FE Week supplement review 2016

Over the course of this year FE Week produced a whopping 172 pages of content across 10 supplements covering all of the key sector talking points of 2016.

Ranging from the AAC, AoC and AELP conferences, to The Skills Show and EuroSkills, below we have brought all of our supplements into one place for our readers to recap on as we move into 2017.

March 11 – National Apprenticeship Week 2016

NAW-feat-image

National Apprenticeship Week, which this year ran from 14 – 18 March, seemed more pivotal than ever as we embarked on the final year of government-led funding before the levy is launch in April.

This 16-page supplement, sponsored by NCFE, gave us the opportunity to look at what lessons can be learned from the past to inform future decisions.

We therefore concentrated on providing historical context throughout this supplement dedicated to NAW 2016 — which covered the history of apprenticeships, key issues currently facing the sector, and beyond that to the “postmodern”.

March 30 – AAC 2016: Souvenir Supplement

AAC 2016 web banner

The FE Week Annual Apprenticeship Conference and Exhibition was once again an outstanding event for our sector.

The second ever AAC this year took place during the last three days of National Apprenticeship Week and offered an array of prominent key note speakers from top politicians, civil servants, providers, employers and most importantly apprentices. There were also over 45 in-depth practical workshops for delegates to attend.

This special 28-page souvenir supplement, sponsored by OCR, provides an overview of some of the highlights from AAC 2016 with content on hot topics such as the levy, apprenticeship funding reform, and the controversial as ever Sir Michael Wilshaw.

June 23 – Traineeships – Tracking progress

TRAINEESHIPS 2016 web banner

FE Week first produced supplement on traineeships in July 2013 as the programme got underway and thought three years on was the perfect time to revisit traineeships to take stock.

In this 16-page supplement, sponsored by OCR, we found that while some progress has been made, it is clear there are still questions and challenges around the policy.

June 29 – #AELP2016 Conference

FE-Week-Website-Banner-AELP-National-Conference-2016

Our fifth ever AELP conference supplement was produced onsite at the end of day one of this year’s conference in June.

With Brexit creating turbulence across Whitehall this was a key date in the FE calendar with scepticism around whether former skills minister Nick Boles would address the conference and if levy plans had been derailed.

Mr Boles thankfully did arrive on time and delivered some welcomed reassurance of the government’s commitments to apprenticeships.

This 16-page supplement, sponsored by OCR, delves deeper into the chatter among delegates and speakers following the monumental moment in British history.

July 14 – FE Week Festival of Skills 2016 Souvenir supplement

FoS-2016-web-banner

This year also marked the inaugural Festival of Skills at Capel Manor College, which FE Week was delighted to host.

This new event is a sister to The Telegraph Festival of Education which in its seventh year attracted over 5,000 festival-goers to Wellington College in June.

The Festival of Skills was an inspiring CPD extravaganza bringing together the best of the sector’s most forward thinking advocates, practitioners of change, policy makers and educators.

This 16-page souvenir supplement, sponsored by City & Guilds, shows the fantastic launch.

September 19 – Tech in FE

Tech supp web ban

In early September the Association for Learning Technology held its annual conference, giving us the perfect time to take a look at all things technology-related for the FE and skills sector.

On the 16 pages we look at some of the many ways that colleges and other providers are working together to create innovative tech solutions to the challenges facing the sector. This supplement was sponsored by Tribal.

November 3 – Area reviews: rebuild for resilience

area-review-2016-web-banner

It had been just over a year since the area reviews of post-16 launched, aiming to move towards “fewer, often larger, more resilient and efficient providers”.

Our reporter Jude Burke has followed the process all the way with great interest – from the first reports of lengthy delays during wave one, to the FE commissioner Sir David Collins’ promise to MPs this month that all reviews were on track to finish on time by next March.

In November many of the earlier reviews had reached the implementation phase – and the government had at last published its long-awaited implementation guidance – providing a good moment to focus on the work ahead for colleges.

Sponsored by the Learning Curve Group, this 16-page supplement reflects on the sweeping changes.

November 25 – AoC Annual Conference 2016

aoc-web-banner

The annual AoC conference was as anticipated as ever, this year bringing a feeling of renewed energy in the FE sector.

