunbridge Wells.

The proposal was approved by Skills Minister Matthew Hancock after an independent review which took into account the needs of the area K College serves.

The agency said two open days had been organised for providers to find out more about taking on the college business. Two of the college’s five campuses will host the open days, with the first at the college’s Tonbridge site on May 22 before a second event at its Folkestone site the following day.

An agency spokesperson said: “Along with the Education Funding Agency, we are looking to commission education and training provision currently delivered by K College across its five campuses.

“This is an opportunity for interested parties to find out more about the commissioning process and attend a Q&A session.”

They added: “The Higher Education Funding Council for England will also be inviting tenders for the College’s higher education provision.”

The college is still recruiting for the next academic year, starting in September and will continue to offer courses offered in line with the college plan until July next year, subject to learner numbers.

A prospectus providing more information about the college’s provision would be published before the open days.

Email kopenday@skillsfundingagency.bis.gov.uk for more details.

Skills Funding Agency wants a chair

The post of Skills Funding Agency advisory board chair is up for grabs.

The agency, which manages an annual budget of more than £3bn, is advertising the three-year unpaid job on its website and is expecting the successful candidate to be in place in around two months’ time.

They will head a board made up of representatives from the FE sector, employers and other stakeholder groups, including Association of Colleges chief executive Martin Doel and NUS president-elect Toni Pearce.

The agency wanted someone with “ideas for reducing bureaucracy” and “better and more simplified ways of implementing programmes”.

The job specification reads: “It [the board] provides independent support and challenge on both the business operations of the agency and on the delivery of its priorities and performance, acting as both a sounding board and source of expert advice, drawing on the particular roles, knowledge and expertise of its members.

“In particular, the board provides practical advice and guidance, as well as challenge to [the agency’s] chief executive on how best to deliver those FE and skills priorities set for the agency by the Secretary of State, including the interpretation of those priorities for particular groups, and on issues such as the impact and implementation of operational procedures on learners, providers and employers.

“The chief executive of the agency is responsible for all individual allocation decisions and for dispensing funding to the sector.

“The board does not have a role in this, nor holding the chief executive or the agency to account for its performance.

“However, the board and chair will be expected to provide feedback to the Department [for Business, Innovation and Skills] and Ministers on the performance of the chief executive and agency.”

The chair could ask to stay in the job for a further three years, but staying on beyond six years would be “exceptional”.

They can expect to be going to around five board meetings a year, and would have to pencil in a further five days over the year for other tasks and functions relating to the post, for which expenses are paid.

Previous board meetings have been chaired by the agency chief executive and also board members, such as Construction Skills chief executive Mark Farrar.

“This is an exciting and rewarding opportunity to be part of a dynamic and fast moving organisation, leading and working collaboratively with a board of high profile figures from across business and the education and training sector,” according to the job specification.

Visit the agency website for more details and for information on how to apply before the deadline of midnight Sunday, May 19.

Success tastes sweet for Carshalton

A five-layer chocolate orange cheesecake was among the dishes that a group of Surrey students used to tempt judges of the Nestle Toque D’or competition.

Chef student Jose Queirolo, front-of-house student Jamie Newman, and Lois Benjamin, who acted as commis chef, all from Carshalton College, presented their two-course lunch, with a main of Peruvian steak,  to the judges at the college’s in-house Nightingale restaurant, along with a presentation about the concept of the lunch and the costing.

Carshalton tutor Anthony Dunball said: “The students worked really hard on designing, preparing and producing the lunch.

“They displayed a high level of skill in their catering and hospitality understanding.”

Eight teams from around the country will go forward to the national final next month.

Featured image caption: Louis Benjamin, 16, Jose Queirolo, 20 and Jamie Newman, 16

Colleges’ troubled merger plan goes ahead

Two Midland colleges are set to merge less than two months after Skills Minister Matthew Hancock told them to go back to the drawing board with the plans.

Proposals by Stourbridge and Birmingham Metropolitan to form “one of the largest and most significant further education providers in the country” have been okayed by governors.

They are now set to become one institution with the 12,500-student Stourbridge College dissolving and its property, rights and liabilities transferring to Birmingham Met, which, two years ago, had more than 26,000 learners.

David Nolan, chair of Stourbridge College Corporation, said: “The board of governors at Stourbridge College has unanimously voted in favour of merger after considering the wide range of benefits this would create for our learners, including greater choice of courses, improved facilities and enhanced connections to employers and the jobs market.”

The merger idea was put out to a six-week formal consultation which ended on Wednesday, February 27.

