Ofsted boss Sir Michael aims annual report fire at skills gap armed with nearly 180 FE and skills inspection results

Ofsted chief inspector Sir Michael Wilshaw today launches the 2014/15 annual report armed with the results of nearly 180 FE and skills inspections.

The education watchdog’s preview commentary on today’s launch contained little for FE and skills, focusing largely on school matters, but a spokesperson told FE Week that one of the issues Sir Michael would reflect on was devolution.

Sir Michael would, the spokesperson added, say in the report that if cities like Manchester, Leeds and Sheffield were to be the engine rooms of a “northern powerhouse”, they need to work harder at closing “skills gaps”.

However, he will be able to draw conclusions on the sector from 177 inspections of FE and skills providers last academic year. Included in this were 48 inspections of general FE colleges between September 1 to August 31 (for 2014/15) — which resulted in two ‘outstanding’, 15 ‘good’, 26 ‘requires improvement’ and five ‘inadequate’ ratings’.

That overall number was down from 81 in 2013/14 — when there were five ‘outstanding’, 45 ‘good’, 27 ‘requires improvement’ and four ‘inadequate’ report ratings. The results for 2013/14 saw Sir Michael renew his questioning of the college sector’s record on employer engagement.

There were 114 inspections of independent learning providers (ILPs) last academic year — with four ‘outstanding’ results, 53 ‘good’, 45 ‘requires improvement’ and 12 ‘inadequate’.

It compared to 140 inspections in 2013/14 — with four ‘outstanding’, 83 ‘good’, 42 ‘requires improvement’ and 11 ‘inadequate’ ratings.

Meanwhile, of 15 inspections of sixth form colleges (SFCs) in 2014/15, there were no ‘outstanding’, seven ‘good’, five ‘requires improvement’ and three ‘inadequate’ report ratings.

It compares to 31 inspections in 2013/14 of SFCs — resulting in two ‘outstanding’, 19 ‘good’, nine ‘requires improvement’, and one ‘inadequate’ rating.

Stewart Segal, Association for Employment and Learning Providers’ (AELP) chief executive, called for changes to how the annual and individual Ofsted reports measure success.

“Ofsted tends to focus on data and technical measures such as completion and timely completion as its way of judging success,” he said.

“But AELP always proposed a basket of measures which gives much more emphasis to outcomes for learners, impact on business and satisfaction levels of apprentices.

He said this was needed for inspections of ILPs as “work-based training is more complex than measuring classroom-based courses” and “too often [current] measures like completion rates are misunderstood”.

Andrew Harden, national head of FE for the University and College Union (UCU), said: “The conclusions of the [annual] Ofsted report should not be divorced from the challenging context within which the sector finds itself.

“The FE sector has faced several years of upheaval, with massive budget cuts and a raft of government initiatives including apprenticeship trailblazers and 16-19 qualification reform.

“Staff in FE have continued to achieve great results with reduced resource and this should be recognised.”

Follow @FEWeek for live coverage of the Ofsted annual report launch from 10am at One Great George Street, Westminster.

Association of Colleges president John Widdowson and social mobility tsar Alan Milburn to address FE issues in Parliamentary hearings

Association of Colleges president John Widdowson is due to tell MPs about how well the FE sector delivers higher education tomorrow.

He will speak on the quality of higher education in a Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) Select Committee session.

It will come a day before Social Mobility and Child Poverty Commission chair Alan Milburn will share his views on FE funding in the penultimate session of the House of Lords Select Committee on Social Mobility.

The BIS committee is holding an inquiry entitled Assessing the quality of Higher Education and will hear from staff, student and sector representatives in what will be its second evidence session. A panel using metrics to assess quality will also participate in the hearing, which takes place from 9.15am.

Mr Widdowson is expected to speak as a witness from 10.40am, alongside a number of university professors and vice-chancellors. Other speakers tomorrow morning include Megan Dunn, president of the National Union of Students; Sally Hunt, general secretary of the University and College Union; and Stuart Cannell, student reviewer with the Quality Assurance Agency.