The AoC’s new chief executive David Hughes undoubtedly added to this feeling of revitalisation. He kicked off the conference on a positive note, and despite acknowledging the challenges brought by the recent “blizzard of changes”, reassured delegates in his speech that he has “a lot of hope”.

This 16-page supplement, sponsored by NOCN, includes everything on offer at the conference, including education secretary Justine Greening, skills minister Robert Halfon, new FE commissioner Richard Atkins, TV star Ruby Wax, among much more.

November 25 – The Skills Show 2016

skillsshow-supp-rolling-banner

While the policy focused AoC conference wrapped up in November, just down the road at Birmingham’s NEC The Skills Show kicked off its fifth annual event.

This was the chance for everyone to see policy put into action as the country’s best apprentices and learners battled in the national WorldSkills UK skills competitions.

There was also an abundance of careers advice from leading employers such as Dyson and Jaguar Land Rover on offer, as well as the chance to have a go at more than 50 different skills, and the opportunity to speak to past WorldSkills UK competitors.

This 16-page supplement, sponsored by Learning Curve Group, gives an insight into the country’s biggest careers event.

December 5 – EuroSkills 2016 | celebrating Team UK’s success

euroskills-supp-rolling-banner

We signed off our supplement haul for 2016 with a week in Gothenburg for EuroSkills 2016.

FE Week reporter Billy Camden has followed Team UK since they were announced in May, with the journey culminating in the European skills finals in Sweden.

Around 500 young people aged 18 to 25, from 28 different countries competed in 44 different skill areas from stonemasonry to hairdressing.

Team UK did themselves more than proud by taking home an impressive medal haul of two gold, one silver, and two bronze medals.

This 16-page supplement completed onsite in Sweden and sponsored by Smart Assessor, takes you from the start to finish of Team UK’s successful journey.

Top 10 FE Week online news stories in 2016

FE Week continues to bring you all the important news, analysis and comment, pressing the government on key unanswered questions and often being first to many of the most important developments.

In 2016 we’ve published a whopping 972 news stories, covering everything from the latest on apprenticeship reforms to the highs and lows of providers performance.

We have also profiled 16 of the sectors key figures, including apprenticeship champion of the year Neil Cain, Neil Carmichael, chair of the Education Select Committee, and Nadhim Zahawi, the former PM’s apprenticeship adviser.

FE Week has shared 209 expert opinions on the whirlwind of changes that 2016 has brought and also celebrated the weird and the wonderful among student experiences in our campus section.  

Finally, we have produced 10 supplements this year on a wide range of topics, such as traineeships, technology and EuroSkills 2016.

Check out our highest hitting stories from the year here:

Rank 1 – Exclusive: Principal’s salary doubles to over £330k

In March, exclusive FE Week analysis of Skills Funding Agency data revealed that the salary of Sunaina Mann, principal and chief executive officer of Nescot, had more than doubled from 2013/14 to 2014/15 – making her the highest paid college principal in England.

Her wage leapt from £150,000 for 2013/14 to £300,000 for 2014/15, the third year of Nescot’s involvement in the Saudi Arabian Colleges of Excellence programme.

FE Week also conducted an investigation into the colege’s involvement in Saudi Arabia, where it runs a female college in Jeddah.

Rank 2 – Ofsted boss tells MPs all 16 to 19-year-olds should be taught in schools

In March former chief inspector of Ofsted Sir Michael Wilshaw caused controversy by saying that all 16 to 19 year olds should be educated in schools, in an oral evidence session of the Education Committee.

During the parliamentary session he said that “16 to 19 should be done in school”, adding that for vulnerable learners the broad nature of FE institutions could mean they “get lost” and “drop out”.

In contrast, he said, schools coming together in groups made for a “really great opportunity” to deliver vocational education. Amongst these groups he included UTCs, which have seen a number of problems with recruitment this year.

Rank 3 – Department for Education taking over FE, skills and higher education

In July, following the government reshuffle that placed Justine Greening as the new education secretary, it was announced that the Department for Education would take over responsibility for FE, skills and higher education – previously handled by the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills.

Number 10 released a statement saying that “bringing these responsibilities together will mean that the government can take a comprehensive, end-to-end view of skills and education, supporting people from early years through to postgraduate study and work”.

Amongst the DfE’s new responsibilities would be “delivering more apprenticeships through a fundamental change in the UK’s approach to skills in the workplace”.