But the proposals were later investigated by Mr Hancock’s officials at the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) to “establish if appropriate processes have been followed”.

He wrote to David Beasley, clerk at Stourbridge College, saying: “I am not convinced by the rationale set out in your consultation document that this would represent the best outcomes for learners in your local area.

“Nor does your consultation document provide assurance to me that the corporation has undertaken the open and transparent processes that we would expect in terms of analysing needs, engaging with stakeholders and, critically, securing the most effective partnerships and delivery option(s) for the future.”

He added: “I would request that the corporation review its processes and rectify any shortfall, including seeking potential partners through open and inclusive processes.”

However, the merger — backed by the Birmingham Local Enterprise Partnership — is set to be complete as of June.

Vij Randeniya, chair of Birmingham Met, said: “We are delighted to be merging with Stourbridge College who have a long established reputation for success and innovation.

“Working together will help both colleges respond to government’s priorities, particularly in light of the current economic climate and the need to develop the skills of our regional workforce.

“Our partnership will offer us the exciting prospect of developing our curriculum across our network of campuses, as well as delivering a host of new opportunities for both organisations to build on the quality and innovation they are already known for.

“We are keen to support the work of the Black Country and Greater Birmingham Local Enterprise Partnerships to deliver economic growth and local community regeneration.”

Twin qualification in Superbike contest

Midlands students had the chance to live life in the fast lane when they qualified at the first round of the MCE British Superbike Championship.

Motorcyclists, twins and Black Country UTC students Matthew and Kurt Wigley represented the UTC and were accompanied by four fellow engineering students, who gained valuable hands-on experience as the pitcrew.

The brothers have been racing motorbikes since the age of six.

Pit crew member Laura Myatt said: “The first race of the season helped us gain a lot of experience and it was exciting to be involved in the preparation to the races.

“It was interesting to learn how the brake lines work and we now have a better understanding of the technology.”

Two students also got to visited the garage of one of the top Superbike teams to get a better idea of the key roles in a larger pit crew.

Featured image caption: Twin brothers Matthew (far left) and Kurt Wigley (far right) and their pit-crew classmates

‘I don’t want the fairytale to end’

A college catering assistant honoured in the new year is now looking forward to a garden party at Buckingham Palace. She’s just hoping the sun will shine, writes Rebecca Cooney

A college catering assistant from Romford has received a British Empire Medal and has been invited to tea with the Queen.

Sandra Coats, 57, has worked at Barking and Dagenham College for six years and was mentioned in the Queen’s New Year honours list for her outstanding contribution to the college.

“It was a lovely feeling, I’m just so pleased to be recognised It’s nice to be appreciated sometimes when you work hard,” she said.

Sandra was presented with her medal by Sir David Brewer, Lord-Lieutenant of Greater London, at a special ceremony held at the Tower of London.

Her husband, daughter and her daughter’s partner went with her.

“It was such a special day. It is something I will never forget,” she added.

But there is still more excitement to come, as Sandra has also received an invitation to a garden party at Buckingham Palace in May.

“I can’t wait to go to the palace — the letter said the Queen and other members of the royal family would be there,” she said. “The weather will be a bit nicer as well.”

A letter arrived last November, telling Sandra she had been nominated for an honour, but that she wouldn’t know for certain until December.

“It said it was confidential and I wasn’t supposed to tell anyone,” she said, admitting she found that a bit of a challenge.

She had been nominated by the college principal, Cathy Walsh.

“When I eventually told Cathy about the medal, she said she was so pleased,” said Sandra. “She told me that she’d nominated me because I deserved it.”

A college spokesperson, Anne Vessey said: “We are so proud of Sandra. The dedication and care she shows to all our students at Barking and Dagenham is very special. Her honour is our honour.”

Sandra serves breakfast and lunch, as well as cater for special events.

“I do really long hours, so I think it is well deserved,” she said. “It’s so nice for Cathy to notice and appreciate me though.”

She might admit to long days but said that she loved her job.

Her colleagues were all “very pleased” for her, she said. She planned to take in her medal to show it to them and to students.

She said she will hold on to and treasure her memories of the year.

“I’ve kept everything, all the letters that have come through right from November from the lieutenant and everything, I’ve got it all in a folder,” said Sandra.

“I feel really special at the moment and don’t want the fairytale to end.”

Featured image caption: Barking & Dagenham College catering assistant Sandra Coats, wears her British Empire Medal, with Lord-Lieutenant of Greater London, Sir David Brewer CMG JP, at the Tower of London ceremony