Mr Milburn will be joined in his session  the following day by Jack Feintuck, head of policy at the commission, and they will discuss any changes to the funding of FE that might improve quality outcomes for middle attainers and underserved groups.

Former Labour MP Mr Milburn became chair of the Social Mobility and Child Poverty Commission in July 2012. Other topics he will address will include the work of the Commission, and how to engage with employers on youth unemployment and imbalances in the labour market.

The evidence session is due start from 10.35am, with Professor Ann Hodgson, Professor of post-compulsory education and co-director of the Centre for Post-14 Education and Work, UCL Institute of Education due to give evidence an hour later along with Professor Kevin Orr, School of Education and Professional Development, University of Huddersfield.

Movers and shakers: edition 156

Barnsley College governors have seen big changes among their senior memberships and staff.

Simon Perryman takes the position of chair from Josie Thirkell, who steps down after three-and-a-half years in the role.

Paul Jagger MBE and Ben Mansford also join the board, with Mr Jagger taking up the position of vice chair.

New chair Mr Perryman runs Perryman, Yeandle and Associates, a skills and industrial strategy business, and is a member of the Sheffield City Region Skills board.

He was previously executive director of the UK Commission for Employment and Skills and director of performance at the Sector Skills Development Agency.

Mr Perryman said: “I am delighted to have been appointed as chair of governors and have been hugely impressed by everything I have seen at the college. The fact that the college is rated outstanding is down to everyone who studies, teaches, manages and supports its excellent work.

“I am confident that with strong leadership and governance the college is very well placed to manage any challenges that lie ahead. I am determined we will continue to do our very best for the people of Barnsley and the surrounding area.”

Ms Thirkell leaves the college board after eight years, in which she also served as vice chair.

“Throughout all of my time as a governor, vice chair and chair of Barnsley College, it has been my privilege to work alongside a very dedicated and highly skilled staff team and a dynamic and professional group of governors,” she said.

“The college has brought a visible difference to Barnsley town centre during this time.”

New vice chair Mr Jagger is chair of Ucas, recently became a member of the Association of Colleges’ regional board and is president of Barnsley and Rotherham Chamber of Commerce.

He said: “Having worked around the further and higher education sectors for many years, I am pleased to have become vice chair of the college’s board of governors.

“The college is a key player is delivering high quality education within Barnsley and I look forward to being part of that process.”

Mr Mansford is chief executive of Barnsley Football Club and has a varied legal background.

He said he would bring “energy and enthusiasm to the board along with my personal experiences of FE and higher education”.

“The success of younger people and everyone seeking to learn new skills is paramount to the growth of Barnsley and the surrounding areas,” he said.

“I will seek to do all I can to drive the college forward over the coming years.”

Barnsley College principal Chris Webb, who himself took up post in September, as previously reported by FE Week, said: “Their backgrounds and skill sets complement those of our existing board members who are all fully committed to supporting the senior management team and taking the college forward to the next level.”

Sixth form colleges’ academy VAT pass announcement comes as perfect leaving present

David Igoe will stand down as chief executive of the Sixth Form Colleges’ Association (SFCA) at the end of March. He told FE Week why he views Chancellor George Osborne’s decision to allow SFCs to become academies and gain VAT exemptions as the perfect leaving present.

It was really good news that Chancellor George Osborne announced on Wednesday (November 25) that Sixth Form Colleges will be able to apply to become Academies and gain the VAT exemption.

It is the culmination of a long campaign by the SFCA to persuade Ministers and the Treasury to give SFCs that option and end the anomaly of the VAT inequality.

These concessions were also on my personal wish list to achieve before I hang up my boots at the end of March 2016

Almost better news was the announcement that the rate would be protected for the life of this parliament and colleges could plan their futures without the spectre of further rate cuts hanging over them.

Given the limitations of the options open to the Department for Education, which will still have to find other savings, this is a significant victory for our campaign to expose the funding dip at key stage five (16-19) and the relative imbalance of funding across the phases.