The change was received positively by the sector, with the Association of Employment and Learning Providers for example saying that having “apprenticeships and traineeships under one roof” could be “a very positive move”.

Rank 4 – Exeter College is the best college in the country, according to FE Week’s new league table

In November, exclusive FE Week research produced our first ever ranking table, which placed Exeter College top of the list.

The Ofsted ‘outstanding’ college had previously been led by the new FE commissioner Richard Atkins from 2002 until he retired in March this year, and scored full marks in the FE Week tables.

It was followed closely by Kendal College, Selby College and Eastleigh College.

The FE Week ratings were based on four measures: 2016/17 adult apprenticeships allocations as a percentage of all adult funding, employer and learner satisfaction scores, and destination data (specifically a college’s success at getting unemployed learners into work).

Rank 5 – Skills white paper to propose academic and vocational divide

May brought another exclusive from FE Week, after we gained access to a leaked report plan which detailed the developments that could be expected from a delayed skills white paper – the first of its kind in a decade.

FE Week revealed that the paper would separate academic and vocational provision, making 16 year olds choose between academic courses that set a path to university and 15 new ‘professional and technical routes’ in work.

The paper reflected the recommendations of an independent panel set up by the government to look into reforms to technical and professional education, which was led by Lord Sainsbury.

Rank 6 – Hotly anticipated apprenticeship levy funding update released

In August FE Week reported on the much anticipated information update from the government on the apprenticeship levy.  

The guidance revealed that nearly all employers would only have to contribute 10 per cent to the cost of an apprenticeship when the levy comes into play in April 2017.

It explained that the government would pay 90 per cent of the costs for the 98 per cent of employers with annual wage bills below £3m, who will not be paying the levy.

Other announcements in the release included a 10 per cent monthly top-up for levy paying employers, and details of a nee register of apprenticeship training providers.

Rank 7 – Apprentice minimum wage rate rising by 10 pence an hour

National Apprenticeship Week got off to a flying start back in March when business secretary Sajid Javid announced the national minimum wage rate for apprentices would increase from £3.30 to £3.40 from October 1.

On the first day of NAW, Mr Javid explained that the Low Pay Commission’s 2016 report made the recommendation for the apprenticeship increase, and the government would abide by all other recommendations on the National Minium Wage, including that the adult hourly national minimum wage rate for 21 to 24-year-olds should increase from £6.70 to £6.95.

Rank 8 – Exclusive: Cornwall College principal Amarjit Basi resigns

Back in July, FE Week was first to reveal that a college plagued with funding problems would part ways with their principal.

FE Week was exclusively sent a statement from Philip Rees, the chair of governors at Cornwall College, saying that principal Amarjit Basi had resigned.

Cornwall College’s funding troubles during Mr Basi’s tenure included receiving a notice of financial concern from the Skills Funding Agency, followed by the University and College Union calling on Mr Basi to take a pay cut to show solidarity with up to 60 staff set to lose their jobs through cutbacks at the college.

Mr Basi, who had been principal and chief executive of The Cornwall College Group since 2013, left his post on July 31.

Rank 9 – Choose academic or technical route at 16 – radical government plans reveal

Shockwaves were sent through the FE sector in July when former skills minister Nick Boles announced plans for a radical overhaul to the post-16 vocational qualification system by replacing 20,000 courses with “15 high-quality routes”, as FE Week had exclusively revealed two months before.

The release of the ‘Post-16 Skills Plan‘ coincided with Lord Sainsbury’s ‘Report of the Independent Panel on Technical Education’, which recommended each route has a ‘common core’ which will include English, maths and digital skills as well as a “specialisation towards a skilled occupation or set of occupations.”

The plans stated the government’s ambition for 16 year-olds to be take one of two choices: “the academic or the technical option”.

Rank 10 – Nescot College board learn husband to principal was paid £177,000

FE Week exclusively revealed in May that the husband of the highest-paid FE principal in the country – Sunaina Mann – was paid almost £200,000 in a contract that was not declared to college governors for 18 months.

FE Week had previously revealed that Ms Mann, the principal of North East Surrey College of Technology, received a salary of £363,000 in 2015 – more than double what she had earned the previous year.

We then found that her husband, Jaswinder Singh Mann, was also employed as a consultant by Nescot to work on its controversial partnership in Saudi Arabia, the Jeddah Female College.

