Prison warning for college spending officer

A Lancashire college purchasing officer could be facing a spell behind bars after she used a work credit card to rack up £21,000 of debt on holidays, sunglasses, solicitors and supermarket shopping.

Included in the spending of Shaheda Lorgat (pictured, right) at Blackburn College’s expense was also £465 on a trip to Alton Towers.

The 42-year-old had been entrusted with a card that was meant to buy equipment for learners needing special help.

Judge Jeremy Baker heard how Lorgat, who pleaded guilty to 19 charges of fraudulent abuse of her position, was suspended in February last year by the 15,000-student college — rated outstanding at Ofsted’s last inspection in early 2008.

Preston Crown Court was told ‘financial discrepancies’ had been uncovered by an internal audit.

Among the personal items Lorgat paid for with college money were personal travel costs totalling £9,031; solicitors bills of £2,464; £8,473 on tradesmen; £315 on personal holiday costs; and, a supermarket bill of £202.

There was also £245 on goods for personal use and prescription sunglasses at £153.

The payments covered more than three years from around summer 2008.

Judge Jeremy Baker said: “Fraudulence in a position of trust carried on over a period of years and obtaining a benefit of more than £20,000 of public money is likely to attract a prison sentence.

“Whether it will or not remains for the judge on the day to decide.”

Leila Ghahhary, defending, said: “There is a long-standing history of domestic abuse and from that, mental health problems from which the defendant suffers.”

Rachel Curry, director of resources at Blackburn College, said: “The college is satisfied with the outcome of the legal proceedings against a former colleague who was dismissed from our employment over 16 months ago, following an investigation initially triggered by minor financial discrepancies.

“As one of the largest and most financially stable further education colleges in the UK, whilst the situation was unfortunate and regrettable there was no impact on the education and training of our learners.”

A police spokesman said: “Shaheda Lorgat was in a position of trust and used the credit card for her own financial gain.

“The card was meant to be used to buy equipment for pupils with certain requirements, but instead she used it to buy herself things.”

Lorgat was unconditionally bailed for the preparation of pre-sentence and medical reports and told to return to court on September 9.

New FE professionalism body launched

The FE sector’s new professionalism and standards organisation, the Education and Training Foundation, launched today.

The body, funded by the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills and formerly known as the FE Guild, started work with its first board meeting, in London.

It comes almost four months after FE Week revealed government funding of the foundation of £18.8m for year one and again in year two along with a series of steering group meetings.

Sir Geoff Hall, foundation interim chief executive, said: “With a focus on workforce professionalism and continuous improvement, the job of this new foundation is to ensure that education and training providers understand and meet the needs of businesses and communities, and have the most effective and best equipped workforce in place.

“We want every learner and every trainee to get maximum benefit from their experience and we want every practitioner to benefit from effective and impactful continuing professional development opportunities.

“Our priorities are to improve learner experience and outcomes, to enhance the reputation of the sector, to develop provider good practice, to make the sector an attractive place to join and work, and to promote and champion equality and diversity across the sector.”

The guild proposal was first put forward by ministers in 2011. A small project team, with a steering group with representation from the sector, issued a consultation document at the end of January.

Its implementation plan, produced at the end of March, sparked controversy when the National Union of Students criticised the decision that there be no learner representation at board level.

Nevertheless, the body was set up with board members proposed by the Association of Colleges (AoC), the Association of Employment and Learning Providers (AELP), the Third Sector National Learning Alliance, and HOLEX.

The board includes Don Hayes MBE, chief executive of voluntary skills consortium Enable; Lynsi Hayward-Smith, head of adult learning and skills at Cambridgeshire County Council; and, John Hyde, co-founder and executive chairman of HIT (Hospitality Industry Training).

Joining them is Chris Jeffrey, strategy and policy adviser for General Physics (UK) Ltd Skills Training Academy; Asha Khemka OBE, principal of West Nottinghamshire College; Peter McCann, principal of Kirklees College; and, Mark White, vice-chair of Stockton Riverside College.

David Hughes, independent chair of the guild’s development steering group and chief executive of the National Institute of Adult Continuing Education, said: “The new foundation has made a strong and early commitment to engaging with learners and the workforce.