Both decisions are a victory for the young people we educate, who can now have some prospect of a continuation of the excellent education SFCs provide.

If the Chancellor wanted to give us a Christmas present then he succeeded.

These concessions were also on my personal wish list to achieve before I hang up my boots at the end of March 2016.

I began my career in SFCs when we were a thriving segment of the schools system.

Incorporation in 1993 forced us into the FE world, but in recent months we have been campaigning for our sector to be both schools facing and, where sensible, to return to be an integral part of the schools provision in an area.

Becoming Academies is the start of that reality.

It is game-changing for area reviews which must now see SFCs, as not just another bit of the FE world, but as an integral part of multi-Academy trusts and the school/Academy system.

I think we have come home.

Young artist’s icons on show

A young artist’s painting of Nottingham’s best-known icons will be put on show at Nottingham City Council.

Internationally-renowned designer Paul Smith and literary greats DH Lawrence, Lord Byron and Alan Sillitoe all feature in 18-year-old Soniya Ahmed’s striking portrait, as well as Albert Ball, the First World War fighter pilot.

Soniya is studying a BTec extended diploma in art & design at Central College Nottingham.

Her painting was commended in the visual arts category of the Young Creative Awards earlier this year, and that is when her work was spotted by the council.

Soniya said: “I entered the awards as part of a college project and wanted to use some famous subjects, but also bring back to life those that maybe not everyone knows about.

“My previous college bought a piece of my artwork, but this is the first time that I’ve sold a piece of my artwork outside of college, so I’m really excited.

“It feels like I’m getting closer to my dream of becoming a famous artist.”

Pic: From left: Nigel Cooke, director of One Nottingham which organises the Young Creative Awards, with Soniya Ahmed and Mandi Chandler, curriculum manager for art & Design at Central College Nottingham

Will 19+ learners buy in to Chancellor George Osborne’s FE loans extension?

Chancellor George Osborne’s extension of the FE loans system from those aged 24 and above to the 19 to 23 age group was a source of uncertainty for government officials — but Mike Farmer explains how he sees it working out.

What do we already know about FE loans? The key message is that the budget is currently grossly (62 per cent) underspent.

I calculate that the scheme could take 125,000 more students receiving loans (at £2,000 a time) without exceeding the £400m allocated to it.

It’s unsurprising that the Chancellor has brought 19 to 23-year-olds into scope. My guess is this will happen next academic year

The scheme is tightly controlled by the Skills Funding Agency (SFA) which caps the fees for every single level three and four qualification. So plenty of scope to expand and modify the scheme without Chancellor George Osborne getting worried.

So where next? It’s unsurprising that the Chancellor has brought 19 to 23-year-olds into scope. My guess is this will happen next academic year. The funds are there and all the systems are in place. I’m also fairly optimistic about the impact on student participation.

Based on the November Statistical First Release I calculate that there are 65,000 to 70,000 19 to 23s (other than apprentices) taking level three and four qualifications. The evidence suggests that younger students are less loan-averse than older students, so a fairly high proportion of 19 to 23s are likely to take out loans.

There are bigger uncertainties around the proposed extension to higher levels. How many level five and six students there will be is much more speculative, and depends on a number of factors, including the speed with which the new National Colleges and Institutes of Technology get off the ground, and the qualifications that they (or awarding bodies) can develop.

There are questions too about where these additional students will come from. Clearly there will be competition with universities and other conventional higher education providers.

That is probably the reason for introducing FE maintenance loans for students of higher level skills, and a planned increase in the FE loans budget.

A gradual integration of the FE and higher education loans schemes looks on the cards and this can only be for the best. The FE scheme has suffered from inadequate publicity, and having a single scheme will help in this respect.

Also needed is a relaxation of the iron grip that the SFA has on FE loans. For example, although this would not be popular, a lifting of fees cap which it currently sets.

Since the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills has to cut 17 per cent of its administration costs, there are questions about whether the SFA will have the capacity to exercise its current control, or even whether it will survive to do it.