The arrangement means that the couple gained £775,000 in total from Nescot over the course of two years.

2016 in FE Week cartoons – vote for your favourite

This year brought a wealth of interesting developments for FE Week to cover – from a new government to long-awaited details on apprenticeship reforms and the outcomes of a number of area reviews.

But none of this would have been the same without FE Week’s brilliant cartoonist Bill Houston to capture the key events, and we have gathered his work below for readers to review some of 2016’s top moments in FE.

Nick Boles featured most often in what turned out to be his final year as skills minster, making seven animated appearances. 

But he was soon succeeded by the new minister for apprenticeships and skills, Robert Halfon, who was so pleased with his first FE Week caricature that he requested a copy to hang in his office. 

Other FE figures who featured three times or more in cartoons this year included David Hughes, chief executive of the Association of Colleges, and his predecessor Martin Doel; Mark Dawe, chief executive of the Association of Employment and Learning Providers; former FE commissioner Sir David Collins; Peter Lauener, chief executive of the Skills Funding Agency and Education Funding Agency, and shadow chief executive of the Institute for Apprenticeships; and the prime minister herself, Theresa May.

Bill was also quick on the draw at the Association of Colleges conference this November, where he could be found meeting delegates and sketching dozens of familiar sector faces (pictured above).

And FE Week’s December portrayal of a magical Sir Michael Wilshaw, his third and final appearance in the paper this year before retiring from his role as Ofsted’s chief inspector, even made it onto a delicious cake to celebrate his time in office. 

Scroll to the bottom of the article to cast your vote. 

Rediscover our year in cartoons here:

159
Edition 159, January 11 – College resorts to £700k from local council
cartoon-160-web
Edition 160, January 18 – Sector figures gather for Learning and Work Institute launch
FE-21-01-art-161-Cartoon-editedweb
Edition 161, January 25 – Policy Consortium letter challenges Wilshaw over ‘inadequate at best’ claim
Edition-162-cartoonweb
Edition 162, February 1 – NUS launches campaign to hear FE students’ views
FE-Week-163-art-cartoonweb
Edition 163, February 8 – Cost of college bailouts as high as £100m
FE-Week-164-cartoonweb
Edition 164, February 22 – Frustration over ‘misleading’ Libor answer
Cartoon-165w
Edition 165, February 29 – Brexit possibility raises skills funding questions *By Stan Dupp
FE-Week-166-cartoonweb
Edition 166, March 7 – Struggling London college in talks with Newcastle group
Cartoon-E167web
Edition 167, March 14 – Boles weighs in — Sir Michael ‘disagrees with himself’
FE-169-artweb
Edition 169, April 11 – Agency under fire for refusing to list changes to quals
170-art
Edition 170, April 18 – Colleges agree ‘hub and spoke’ London proposal could work
fe171-art
Edition 171, April 25 – DfE accounts late and lack ‘truth and fairness’
E172-cartoon
Edition 172, May 2 – Ofsted drops probe into ‘brave’ inspector
FE173-cartooncopy
Edition 173, May 9 – Sector leaders left ‘outside the tent’ on reforms
FE-174-art
Edition 174, May 16 – Revised accounts show principal annual pay packet of £358,000
FE175-gove-cartoon
Edition 175, May 23 – Here we Gove again: Now we’re getting academies for prisons
Edition 176
Edition 176, June 6 – Employers told to stick to ‘core business’ after Citroën blow
FE177-art
Edition 177, June 13 – Sir David Collins to step down before area reviews complete
FE178-cartoon-web
Edition 178, June 20 – Osborne’s Brexit budget warns of £1.15bn cuts in education spending
FE179cartoon
Edition 179, June 27 – AELP boss accuses government of distorting market against ITPs
FE180-cartoon-wp
Edition 180, July 4 – Education ministers back Gove on road to Number 10
Edition 181, September 12 – Halfon should ask the Treasury to hand back the savings and fully fund younger apprentices
Edition 182, September 19 – Motor Industry boss gives both barrels to PM over funding cuts
Edition 183, September 26 – New FE commissioner revealed, and there are two
Edition 184, October 3 – It’s a CEO hat-trick for Peter Lauener as he takes on the IfA
Edition 185, October 10 – Conservatives talk big on skills agenda ahead of Budget
Edition 188, November 7 – Lammy accuses Halfon of hoodwinking parliament on funding cuts
Edition 187, October 17 – Lead officials given grilling by Public Accounts Commitee
Edition 189, November 14 – AoC and AELP bosses battle over independent provider quality
Edition 190, November 21 – Guess the FE cartoons!
Edition 191, November 28 – Gloomy Brexit forecast means projected levy pot will fall by £200m
Edition 192, December 5 – Wilshaw contradicts own report with ‘personal’ english and maths attack
Edition 193, December 12 – ‘Incredibly unfair’ funding quirk riles colleges