“There will be a learner and a practitioner on the foundation board, and we are working with NUS, employee unions and The Institute for Learning to ensure that learner and practitioner voices are heard and acted upon across all areas of work.

“We will drive continuous quality improvement through genuine sector ownership, recognising best practice and tackling issues as we find them.”

Martin Doel, AoC chief executive, said: “This is an exciting time for the FE and skills sector and I am confident this new organisation will have a positive impact not just for individual learners, teachers, practitioners and organisations, but on the status of FE and training as a whole.”

Stewart Segal, AELP chief executive, said: “As a sector, we have had a very real opportunity to shape the new foundation and form its priorities.

“This is truly about self-improvement by the sector, for the sector. By listening to and involving providers, practitioners, learners and employers, the foundation will ensure we are all best-placed to meet future needs.”

The foundation launch took place at the Goldsmiths’ Centre.

SFA to pay up to £900 per work placement

The Skills Funding Agency has announced rates from £500 to £900 for work placements in the government’s new traineeship programme.

Agency officials laid out payment bands of 100 to 199 hours; 200 to 499 hours; and, 500 hours-plus in a sector webinar on Monday (see slides below). They said the bands would mean training providers were funded at £500; £700; and £900, respectively (with 20% held back until there is a positive progression into work). Click here to download the full set of SFA slides.


Traineeships were first proposed by Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg in June last year for 16 to 24-year-olds. But there was disappointment throughout the sector in May when the first framework showed only those aged below 19 would be included in the programme, along with those with learning difficulty assessments up to academic age 25.

But the situation changed with this year’s Spending Review, when the government included the older age bracket for when they begin next month.

The revision resulted in new framework guidance this month, setting out what traineeships hoped to achieve.

This included work preparation training such as interview preparation and CV writing, training in English and maths, a high-quality work placement between six weeks and five months and training from providers who were rated outstanding or good by education inspectors Ofsted.

Skills Minister Matthew Hancock said: “Young people in Britain deserve the chance to work and get on in life which is why we’re introducing traineeships to help them get on the first rung of the ladder.

“Employers value real experience which is why I’m delighted that more than 100 businesses have come forward. I now want to urge more employers — no matter what size — to sign up to the programme and make the most of the talents of our young people.

“This is vital for our economy to compete in the global race. Traineeships are just one of the ways this government is making sure young people cross the start line.”

FE Commissioner selection ongoing

The new FE Commissioner is yet to be appointed despite interviews by officials from the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS), FE Week understands.

A number of candidates have already been spoken to, but none has been appointed to the role — or to any of its seven advisory posts.

“The interview and appointment process is ongoing,” said a BIS spokesperson.

It had been hoped — when the powerful new role was announced in April — that posts would be filled by June. But with that date past, no new timescale was given.

The FE Commissioner’s appointment, and that of the advisers, had been managed through the National College for Teaching and Leadership’s (NCTL) e-procurement system.

BIS and the Department for Education had wanted candidates registered on the NCTL’s operational associate framework so they could issue a request for quotation.

However, it was not clear whether the same system and requirement would apply when the posts were readvertised.

The commissioner will be able to call for a college to be shut down and will be sent in if a college is graded ‘inadequate’ by Ofsted, is in financial trouble or is failing to hit learner success targets.

They will report directly to Ministers with the aim of turning the college around within a year.

They could call for institutions to be slapped with ‘Administered College’ status, thereby losing powers such as staff changes, expenditure or transfer of assets.

They could also recommend governors be kicked out, but ultimately they could also call for a college to be dissolved.

Skills Minister Matthew Hancock announced the intervention measures under the government’s new Rigour and Responsiveness in Skills strategy.

“Where colleges are failing learners we will be knocking on their doors and take swift and effective action,” he said.

“It is a dereliction of duty to let failing colleges teach young people. We will not fail in our duty to act.

“All providers should meet tough standards of rigour and responsiveness. Through these reforms we will be able to intervene without hesitation where they fall short.”

For colleges who require improvement (one grade better than inadequate), Ofsted will provide enhanced support and work with them on a development plan.