[socialpoll id=”2410062″ path=”/polls/2410062″ fif=”false” width=”500″]

Marsden ‘very disappointed’ as assurances on IfA announcements fail to deliver

Delays to the release of key details about the Institute for Apprenticeships are “very disappointing” evidence of a “haphazard” approach from the government, shadow skills minister Gordon Marsden has said.

In a Public Bill Committee hearing on November 22, Peter Lauener, shadowlauener-and-collier2 chief executive of the IfA (pictured right), suggested to Mr Marsden that information – including a draft of the government’s strategic guidance for the institute, an operational plan and the successful candidates for posts at the institute – would be revealed before Christmas.

But a ‘Trailblazer Times’ newsletter, sent by the Department for Education to apprenticeship employer groups today (December 22), has confirmed that these important points will now be delayed until “early in the New Year”.

The newsletter, which was signed by Carl Cresswell, deputy director for apprenticeships at the DfE, said that the department will be consulting on a draft of the government’s strategic guidance for the institute and an operational plan will be launched for public consultation in January.

This plan will “set out further detail on the role of the institute, including proposals for how it will deliver its functions; and key objectives for its first year of operation and up to 2020”.

The IfA’s board members, chosen from 300 applicants, will also be announced next month.

Speaking in November, Mr Lauener told Mr Marsden: “The process for appointing members of the institute is substantially complete … I would be surprised if there was not an announcement before Christmas.

“Incidentally, we are also planning to publish for consultation the Government’s remit letter in draft to the institute, and I would also expect, again before Christmas, a draft of the institute’s first strategic plan.”

Mr Marsden told FE Week today that the delayed release of information about the IfA was frustrating for the progress of the Technical and Further Education Bill through Parliament, as it sets out the government’s proposals to expand the role of the institute in April 2018 to include college-based technical education.

He said: “It’s very disappointing that the department has failed to deliver any of the assurances that Peter Lauener gave the bill committee in parliament last November that we would have an announcement about the new institute’s membership, its remit, and its strategic plan.

“This is not good for a proper and thoughtful discussion with employers and stakeholders, which will now have to come later in January with a very tight timetable for the implementation of the institute, and with the bill itself coming back for final decision in the commons straight new year.”

He added: “It’s rather symptomatic of the haphazard way in which the government has been dealing with the institute all along.”

FE Week had previously asked the DfE for details on the release date of new information about the IfA, but had not received a response or any comment at the time of publication.

It is not the first time Mr Marsden has been left waiting for answers about the IfA -in November he told FE Week the government’s handling of the institute was “shambolic”, after it evaded a series of parliamentary enquiries about its capacity.

Despite the tight timeframe and the IfA’s new responsibilities, Mr Marsden was told that the government was “not yet able to set out initial staff numbers”, because the “detailed structure” of the IfA was still in development.

At the time he said it was “absolutely pressing” that plans were finalised.

The Trailblazer Times newsletter also announced that the department will now be asking bidders who want to introduce new apprenticeship standards to explain which of the 15 technical education routes outlined in the recent Skills Plan their proposal aligns to.

It said: “Over time, occupational maps will be become available for each of the 15 routes.

“As and when they become available we will ask bidders to specify which occupations within the route map their proposed standard covers.”

Mark Dawe, chief executive of the Association of Employment and Learning Providers, responded to this, saying: “When Sainsbury was published, we highlighted that 57 per cent of jobs in our economy are outside the review recommendations’ scope, so we are in danger of creating an elitist system that would deny many young people a work based learning route to level two or three. 

“What are employers on the trailblazers in areas such as retail supposed to do if their sector doesn’t fit into one of the 15 routes?  Will their standard get rejected?”

He added: “AELP has been saying that putting apprenticeships and technical education under the same IfA roof is going to throw up some big challenges that only can only be overcome if we see proper joined-up policymaking. 

“This newsletter suggests that we have some way to go towards achieving this and it underlines why we really need a pause on the whole standards and end-point assessment process.”

 

EFA announces no change to 16-18 funding rates

The Education Funding Agency has announced that the national base funding rates of £4,000 per full time student aged 16 to 17 and £3,300 for 18 year olds will remain unchanged for the academic year 2017 to 2018.

The update will come as a disappointment to the Association of Colleges, which has been lobbying the government to increase the funding rate.

In its Autumn Statement Submission in October the AoC published 20 recommendations, with the funding rate third on its list.

It said: “The national base rate for 16 and 17-year-olds (currently £4,000) should be increased so that it provides the necessary funds for high-quality education.”

But in today’s (December 21) letter from the EFA to providers, Peter Mucklow, national director for young people, wrote: “The national base rates of £4,000 per full time student aged 16 to 17 and £3,300 for 18 year olds are maintained for academic year 2017 to 2018 as are the part time funding rates.

“This is in line with the commitment made in the 2015 Spending Review.”

The letter also covered traineeships. Mr Mucklow wrote: “We will continue to ensure that funding supports institutions growing traineeship numbers.

“If you have exceptional growth in traineeships in academic year 2016 to 2017, please submit a business case using our online enquiry form after the R06 data window closes. We will then review cases in March 2017 and inform you of the result in April 2017.”

He added: “We will confirm the deadline and criteria for business cases in late January 2017 via our e-bulletin.”

A spokesperson for the Association of Employment and Learning Providers said: ‘It’s good to see the EFA’s commitment to support growth in traineeships. 

“However we have said to ministers that the whole funding system for the programme needs review because growth has generally been modest. 

“Uncertainty surrounding the programme’s long-term future with devolution on the horizon is also holding back provider investment in it.”

In addressing high needs funding, Mr Mucklow announced that the EFA is “proposing to introduce a new national formula for distributing high needs funding to local authorities”.
 
He wrote: “The department launched a second consultation on the high needs national funding formula on 14 December. Please feel free to
respond to this new consultation, which runs until 22 March 2017.”
 
Other areas covered in the letter included: formula protection funding, maths and English, student support (including free meals), lagged student numbers, 19+ continuing students, disadvantage block 2, and the allocations process and timeline.

Mr Mucklow also confirmed that the EFA will be moving forward with plans to phase out Formula Protection Funding, with 2020/21 the final year it is payable.

Scotland to spend less than half their levy funding on apprenticeships

The Scottish government has announced that its use of the apprenticeships levy will be more flexible than in England, funding a “range of employment measures”.

Less than half of Scotland’s estimated £221m levy funding in 2017-18 will be used for apprenticeships, with the rest to be spent on a range of workforce development and pre-employment support programmes.

In contrast, the share of the levy funding for England, which will reach close to £2.5bn by 2019-20, is all ring-fenced for funding apprentices employees working for the majority of their time in England.

This broader approach from the Scottish government may frustrate employers in England.

Carolyn Fairbairn, director-general of the Confederation of British Industry, expressed concerns about this restricted use of the funds in a speech on April 28, saying: “When it comes to training – business knows best.  

“They should have the flexibility to choose the kind of training which is right for them, whether it’s labelled an ‘apprenticeship’ or not.

“Other levy systems in Ireland, Germany, Denmark, France and Quebec, give greater flexibility on spend than the UK Government is proposing. So it can be done – and this is how our levy should work too.”

The apprenticeship levy will come into play in April 2017, meaning larger employers pay 0.5 per cent of their annual wage bill above £3m directly to the HMRC.

A spokesperson for the Association of Employment and Learning Providers questioned the strategy, saying: “We have to recognise that the Scottish government’s decision not to ring-fence its share of the levy for apprenticeships only has been taken after a consultation, although we are aware that there are employers north of the border who aren’t happy about this. 

“It surely wouldn’t be in the Scottish economy’s interests if these employers started shifting their apprenticeship training into England as some are warning.”

Commenting on Scotland’s approach, Jamie Hepburn MSP, minister for employability and training, said: “We will use the apprenticeship levy to give the workplace more options and flexibility.

“While we will boost modern apprenticeships we will also address skills gaps and the training needs of existing employees where a full apprenticeship might not be appropriate.”