But the new skills strategy also includes stronger action to support good and outstanding colleges.

Ten colleges with half billion pound total income join forces

Ten colleges in the North West have joined forces to form a joint venture company boasting a combined income of nearly half a billion pounds.

Principals have been working on the move to form the Greater Manchester Colleges Group since 2010.

It is believed to be the first of its kind in a city region and includes include Bolton College, Bury College, Hopwood Hall College, The Manchester College and Oldham College.

Salford City, Stockport, Tameside, Trafford and Wigan and Leigh colleges will also be involved in the partnership, which aims to enhance students’ job hopes.

And the partnership has moved forward after the colleges’ principals successfully secured a European funded bid worth £14m, which will play “a critical role in ensuring that the region has a skilled and educated population,” said a spokesperson.

They added that the group represented and promoted the FE sector within Greater Manchester and contributed more than £500m to the local economy each year.

Tameside College principal Peter Ryder is the group’s chair. He said: “As a group we will be continuing to work with local and regional employers to bring a greater emphasis on enterprise, entrepreneurialism and innovative thinking to the education sector.

“We aim to build capacity and excellence by developing existing provision and pulling together the expertise and specialist skills from all of the colleges involved.

“This latest development is testament to the optimism we have for the future, and our shared belief in the positive benefits for learners and the wider community of our working closely together.”

Robin Newton-Syms, the group’s partnership director, said: “Our aim is to use the new company to attract more funding into Greater Manchester and facilitate work with other organisations.

“We already have strong links with the Chamber of Commerce, private sector training providers, local authorities and the voluntary sector which is helping employers develop the skills of their workers.

“The potential now is for colleges to help shape the future of businesses, by offering effective training solutions and skills development which will enable them to grow.”

College

Million income in 2011/12

Principal
Bolton College

£29,167

Marie Gilluley
Bury College

£31,977

Charlie Deane
Hopwood Hall College

£25,755

Derek O’Toole
The Manchester College

£187,451

Jack Carney
Oldham College

£25,396

Alun Francis
Salford City College

£43,470

Martin Sim
Stockport College

£32,496

Stephen Carlisle
Tameside College

£24,405

Peter Ryder
Trafford College

£27,031

Sir Bill Moorcroft
Wigan and Leigh College

£33,621

Cath Hurst OBE
Total

£460,769

Skills call on LEPs accepted by government

The government has accepted a recommendation that skills should be a core priority for Local Enterprise Partnerships (LEPS).

The recommendation was made by the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills Select Committee in April.

It came in a report that also said LEPs should demonstrate engagement with providers.

“We believe that skills should be a core priority,” said the committee report.

“While we acknowledge that many LEPs have got the balance right, and note the government guidelines on the subject, we have heard that some LEPs need to refocus.

“We therefore recommend that LEPs be required to demonstrate their levels of engagement with local education, in particular with skills and apprenticeship providers, FE colleges and schools.”

The government’s response to the report was published by the select committee on Thursday, July 25.

“The government accepts this recommendation,” it said.

“It is up to LEPs to determine the priorities for their areas. Some skills elements will be included in the SLGF [single local growth fund] and LEPs will have to provide details of how they intend to deliver their strategic plans.

“The government is committed to putting control over the skills system in the hands of employers and learners and ensuring that the skills system is responsive to the skills needs of local communities to support growth and jobs.

“We have put £340m directly in the hands of employers through the Employer Ownership of Skills Pilot and will support demand from learners aged 24+ through Advanced Learner Loans.

“In response to Lord Heseltine’s report, the government stated that a skills system that is responsive to local needs can help drive economic growth.

“To ensure that local businesses can shape the pipeline of talent emerging from local further education (FE) institutions, at Autumn Statement 2012, the government agreed that LEPs would have a new strategic influence over skills policy in accordance with Lord Heseltine’s analysis.

“LEPs will be responsible for setting local skills strategies and will work with the FE providers to agree how those priorities will be delivered.”

The government said LEPs had a “number of levers to strengthen their engagement with providers,for example Chartered status for FE colleges was now dependent upon having taken into account the skills priorities of local LEPs.

“The government is reforming the delivery landscape so that employers have direct influence over qualifications and learning programmes and by ensuring that businesses and LEPs are represented strongly on college governing bodies,” added the government.

Household names get SFA budget cuts

Government funding budgets for training at major UK firms has been slashed, new figures have shown.

Firms such as British Gas, BT and McDonalds all under-delivered on the training they had been expected to deliver, according to the latest quarterly allocation figures from the Skills Funding Agency.

British Gas had its 16 to 18 apprenticeship contract for 2012/13 (ending July 31, 2013) reduced by 44 to £1.2m, while its combined apprenticeship budget (including 19 plus) decreased by 38 per cent to £1.8m.

British Telecom’s combined in-year budget fell 10 per cent to £8.1m and McDonalds had both its 16 to 18 apprenticeships budget and its combined apprenticeship budget squeezed by 10 per cent.

Meanwhile, the Alternative Hotel Group (owned by Lloyds Banking Group) had the greatest cut in combined 2012/13 budget with a 28 per cent reduction in its apprenticeships contract to £6.6m.

The conference and hotel business had its 16 to 18 apprenticeships budget cut 37 per cent to £3.8m.

A spokesperson for the Alternative Hotel Group said the reduction was caused by an increase in the length of apprenticeships they were offering and difficulty in recruiting apprentices.

She added that the company had fewer “progression opportunities” with employers due to “the current economic climate”.

A spokesperson for British Gas said: “Funding contracts are always forecasted in advance and during the period in question, we simply did not need to recruit the forecasted numbers via the funded route.”

A BT spokesperson said: “We work closely with the agency to ensure that the amount granted matches our apprenticeship provision.”

She added: “Factors such as changes in our recruitment profile can make a difference to our contract value.”

A spokesperson for McDonalds said: “The reduction in allocation of funding is not indicative of any reduction in training for McDonalds’ employees. It is the result of natural fluctuation in the training we deliver as we have seen new employees come into and through the business, started to introduce new training programmes and transitioned between providers.”

The agency said 521 contracts overall had been reduced due to “underdelivery by providers”.

Government commentary on the allocations said this meant £10.9m was “recovered” from adult provision and £41.8m from 16 to 18 apprenticeships.

“We have reduced contract values where actual delivery was below profile in line with our published performance management arrangements,” said an agency spokesperson.

She added: “As a result we funded an additional £19.1m growth for adult provision and £6.4m for 16 to 18 apprenticeships.”

The figures showed that overall the Adult Skills budget had grown by 2 per cent from August 2012.

However, 16 to 18 apprenticeships funding slumped 20 per cent from £858.5m in August, while funding for 19 plus apprenticeships was up 2 per cent to £3.28m.

The Association of Employment and Learning Providers’ chief executive, Stewart Segal, said: “It is important going forward that the agency clearly establishes the priorities for 2013-14 so that providers can plan their delivery.”

It comes just weeks after FE Week reported how Education Secretary Michael Gove’s Department for Education (DfE) had cut its projected budget for 16 to 18 apprenticeships by £165.5m.

The cut came, in part, because of “competition” from older applicants — who are funded by the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS), rather than DfE. And last month FE Week reported how the latest Statistical First Release showed 4,000 fewer 16 to 18-year-olds started apprenticeships from February to April (Q3) this year compared to the same period last year — a 19 per cent drop.

Education Funding Agency to publish 16 to 18 payments

The Education Funding Agency is to start publishing information on the value of providers’ 16 to 18 delivery, FE Week can reveal.

The agency already goes public with annual allocation details, but it doesn’t release information about the value of provision actually delivered.

However, following an FE Week request for figures on the value of delivery under the Freedom of Information (FoI) Act, the agency said it was planning to release 2012/13 details this year. It was also looking at releasing the information relating to 2011/12.

“The vast majority of institutions funded by the agency, including schools, colleges and academies, are funded on a lagged basis, so the funding allocated in one year relates to the student numbers recruited in earlier years, and the funding allocated and paid is the same,” said an agency spokesperson.

“However, funding for commercial and charitable providers is reconciled against delivery, and payments are adjusted according to rules published annually in the agency funding guidance.