He added: “We have responded to the needs of employers by announcing an approach that is much broader than is currently proposed in England, and that will support skills, training and employment.”

In guidance released in August, the Welsh government proposed a similar approach to the Scottish use of the apprenticeship levy, though said the decision was a work in progress.

 The document stated: “We are working with the UK Government and the other devolved administrations to resolve a range of cross border issues.   

“We recognise that there is a need to maintain flexibility to enable employers to choose whatever training is best for their business.

“The issues are complex and need to be properly considered. They are likely to take some time to progress.”

Here’s how Scotland plan to spend their levy:

scotland-levy-table-1

 

 

Public Accounts Committee warning over ‘high risk’ devolution plans

“High risk” devolution plans giving local enterprise partnerships widespread adult education budget spending powers must be subjected to far more stringent scrutiny, a new Public Accounts Committee report has warned.

The document was unveiled this morning, with committee chair Meg Hillier (pictured) insisting “every pound of public money” spent by LEPs and other relevant local bodies “must be a pound parliament can trace”.

It comes after an investigation published by the Mail Online alleged that LEPs had made more than 270 payments to companies, or other projects, connected with their own board members, with sums for example ranging from £13,000 to £1 million.

Question marks over accountability matter deeply to FE, with LEPs already in control much of the funds available to providers for capital spending – and last month’s autumn statement confirmed that the government is pushing ahead with plans to devolve the AEB.

The findings prompted Mark Dawe, chief executive of the Association of Employment and Learning Providers, to hit out at “a system set up in a manner that leads to institutional bias”.

The new PAC report has raised further concerns about scrutiny, transparency and accountability, stressing that “taxpayers must be able to understand who is spending their money, how that money is allocated and where responsibility lies if the system fails to deliver good value or things go wrong”.

A spokesperson stressed: “This includes the ‘opaque’ nature of accountability for the activities of LEPs – designed to bring together the public and private sector – which are now negotiating local growth deals funded by a £12 billion fund over a five-year period”.

Ms Hillier complained today that the message coming from government was that combined authorities had signed up for devolution and “it’s over to them – full stop”.

But she said: “This high-risk strategy is squarely in the sights of our committee. Our concerns are not addressed to the policy of devolution but rather the risks inherent in its implementation.

“Every pound of public money spent by an elected mayor, LEP or other body must be a pound parliament can trace. Spending must face robust scrutiny.”

A LEP-funded report published in October by Metro-Dynamics, called ‘Leading the way’, previously came out in support of greater transparency.

It said: “LEPs need to continue to ensure that they are known for having the best possible approach to transparency and governance in terms of decision-making and spending.”

The chairman of the Greater Cambridge Greater Peterborough Enterprise Partnership, Mark Reeve, told FE Week on behalf of the LEP Network Board, that “all LEPs take any allegations of improper conduct extremely seriously”.

“LEPs continuously seek ways to improve transparency and share best practice,” he said.

“It is not the role of the LEP Network to monitor how LEPs allocate grant funding or assess conflicts of interest.

“The government has clearly vested that role in the democratically elected councils who are accountable for monitoring conflicts of interest and ensuring how grant funding is awarded by the LEPs.”

A government spokesperson said: “Our rules make clear the need for a published conflicts of interest policy and insist upon transparency in the way taxpayers’ money is spent.

“We won’t hesitate to act if any LEPs are found to have failed to follow our rules.”

Ofsted criticises ‘financial mismanagement’ at college preparing to join with university

Governors have been criticised for being slow to recognise “financial mismanagement” at Lambeth College, in new report unveiled by Oftsed.

The grade three across the board report, published by the inspectorate today, recognised that “clearer and firmer arrangements” had recently been put in place to ensure governors’ “oversight of the college’s corporate functions”.

But it warned: “In the last academic year, governors were slow to recognise key indicators of financial mismanagement at the college.”

A spokesperson for the provider, which had over 6,000 learners at the time of the inspection, told FE Week today: “The governors and senior managers accept the findings of the Ofsted inspection and are pleased to have had the opportunity to demonstrate that errors made in the past are not being repeated in the present.”

The report comes three days after Lambeth announced it was pushing ahead with plans to join forces with London South Bank University.

“Following the recommendations of the government area review of post-16 education for central London, Lambeth College is delighted with the decision…to join the London South Bank University family in principle and subject to the development of a full business case,” a spokesperson said.

Minutes from a meeting of the college corporation held in July indicated problems.

“The 2015/16 deficit forecast brought to the board on March 10, 2016, had been at £500k, but had now gone up to £5.6 million,” it said.

FE Week subsequently asked the Department for Education if the Skills Funding Agency had bailed out the college.

A spokesperson for the agency said in response that “exceptional financial support” had been provided.

The LSBU family consists of the university, UTC and academy, together with a company called South Bank University Enterprises Ltd.

The college, which was allocated just over £11m from the adult education budget for 2016/17 as of September, said joining the group would offer it operational stability, while also helping to build clear learning pathways for students.

FE Week asked a spokesperson if the move would mean Lambeth would no longer be an independent corporation.

She said in response: “The exact structure of the college within the LSBU family is not yet decided upon.”

Mary McCormack, chair of governors, said: “We are confident this exciting and innovative partnership will broaden and increase the opportunities for Lambeth College students to progress from FE into higher level apprenticeships, higher education and employment.”

Professor David Phoenix, vice-chancellor at LSBU, added: “Post-16 education is a critical part of the fabric of our society and employers are calling for a more highly educated and skilled workforce.

“Welcoming Lambeth College into this exciting and innovative model with the LSBU family is an excellent opportunity to enhance the provision of FE across south London.”

It comes after FE Week reported in November that Lewisham Southwark College, which last year became the first college ever to receive two ‘inadequate’ ratings from Ofsted in a row, had explored a number of what it called “potential options” to improve in the wake of the London (central) area review, according to a spokesperson.

Options under consideration included separate mergers with two nearby institutions: London South Bank University and Lambeth College.

Both options were deemed unviable by the bosses at Lewisham. The college said at the time it was instead revisiting its “preferred” proposal – of merging with Newcastle College Group, based in the north-east of England.

Find out which organisations can assess the most apprenticeship standards

A big three familiar names dominate the updated list of 33 approved assessment organisations – taking responsibility for end point assessments with almost a third of new apprenticeship standards.

City and Guilds tops the list, having signed-up to assess 18, followed by Pearson Education with 16, and NOCN with 11, according to the updated register published by the Skills Funding Agency this morning.

It means they are together responsible for assessments with 45 out of a total of 153 standards cleared by the agency as ready for delivery.

 

Edwina McQueen, director of apprenticeships at City & Guilds, said: “City & Guilds has made a significant investment in developing end-point assessments to date as we know that they are an essential part of creating a high quality and efficient apprenticeship system in the UK.

“We have already developed end-point assessments for 18 occupations, more than any other awarding organisation, and have many more in the pipeline which will be released next year, including customer service and digital.”

She added: “Developing end-point assessment for each occupation requires a significant investment in creating assessment instruments and in developing the right support systems.

“At City & Guilds we have been planning this for some time and have a plan in place which includes assessment of existing published occupations and a strong focus on the needs of the future marketplace.” 

Courses to be assessed by City and Guilds include for golf greenkeepers and property maintenance operatives at level two, and level four software developer.

City and Guilds has also developed end-point assessment for some occupations that are not yet out for tender. 

Pearson covered standards including dental laboratory assistant, motor vehicle service and maintenance technician (light vehicle), and water process technician, all at level three.

A spokesperson for Pearson said: “We welcome the opportunity to continue to apply to the register and are reviewing each standard on a case by case basis. 

“We are committed to ensuring that our end-point assessments deliver high quality apprenticeships.”

NOCN has approval to assess standards, for example covering adult care workers, and financial services customer adviser at level two, science manufacturing technician at level three.

Graham Hasting-Evans, managing director of NOCN, told FE Week: “We have [actually] been successfully appointed to deliver 14 end-point assessments in seven sectors [because the portal is not yet fully updated] making us third in the national league.

“We have worked towards this for the last four years, being fully committed financially and operationally.

“We have systems and staff now in place and we are ready to deliver, that is why we’re featuring so heavily in the AAO list – we’re here because we can do the job, plain and simple.”

It comes as FE Week revealed today (December 15) that under half of apprenticeship standards approved for delivery still have no approved assessment organisation, according to exclusive analysis of new data, despite recent assurance by SFA boss Peter Lauener and apprenticeships and skills minister Robert Halfon.