“We have not previously published information on delivery and payments for these providers, but are planning to do so for the first time in relation to 2012/13 once we have final audited figures from all providers, which are returned in the autumn.

“We expect this information for 2012/13 to be published around the end of 2013.

“We will also publish data for commercial and charitable providers for 2011/12 as a historical record, which we are provisionally planning to make available in August 2013.”

It follows an FE Week story this month about the amount of agency funding for independent training providers for which no delivery had taken place. They were overpaid around £20m last year, it was revealed.

Around 10 per cent of the agency’s 2011/12 budget for private sector provision for 16 to 18-year-olds was not returned, even though it wasn’t delivered.

A further 15 per cent — around £25m — was handed back.

An EFA spokesperson said it allowed providers to keep a certain amount of funding for which no provision had been delivered. But, she said, it was not true that it had paid £20m to independent training providers “for nothing”.

“In 2010/11 and 11/12 we applied a 10 per cent margin for some independent providers where they under-delivered to reflect changes to the funding system in those years. This has been reduced to 5 per cent in 2012/13,” she said.

The overpayment figures were not in the public domain — prompting the FoI request — but were seen by FE Week.

They provided a stark contrast to funding for older learners, paid for by the Skills Funding Agency (SFA) and BIS.

The SFA makes the details of its overpayments public, but it pays independent training providers strictly on delivery. Its overpayment of £91m last year therefore ended up largely in the coffers of colleges and local authorities, for example.

Kim Thorneywork, the SFA’s chief executive, said the overpayment — revealed in December — meant some providers’ allocations for 2012/13 would be reduced, and she expected “to deliver a balanced budget for the 2012/13 financial year”.

EFA name first seven colleges allowed to recruit full time 14 and 15-year-olds

Seven colleges will be taking up the opportunity, for the first time, to directly enrol full-time 14 and 15 year olds in September.

The Education Funding Agency (EFA) has now confirmed  the seven colleges which “meet the entry criteria as at 15 July 2013 to commence delivery from September 2013″ are:

Central territory:
Halesowen College. Local authority: Dudley

North territory:
Middlesbrough College. Local authority: Middlesbrough
Leeds City College. Local authority: Leeds
Newcastle College Group. Local authority: Newcastle upon Tyne
Accrington and Rossendale College. Local authority: Lancashire
Hull College. Local authority: Kingston upon Hull

South territory:
Hadlow College. Local authority: Kent

Of 283 colleges which meet the criteria laid out by Skills Minister Matthew Hancock in December last year, only these seven (2.5 per cent) are planning to recruit 14 and 15 year olds full-time. However, the agency website states: “if there are additional colleges intending to deliver this provision, they should advise the EFA as soon as possible and by end of August at the latest.”

The agency declined to indicate how many students were likely to be enrolled but a spokesperson said: “We are pleased that these seven colleges will be acting as early pathfinders and will be working closely with them to learn early lessons and share good practice.”

He added: “The funding they receive will be based on the actual numbers they recruit.”

FE Week understands that more colleges are planning to offer 14 and 15 provision in 2014-15.

The criteria for direct recruitment of 14 to 15-year-olds required colleges to have an ‘Outstanding’, ‘Good’ or ‘Requires Improvement’ with improving results.

Mr Hancock’s announcement last year followed a recommendation made in Professor Alison Wolf’s report on vocational education in 2011.

He confirmed his decision in a letter dated December 6, 2012 to Mike Hopkins, principal of Middlesbrough College, and Tony Medhurst, principal of Harrow College, both members of the 14 to 16 College Implementation Group, which was set up to investigate the possibilities of the recommendation.

Mr Hancock wrote that he was “delighted” with the work and findings of the group.

He added: “As you know, I am keen to ensure the best possible provision for young people that meets their needs.

“In some cases that means enrolling them in FE colleges full-time from the age of 14.”

Colleges who do take on 14 and 15-year olds will be required to provide a dedicated area for them within the college estate, as well as separate 14 to 16 leadership.

Colleges will also be subject to an Ofsted inspection under the schools’ framework within two years of their 14 to 16 centre opening.